Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


One woman a month developing cancer

One woman a month developing cancer

Jim Anderton MP Tue Sep 21 1999

Jim Anderton
MPOne woman a month is likely to develop invasive cancer because of misread slides in the Gisborne area and the slow pace of the response to the disaster, Alliance health spokesperson Phillida Bunkle says.

While welcoming the fact that the Minister of Health has finally responded to Alliance calls for a full public inquiry, she wants the inquiry broadened to investigate the reasons that no action was taken when knowledge of the misread slides was widespread in the medical establishment.

The Health Funding Authority has today admitted that only 28 out of 157 abnormal smears were correctly identified by Gisborne pathologist Dr Michael Bottrill. The existence of widespread problems with the slides in Gisborne was made public in Parliament in April by Phillida Bunkle. Health authorities had known of the problem since 1996, but failed to act even after a Medical Council guilty verdict and a court case involving one of the women, until Ms Bunkle exposed the issue.

'This is the biggest medical disaster in New Zealand's history. If 120 women out of 5000 have had their slides misread, then it's likely that 600 will be found to have been misread by the time the full 25,000 slides have been examined. On the HFA's own figures, 2% of those women each year will develop invasive cancer, which amounts to 12 a year, or one woman every month.

'It has taken years to brerak through the denial that there was a problem. Action is now urgent. The Health Funding Authority is still going to take until December to re-read the misread slides, and 50% of the women whose slides were misread have still not been identified, yet they are developing invasive cancer at a rate of one a month. More effort needs to go into recalling the women and the Government should accept liability and offer immediate financial support for the women without dragging them through court again.

'The government had no choice other than to hold the inquiry that the Alliance has been pushing for since April. However the key issue in the inquiry has to be this: Why were there delays in checking all smears done at the laboratory once there was evidence of mistakes in 1996?

'When the extent of the Gisborne disaster was first publicly known, the pathologists were still claiming publicly that the misread slides were within acceptable failure rates.

Phillida Bunkle said the announcement of the inquiry today vindicated the use of parliamentary privilege

'If it had not been for the freedom of MPs to speak out in parliament, it is possible that the extent of the Gisborne disaster would never have been made public.'


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Jami-Lee Ross Saga

In the end, the Jami-Lee Ross tweet about secretly taping his leader and promising to use it – assuming that such a tape exists, and wasn’t just being conjured out of thin air as a random threat – is a more serious offence than the original leak.

After all, even the PWC report hadn’t finally and definitively pointed the finger of blame at Ross, but had cited him merely as the most likely suspect. More>>

Press Conference Video: Jami-Lee Ross Plans By-Election, Police Complaint
National MP Jami-Lee Ross is to resign his seat and step down from the National Party, and will stand as an independent in any by-election for his Botany seat... Speaking to media at Parliament, he alleged Mr Bridges had broken electoral donation law and said he would put in an official police complaint. More>>


Education Amendment Bill Proceeda: Urgency Sought For Partnership School Treaty Claim

The claim takes issue with the acts and omissions of the Crown in respect of the closure of Partnership Schools | Kura Hourua. More>>


Salvation Army Paper: Call For Public Housing Investment

To meet these future demands the report suggests the government needs to look beyond the private rental market and begin to invest heavily into home-ownership programmes and more public and social housing. More>>


Fate Of Tahr Sealed: Himalayan Tahr Control Operation Proceeding

“The target of controlling 10,000 Himalayan tahr over the next eight months remains. The revised plan provides for a staged control operation with increased reporting to the Tahr Liaison Group...” More>>


Health: Petitions To Fund Breast Cancer Drugs

Women marching to Parliament today, to present two petitions calling for Government funding of vital medicines, have 100% support from a coalition representing than 30 breast cancer organisations. More>>


Animal Welfare Advisory Committee: Report On Rodeo Practices Released

The independent committee that advises the Minister responsible for Animal Welfare, has today released a report on animal welfare in rodeos, together with advice to the Minister making recommendations to improve the welfare of the animals in rodeos. More>>


PM's Press Conference: Fuel And Leaks

Other topics included the apparent murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi at the Saudi Arabian embassy in Turkey, the relation between the Government moves against high fuel prices and the commitment to act on climate change, NZTA's failures in compliance checks ... More>>


New Hager Investigation: War Crimes, Sexual Assaults And Coverups In Armed Forces

A string of current and ex-New Zealand Defence Force staff have contacted Hager since the book he co-authored with Jon Stephenson – Hit & Run – was published in March 2017... More>>


Israel's Anti-Boycott Law: NZ Activists Fined Over Lorde Cancellation Raise $12k For Charity

New Zealand activists being fined in Israel for urging pop singer Lorde to cancel her concert have raised more than $12,000 for a Palestinian charity. More>>





InfoPages News Channels