Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


Prebble challenges Cullen to debate

Friday 8th Oct 1999

Richard Prebble
Media Release -- Other

ACT Leader Richard Prebble has challenged Labour's Michael Cullen to a debate on Treaty of Waitangi settlements.

"Dr Cullen who has made a practice of personally attacking anyone who disagrees with him, has claimed that ACT's proposals to close down the Waitangi grievance industry and ensure all settlements are finalised, are the policies of Pauline Hanson's One Nation party," Mr Prebble said.

"All intelligent New Zealanders know that Pauline Hanson's party denied that Australian Aborigines had any valid land claims at all. The ACT Party says by contrast that real Maori grievances like land confiscations are being ignored while the Tribunal deliberates on bogus claims like that for the electromagnetic spectrum.

"Where does Labour stand on the claim that the electromagnetic spectrum is a Maori taonga? Will Labour be parting with taxpayers' money for the electromagnetic spectrum, and if so, how much?

"I look forward to Dr Cullen's reply."


Attached: letter to Dr Cullen

Hon Richard Prebble CBE Leader ACT New Zealand Parliament Buildings Wellington

8 October 1999

Dr Michael Cullen
Parliament Buildings

Dear Dr Cullen

Challenge to debate

I see I have joined the West Coasters as the latest New Zealander to be subject to a vitriolic attack by yourself, with a comparison between ACT's treaty policy and Pauline Hanson's One Nation party.

I hope this can be about issues not personalities. I invite you to tell me how Labour intends to handle Treaty of Waitangi clams. In particular, does Labour accept the Waitangi Tribunal's ruling that the electromagnetic spectrum is a taonga protected under the Treaty?

I enclosed for your information a copy of ACT's policy for resolving Treaty claims once and for all so we can all move forward, with one law for all. I would be interested to receive a copy of your policy.

Since you regard the issue worthy of an attack under Parliamentary privilege perhaps you would like to debate the issue with me. I have had indications from media organisations that they would be interested in hosting such a debate. I look forward to your response.

Yours sincerely Hon Richard Prebble CBE


For more information visit ACT online at or contact the ACT Parliamentary Office at

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Remembrance: Anzac After Christchurch

A community group is creating The Sound of Peace, a crowdsourced soundscape that captures messages of peace from New Zealanders in their own voices and languages...

The Anzac Eve event, The Art of Remembrance with Kristin Darragh, is a concert and memorial service in the grounds of the historic St David’s Memorial Church in Uptown Auckland.

‘As we remember the lives lost in World War One, we remember the horrors of all wars, and the potential to reach out across the divides now to expand understanding and a sense of our shared humanity.’ More>>


NZ And France To Seek To End Use Of Social Media For Terrorism

New Zealand and France announced today that the two nations will bring together countries and tech companies in an attempt to bring to an end the ability to use social media to organise and promote terrorism and violent extremism, in the wake of the March 15 terrorist attacks in Christchurch New Zealand. More>>


Christchurch Attacks: Families Offered Option To Stay Permanently

Immigration New Zealand has created a special visa category for those directly impacted by the shootings at Al Noor Mosque and Linwood mosque, as well as their families. More>>


Auckland: Consent Granted For Queens Wharf Cruise Ship Upgrade

In its decision, released this afternoon, Auckland Council says that although the upgrade will have a "range of adverse effects on the environment, both during construction and operation", these can be managed to an "acceptable" level. More>>


Welfare: Access To Hardship Grants Hits Record High

Figures from the Ministry of Social Development for the March 2019 Quarter showed that hardship assistance grants increased by $48 million in the past year... They also showed the emergency housing grants went from $6.6m to $23m, and there were 70,000 extra requests for assistance for food. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Scrapping The Capital Gains Tax

As PM Jacinda Arden said yesterday, there was no point in Labour bringing a proposal into the House that it didn’t have the votes to get passed. Looking back, maybe she always felt this outcome to be inevitable... More>>





InfoPages News Channels