Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Time For Rational Law On Mad Defence

The Claude Gabriel case highlights the need for an end to the extreme difference between the way we treat `bad' killings and `mad' killings, ACT Justice Spokesman MP Stephen Franks said today.

"We should urgently provide for a verdict of guilty but insane.

"Huge resources are poured into lawyers and competing `experts' arguing the difference, when the outcomes for the community and the killer are, or should be, much the same.

"Since the abolition of the death penalty, the social value of legal exploitation of the insanity defence has been dubious. Now the treatment of murder in Mr Goff's Sentencing and Parole Reform Bill makes absurd any substantial waste of legal resources on the distinction between mad and bad. "Life imprisonment" can now mean anything, except life in prison. The Bill means that a mad killer is likely to be locked up for longer than a killer who attracts the Court's sympathy. The current 10-year minimum sentence for murder is abolished.

"A guilty but insane verdict would only affect the kind of institution the killer goes to. Insane killers should not be in prison. But they should be in custody. It may not make an enormous difference. Just as murderers are always at least theoretically subject to recall to complete a life sentence, so should a mad killer be kept locked up or constantly subject to recall, at any time there is any concern about the safety of others.

"ACT raised this simple change during the select committee process. I objected to the deceit in continuing to use the term "life imprisonment" when it can mean anything from one year to 17 years.

"It is still not too late for the government to amend this bill to make sure that in New Zealand at least the outrage of cases like that of Claude Gabriel, cannot happen again. We can save most of the enormous legal aid waste on having judges agonise over the difference between mad and bad," Mr Franks said.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Bridges’ ‘Meth Crooks’ Leadership Failure

Back in June, Bridges publicly accepted that Housing NZ had got it wrong, and that the National government had acted upon bad advice.

Now, you’d think this admission would create a broad bi-partisan basis for compensation to those families who had been unfairly evicted, at considerable cost and emotional distress. Some people had lost their possessions in trying to meet the expense of the upheaval.

Not everyone felt so compassionate. More>>


Multimedia & Transcript: Acting PM's Press Conference

Winston Peters, Acting Prime Minister while Jacinda Ardern is in New York for the UN Leaders' Week, held a short press conference Monday after chairing this week's cabinet meeting. More>>

General Assembly: Ardern Rejects Trump Call For War On Drugs

New Zealand will not be signing the United States' document calling for global action on the war on drugs, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says. Ms Ardern is in New York for the United Nations General Assembly this week, along with about 140 other world leaders. More>>


Pay Equity: Cabinet Funds Deal For Oranga Tamariki Social Workers

The Minister said that an agreement in principle has been reached between Oranga Tamariki and the PSA on a settlement worth $114.6m over five years. More>>


Hunting v Pest Control: Tahr Control Needed To Protect Alpine Habitats

A cull of introduced Himalayan tahr browsing conservation land in Kā Tiritiri o Te Moana/ the Southern Alps is needed to protect special alpine plants and their habitats, Conservation Minister, Eugenie Sage said. More>>


Protest At Sea: Judge Discharges Greenpeace Activists

The judge today discharged Norman and Howell without conviction, saying the cumulative consequences of a conviction would be out of proportion to what was “low level” offending off the Wairarapa coast in April 2017. More>>


No Reshuffle: Meka Whaitiri Removed As A Minister

Meka Whaitiri will be removed as a Minister with immediate effect... The decision was made after receiving a report into an incident that occurred on 27 August in Gisborne, involving Meka Whaitiri and one of her staff. More>>





InfoPages News Channels