Parliament

Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search

 

Birch Not Fit To Be Revenue Minister - Peters

Birch Either: - Doesn’t Understand The Law - Or - Has Contempt For The Law. Either Way – Not Fit To Be Minister Of Revenue.

New Zealand First Leader, Rt Hon Winston Peters, today said that Revenue Minister Sir William Birch either does not understand the law or he has contempt for the law. Either way Mr Birch is not fit to be Minister of Revenue.

“The findings of the Winebox decision are immense, and show that this country has been subjected to the worst kind of tax evasion. Mr Birch’s comments on the judgement are straight politicking – an attack on those who fought for the truth and an unethical defence of those who have done wrong. In doing so the Minister is failing in his duty to uphold the integrity of our laws.

“Mr Birch had to admit on morning radio that $140 million in tax re-assessments resulted from the Winebox Inquiry so why is he disingenuously talking about $12 million costs when if he had done his job from day one the return to the taxpayers would have been in the hundreds of millions and the cost negligible.

“Mr Birch says that tax loop holes have since been closed. My questions is, when Mr Birch, and what laws? Mr Birch’s statements are blatantly false. These Privy Council, Court of Appeal and High Court decisions state clearly that there never were any loop holes. Moreover, those involved, all of whom were qualified lawyers and accountants, either didn’t know what they were doing, (although they clearly understood the monetary advantage in what they were doing), or they simply broke the law by deliberately withholding information from IRD.

“Even Commissioner Davison got that part right (see pgs 1:9:16, 1:9:19 of his Report - attached). Sadly, for reasons he will have to explain he got the law wrong despite the excellent submissions of counsel assisting him and every legal precedent he should have read including Brannigan v Davison, a Privy Council decision in his favour.

“The Prime Minister and Mr Birch say they are going to the Solicitor General for advice. Don’t they realise that in 1996 the Solicitor General appeared at the Privy Council acting for Davison in the Brannigan Case. The Solicitor General there argued successfully that Magnum was: one single transaction that Cook Islands Law did not override New Zealand Law

“A Privy Council decision supported by the 5 Member Court of Appeal and the 2 Member High Court. In short, 12 jurists have sought to tell the Prime Minister and Revenue Minister the law and these unqualified politicians want to ignore it.

“To say that the Winebox transactions are somehow part of some forgivable past is convenient, self serving, venal and itself an attempt to aid and abet crime. Treasury’s own studies have found that scams like the Magnum deal cost this country millions of dollars a year. Such scams continue to this day and the ramifications are huge for our revenue.

“Money lost in this way has had to be picked up by law abiding taxpayers.

“There is not another Western Democracy where such corporate and political behaviour would be tolerated. Why is it being tolerated in our country that claims to have a system of law and a constitutional government?

“No wonder New Zealanders think that politics in this country are at an all time low,” said Mr Peters.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On Allegations Of Left Wing Media Bias

“Left wing bias” accusations date back at least to the mid 1990s, when complaints were commonly being levelled at RNZ’s Morning Report programme, largely by National MPs discomfited by being interviewed by Kim Hill.

The charge of left wing bias was ridiculous then, and is ridiculous now. More>>

 
 

Next Wave Of Reforms: Gun Registration And Licensing Changes Announced

“The Bill includes a register to track firearms and new offences and penalties that can be applied extraterritorially for illegal manufacture, trafficking, and for falsifying, removing, or altering markings – which are a new requirement under the Firearms Protocol.” More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Labour’s Mishandling Of The Alleged Sexual Assault

The focus of Labour’s alleged sexual assault scandal has now shifted from the party organisation to the Beehive... This is now a crisis of Beehive management and response, not something occurring at a distance within the party organisation. More>>

ALSO:

'History Rectified': Rua Kēnana To Be Pardoned

An official pardon for Tūhoe prophet and leader Rua Kēnana is one step closer after the Te Pire kia Unuhia te Hara kai Runga i a Rua Kēnana: Rua Kēnana Pardon Bill was read in Parliament for the first time today. More>>

ALSO:

Mental Health: Initial Mental Health And Wellbeing Commission Appointed

The Government has announced details of the initial Mental Health and Wellbeing Commission which will play a key role in driving better mental health in New Zealand. More>>

ALSO:

people outside the meeting house at WaitangiEducation: NZ History To Be Taught In All Schools

“We have listened carefully to the growing calls from New Zealanders to know more about our own history and identity. With this in mind it makes sense for the National Curriculum to make clear the expectation that our history is part of the local curriculum and marau ā kura in every school and kura,” Jacinda Ardern said. More>>

ALSO:

Sexual Assault Claims Mishandled: Labour Party President Resigns

Jacinda Ardern: “This morning I was provided some of the correspondence from complainants written to the party several months ago. It confirms that the allegations made were extremely serious, that the process caused complainants additional distress, and that ultimately, in my view, the party was never equipped to appropriately deal with the issue…" More>>

ALSO:

Budget Process: Wellbeing To Be Enshrined In Law

Legislation has been introduced in Parliament to ensure every Government considers the wellbeing of New Zealanders when creating future budgets. More>>

National In China: Bridges Praises CCP, Meets Law Enforcement Head

A recent trip to China has raised questions over who the Opposition leader Simon Bridges met with and why... Anne-Marie Brady, a Canterbury University professor and expert on Chinese politics, has described Guo Shengkun as the leader of the Chinese secret police. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The SIS/GCSB’s Compliance With Torture

Torture is a crime under international law. New Zealand has signed (a) the UN convention against torture and (b) formal agreements about how armed conflict should be conducted. That’s the legal backdrop to the fascinating report released this week by the SIS Inspector-General.

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels