Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Documentary makes valid point on evidence flaws

Smith: Documentary makes valid point on evidence flaws

United Future justice spokesman Murray Smith today agreed with the makers of the documentary on convicted double murderer John Barlow that there are inadequacies in the evidence given in criminal trials and wants greater disclosure on the part of the police.

Trial by Ordeal screened on TV One last night.

Mr Smith said that while he personally had no doubts about Barlow's guilt (he changed his story every time the police found fresh evidence), the trial pointed to deficiencies in the production of evidence on the part of both the police and Barlow.

At present the discovery process (whereby defence counsel get access to the police case research) requires defence lawyers to guess what the police have got and make fairly specific requests for it.

"If they don't think to ask; they don't get it" he said.

Mr Smith said that, given the disparity in resources available to the police and defence teams to investigate a crime, the police should be required to disclose to the defence counsel and, more importantly, the jury everything this is at all relevant to the case.

While Mr Smith admits that this would add a lot of time-consuming work to the police, it was important that juries were presented with all relevant facts if they were to be expected to return correct verdicts.

Mr Smith repeated a call he made last month that defendants be required to give evidence so that the jury hears directly from them what their answer is to the charges brought. Failure to do so could be held as prejudicial against them by the court.

"Barlow was happy to tell the media his side of the story throughout the investigation but wouldn't repeat it to the jury.

"It is my view that if he had been required to do so there would have only been one trial, not three, before he was found guilty" Mr Smith said.

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Charlotte Graham: Empowering Communities To Act In A Disaster

The year of record-breaking natural disasters means that in the US, as in New Zealand, there’s a conversation happening about how best to run the emergency management sector and what philosophies best engage and protect communities in the event of a crisis.

How much of the responsibility for a community’s safety in a natural disaster is the Government’s, and how much can be left up to the community themselves? And how do we ensure none of our most vulnerable residents are left behind? More>>


CPAG Report: The Further Fraying Of The Welfare Safety Net

New Zealand’s welfare system has undergone a major transformation during the past three decades. This process has seriously thwarted the original intent of the system, which was to provide a decent standard of living for all New Zealanders in times of need... More>>


Signage, Rumble Strips, Barriers: Boost For State Highway Road Safety

Boost for road safety this summer Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter today announced a short term boost in road safety funding this summer and signalled a renewed focus from the Government on introducing safer speed limits. More>>


Risks & Adaptation: Cheaper To Cut Emissions Than Deal With Climate Change

The cost of climate change to New Zealand is still unknown, but a group of experts tasked with plugging the country's information gaps says it will likely be significant and it would be cheaper to cut greenhouse emissions than simply adapting to those changes. More>>


BPS HYEFU WYSIWYG: Labour's Budget Plans, Families Package

“Today we are announcing the full details of the Government’s Families Package. This is paid for by rejecting National’s tax cuts and instead targeting spending at those who need it most. It will lift 88,000 children out of poverty by 2021." More>>





Featured InfoPages