Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

De Facto Decisions Review Background

30 August 2002

Work And Income Offers To Review

De Facto (Marriage-Type) Decisions

Background Information

Timeline

1. In October 1996, the Court of Appeal set a new test for determining whether a relationship is a “relationship in the nature of a marriage’ in terms of section 63 (b) of the Social Security Act 1964. Details of the case that led to the new test are outlined on the next page.

2. In 1997, the National Government introduced legislation (the Conjugal Status Bill) so that the Court of Appeal ruling would be overturned retrospectively. The bill was never passed.

3. In September 2000, Associate Social Services and Employment Minister Ruth Dyson commissioned Auckland lawyer Frances Joychild to prepare an independent report on whether Work and Income (formerly Income Support) was applying the correct legal test for relationships “in the nature of a marriage’ (de facto relationships) as defined by the Court of Appeal in 1996.

4. On 13 March 2002, Ruth Dyson released Ms Joychild’s report. It concluded that Work and Income did not consistently apply the correct legal test for de facto relationships between 1 November 1996 and 31 December 2000, and made a number of recommendations. The principal recommendation was that all relevant cases during that time period should be reviewed.

5. On 13 March 2002, Ms Dyson also released the Ministry of Social Development’s response to the Joychild report. The ministry said it agreed with most of Ms Joychild’s recommendations and was working to implement them. It said further work needed to be done before a decision could be made as to whether all relevant cases between 1 November 1996 and 31 December 2000 should be reviewed. Both Ms Joychild’s report and MSD’s response are available on www.msd.govt.nz

6. On 30 August 2002, Ruth Dyson announced that the Ministry of Social Development would offer to review all relevant cases between 1 November 1996 and 31 December 2000, where people’s benefits were stopped and/or they had to pay back money because they were deemed to be living in a de facto relationship. Cases that had already been prosecuted in a district court or considered by the Social Security Appeal Authority would not be eligible.

WORK AND INCOME REVIEW: BACKGROUND INFORMATION (CONTINUED)

1996 Court of Appeal case

Miss R lived with Mr T for about 18 years, from 1974 to 1992. They never married. The relationship was characterised by severe violence.

Miss R had a child to Mr T in 1977. Mr T never provided financial support for her or their child. He gave little or no assistance with domestic duties and took little part in looking after their child.

Between 1977 and 1992, Miss R received various welfare benefits.

Following an anonymous tip-off, Work the Income investigated Miss R’s case and referred it to the district court for prosecution, on the grounds that she had failed to disclose her relationship with Mr T. She was convicted, her benefit was cancelled and the court directed her to pay back $44,759.93.

Miss R unsuccessfully appealed to the High Court. She then appealed to the Court of Appeal.

In 1996, the Court of Appeal found that, in order for a relationship to be “in the nature of a marriage’, two essential features must be present:

- a degree of companionship demonstrating an emotional commitment, and

- financial interdependence.

The court also found that the effect of violence in a relationship must be taken into account when assessing these features.

In Miss R’s case, the Court of Appeal found that there was no financial interdependence because Mr T had not provided any financial support and, further, that the violence and other forms of control exerted by Mr T meant that the required emotional commitment was not present.

The Court of Appeal allowed Miss R’s appeal and quashed her convictions.


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Another Reason To Loathe HR Departments (And On The Teachers Strike)

This morning’s news item about Police emergency call centre staff turning up for work while they’re sick – because they’re afraid their sick leave statistics will be used against them, and their jobs put in jeopardy – is not an isolated case...

Obviously, sick people shouldn’t be being treated by doctors and nurses who are themselves sick and potentially infectious. Similarly, Police emergency calls also need to be fielded by people who’re feeling alert, and on top of their game. More>>

 
 

MPs' Computers To Be Searched: Inquiry Into Leak On Simon Bridges' Expenses

An inquiry has been launched to find out who leaked the National Party's expenses to the media... Parliament's speaker, Trevor Mallard, said a Queen's Counsel would lead the inquiry with the help of an employment lawyer and also someone with forensic IT skills. More>>

ALSO:

Teachers Strike: Nationwide Rallies And Marches

Teachers and principals voted for a full day strike to be held on 15 August to send a strong message to the Government that the current collective agreement offers from the Ministry of Education would not fix the crisis in teaching. More>>

ALSO:

Wellington.Scoop: City Council Ends Its Support For Jackson’s Movie Museum

The Wellington City Council and the Movie Museum Limited have today announced a mutually-agreed parting of the ways for a joint project between the Council’s Convention Centre and TMML’s Movie Museum... Both parties remain optimistic for the future of their respective projects. More>>

Pay Equity: Historic Settlement For Education Support Workers

The New Zealand Educational Institute (NZEI) and the Ministry of Education today signed Terms of Settlement to address a pay equity claim for 329 support workers who work with very young children in early childhood and primary schools. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Stereotypes About Jacinda Ardern

Routinely, female politicians get depicted as either show ponies or battle axes, with little room for anything else in between. .. More>>

Weekend Interviews: "Discriminatory And Racist" Aussie Deportations

The former president of Australia’s Human Rights Commission Gillian Triggs says deportations have risen dramatically in Australia since 2014 when ministers and ministerial delegates were given the power to cancel visas - and half of those being deported are New Zealanders. "These are massive numbers, actually escalating dramatically."... More>>

ALSO:

Legal Challenge: Prisoner Has 9 Boxes Of Documents Seized

Human rights organisation People Against Prisons Aotearoa says a prisoner they advocate for has had 9 boxes of legal documents seized from him just days before his case against the Department of Corrections was to be heard. More>>

Single-Use Plastic Bags: Govt To Phase Them Out

Single-use plastic shopping bags will be phased out over the next year, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern and Associate Environment Minister Eugenie Sage announced today. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages