Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Marc My Words: 10 Sep 2004

Marc My Words.by Marc Alexander MP

Justice, in the hands of a human rights lawyer, is the art of looking for trouble, finding it everywhere, diagnosing it incorrectly and applying the wrong remedies.

We've all heard by now of the four prisoners who look set to receive compensation with a claim totalling $605,000. The High Court concurred with an earlier Court declaration that under the Bill of Rights Act the prisoners' rights had been breached. The lawyer acting on behalf of the prisoners conceded what the real intentions of the inmates were by saying, "The clients want a cheque".

The Sunday Star-Times editorial ran with the headline, 'We must guard prisoners' rights too' while the Dominion Post turned victimhood completely on its head in identifying these criminals as victims with its headline, 'Justice for all victims'.

These two bleeding heart columns make similar assertions, some sensible, some silly; that the abuses committed by the prison system cannot be overlooked; that the 'power of the jailers' should not go unchecked; and that the 'five prisoners who were subjected to a harsh solitary confinement regime' should have access to compensation as redress.

No one can disagree that the Corrections Department has an obligation to account for their actions and treat inmates humanely. No one can seriously entertain the possibility that guards should be exempt from the rule of law. But it is misleading to consider that 'going to jail is itself a punishment', or that 'prisoners have only limited ability to change their circumstances' and are 'at the mercy of other inmates, prison guards and the system that put them there'. After all, 'they' put themselves there!

Imprisonment is a direct consequence of the choice to commit a crime, pure and simple. The limitation of freedom is not a punishment in itself but is a practical response (triggered by an offender's wilful act) to prevent risk to innocent members of society. Punishment is a result of the burden of guilt and how the criminal deals with that through the opportunities provided by imprisonment, for better or for worse. In essence it is the process of accepting and acknowledging responsibility for actions and choices.

Let's remind ourselves of the five criminals for whom their lawyer demands compensation. One was serving a life sentence for murder. He slashed the throat of his victim so savagely that the spine was exposed. Another was serving a term of seventeen years for serious violent offences, including aggravated robbery and wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm.

The other three were serving sentences for a range of violent offences - two had convictions for aggravated injury and assault with a weapon arising from assaults on the Corrections' officers whose jobs require that they guard them. One of the applicants whose claim related to non-voluntary segregation issues was serving a sentence for a range of violent offences including rape, injuring with intent and assault on a Corrections' officer.

Convicted murderer Christopher Taunoa - earmarked for the largest payout - was regarded as the most disruptive prisoner at Paremoremo. He spent more than 700 days on a segregation regime and, as a result, was deemed to have been held for unlawful periods. It was found that these five inmates were unlawfully deprived of entitlements, given inadequate clothing and bedding, as well as routinely strip-searched.

While it's unclear what the extent of those deprivations were, a number of points should be raised; the first is that these criminals, by their violent actions posed a severe risk to other inmates as well as to Corrections' staff. To put them in the general prison population would be to risk the safety of others, surely an inhumane act?

While prisoners choose to commit crimes and, at least in that sense, choose to go to prison when apprehended, the safety and security of all must constitute a basic right and expectation.

The problem arises when some inmates put others at risk and must have increased restrictions including segregation, placed on them. Where segregation is the only viable option, it is in itself a response to a choice made by the criminal.

Allowing offenders to demand compensation is no more than allowing them to demand payment for their own violent choices. Seen in this light, it is an absurdity.

While brutality towards criminals can never be excused or tolerated, neither should crime be allowed to profit criminals. That would be a denial of justice to civil society; an absolute affront to the maxim that 'we reap what we sow'; and much too much to ask their victims to accept.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Also, Loan Interest: Productivity Commission On Tertiary Education

Key recommendations include better quality control; making it easier for students to transfer between courses; abolishing University Entrance; enabling tertiary institutions to own and control their assets; making it easier for new providers to enter the system; and facilitating more and faster innovation by tertiary education providers... More>>


Higher Payments: Wellington Regional Council Becomes A Living Wage Employer

Councillor Sue Kedgley said she was delighted that the Wellington Regional Council unanimously adopted her motion to become a Living Wage employer, making it the first regional council in New Zealand to do so. More>>


Scoop Images:
Dame Patsy Reddy Sworn In As Governor-General

This morning Dame Patsy Reddy was sworn in as the New Zealand Realm’s 21st Governor-General. The ceremony began with a pōwhiri to welcome Dame Patsy and her husband Sir David Gascoigne to Parliament. More>>


Ruataniwha: DOC, Hawke's Bay Council Developer Take Supreme Court Appeal

The Department of Conservation and Hawke's Bay Regional Investment Company (HBRIC) are appealing to the Supreme Court over a conservation land swap which the Court of Appeal halted. More>>


With NZ's Marama Davidson: Women’s Flotilla Leaves Sicily – Heading For Gaza

Women representing 13 countries spanning five continents began their journey yesterday on Zaytouna-Oliva to the shores of Gaza, which has been under blockade since 2007. On board are a Nobel Peace Laureate, three parliamentarians, a decorated US diplomat, journalists, an Olympic athlete, and a physician. A list of the women with their background can be found here. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Key Style Of Crisis Management

At Monday’s post Cabinet press conference Key was in his finest wide- eyed “Problem? What problem?” mode. No, there wasn’t really a problem that top MPI officials had been at odds with each other over the meaning of the fisheries policy and how that policy should be pursued... More>>


Mt Roskill: Greens Will Not Stand In Likely Post-Goff By-Election

“The Green Party’s priority is changing the Government in 2017, and as part of that we’ve decided that we won’t stand a candidate in the probable Mt Roskill by-election... This decision shows the Memorandum of Understanding between Labour and the Green Party is working." More>>


Get More From Scoop



Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news