Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Dunne on the Duynhoven case

Dunne on the Duynhoven case

United Future leader, Peter Dunne, says there's a major hurdle to overcome before his party's eight MP's can vote in favour of the law that will allow Labour MP Harry Duynhoven to remain an MP despite his applying to renew his Dutch citizenship.

Mr Dunne told Parliament, which is considering the legislation under urgency, "This is not a simple case of an MP breaking the law and Parliament fixing it in a way that might not happen in other circumstances.

"By every admission, the provisions Mr Duynhoven breached are ancient and obscure. Moreover, it is widely conceded that he did not deliberately seek to breach the law, although I readily accept the maxim that ignorance of the law is no excuse.

"It is clear that the provisions in the Electoral Act were crafted at a time when the world was a vastly different place.

"In the 1850s when the world was essentially divided between the British Empire and hostile Europe, the issue of allegiance to foreign powers was a very real one. Even as late as World War Two, as the detention of alien nationals in our country shows, the issue was still extremely relevant, and understandably so.

Mr Dunne said today, "Indeed, it could be argued that there are certain powers today - the so-called Axis of Evil, for example - where the same could be held to apply, and where we would be properly concerned to have MPs declaring various forms of allegiance.

"However, none of this applies in Mr Duynhoven's case. New Zealand has long enjoyed the closest of relations with the Netherlands and there has never been a suggestion that any action of allegiance by an individual to the Netherlands poses any threat to New Zealand's security or national integrity.

"That raises the question: Is banishing Mr Duynhoven from Parliament a reasonable response? He has committed no crime, and would be eligible to stand again for Parliament immediately, without any penalty.

"While relevant in a general sense only, issues relating to the cost and practicality of a by-election are not in my mind critical to the question of whether Mr Duynhoven should be disqualified.

"There is a general legal principle in favour of retrospective validation of actions where such validation is beneficial either to the individual or to the group concerned.

"Parliament regularly passes validation Bills to cover the actions of local authorities and others caught in similar situations, for example.

"The issue here is essentially whether in Gilbert and Sullivan's famous phrase, "the punishment fits the crime."

"I do not think that Mr Duynhoven's disqualification would be a reasonable "punishment" in this case, especially since he would be immediately eligible to stand again for Parliament.

"At the same time, I do not think it reasonable to create a situation whereby any other MP can now with impunity for the balance of this Parliament at least apply for dual citizenship, or nationality, and not be held to account the way Mr Duynhoven has been.

"In common parlance, the law in this instance has clearly become an ass, and it is unreasonable to penalise Mr Duynhoven by it.

"Therefore, I favour a limited amendment to the law to validate Mr Duynhoven's election, pending a thorough review of the provisions in question. If there are other MPs who may have been caught in a similar way to Mr Duynhoven, but who have chosen to remain silent and let him take the rap, as it were, I do not believe they deserve the ongoing protection of the law.

"Therefore, should other cases subsequently come to light it is my strong view that any such MPs who have stayed silent now should not enjoy the protection of the law in the future.

"I intend moving an amendment to that effect in the committee stages of the Bill and the fate of that amendment will have a powerful effect on how United Future votes in the final instance," said Mr Dunne.

He said it was pertinent to note that the case of National's Dr Nick Smith had been raised in the context of the government legislating to protect its own MP only.

"I believe Parliament should act to protect Dr Smith from being prosecuted by the Solicitor-General for alleged contempt of court, since he was doing the jobs all MP's must do and that is to advocate on behalf of their constituents," he said.

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Whether Trump Is Likely To Be Impeached

'Tis the season to be jolly, and for wrapping a plea bargain under the Christmas tree for all ye formerly merry, Trump-connected gentlemen.

Reportedly, Michael Cohen, Paul Manafort and Michael Flynn have all been co-operating with the probe led by special counsel Robert Mueller.

Flynn has done 19 interviews so far. So what chance has the Trump presidency got of surviving, all things considered? More>>


Dealing Crackdown, Addiction Support: Government Action On Synthetics

The NZ Drug Foundation has welcomed the Government’s response to synthetic drug deaths. The response strikes a balance between giving law enforcement the tools they need to target criminal networks and changing drug law to make it easier for people to access help when they need it. More>>


Strategy Committee Unanimous: Wellington To Forge Ahead With Convention Centre

The three-storey Cable Street building, with around 18,000-square metres of floor space, will comfortably be able to host 1500 people for conventions. It includes a 1651sq m exhibition area that will attract international exhibitions too big for nearby Te Papa and provide an always-changing visitor attraction. More>>


Surveying The Surveillance: First IGIS Review Of Warrants Under New Act

The report sets out the Inspector-General’s interpretation of the new warrant provisions under the ISA and her expectations of the GCSB and NZSIS when they prepare warrant applications. More>>

SSC: 2018 Public Service Workforce Data Published

State Services Commissioner Peter Hughes has published the 2018 Our People, Public Service Workforce Data , which shows the Public Service is making significant progress in important areas. More>>


Sinking Cap: Auctions, Permanent Forests, Added To ETS

The move to auctions, signalled in an August consultation paper, will help put a cap on the number of emission units available over time. Annual announcements, looking forward five years, will help provide certainty for scheme participants, she said. More>>


Joint Select Committee Report: Achieving Smokefree 2025

In a historic first for select committees, the Māori Affairs Committee and the Health Committee presented their joint report on achieving the Smokefree 2025 goal to the House on Tuesday, 11 December 2018. More>>

"Shared Interests And Democratic Values": Peters To Visit USA

Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters will travel to Washington D.C. for talks with US Secretary of State Michael R. Pompeo and other senior members of the US Administration. More>>




InfoPages News Channels