Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | Video | Questions Of the Day | Search


The world according to Helen Clark

18 November 1999

The world according to Helen Clark

upton-on-line's plans to visit Queenstown on 'Lipstick 1' were thwarted by the terrible floods. The change of plans did, however, leave him time to read through a transcript of Helen Clark's extended interview with Kim Hill on Tuesday.

It was revealing.

The economy:

Helen Clark tells us that Labour's is "a much more active-in-the-economy approach". She said, "government has to get off the fence on the economy and get active. "Under Labour we'll have "smart, intelligent government interventions".

Well, everybody thinks their interventions are smart and intelligent – Muldoon surely did. Bob Tizard did. History told us otherwise.

How short memories must be. She waxes lyrical about the Kirk years. Yes, they were warm and fuzzy, but that government was probably the worst economically in the last half century. It was boom and bust on a grand scale. (Am I the only person who can remember Warren Freer’s ill-fated “Maximum Retail Price” scheme?)

Do Ms Clark and her front bench of teachers and unionists really know more about business success than the people actually involved?

It's a chilling thought.

National is not entirely "hands free" as Clark alleges, but we have a more modest view of government's ability to intervene successfully in the economy.

If we needed any proof of the perils of state control, Helen Clark says she is eagerly looking forward to re-restructuring the Health system to bring back elected health boards (which, apparently, were "wonderful"). (At least she's consistent with her double standards, because here she's "absolutely confident that the way to go is not for central government sitting in Wellington to try and second-guess what the best strategies are for the region").

So, after another top-driven shake up, hospitals will be run by local busy-bodies who, generally, have no idea how to run vast and complex enterprises.

Helen Clark rattles off European examples of how governments should act and what they should provide ("good universal healthcare, education, superannuation"). It's almost as simple for her as saying, we just have to do what European social democracies do and we'll be as rich as the Europeans.

Upton-on-line quietly reminds Ms Clark that New Zealand is not in Europe. We are not in a market of 300 million of the richest people on earth. Europe can afford costly and inefficient governments. They pay for it with high unemployment. New Zealand is not living in the same world. Our margin for error is much smaller.

Student loans:

When asked whether Labour's plans for the student loans scheme wouldn't just lead to students taking interest free loans and investing them for profit, her answer was less than convincing.

Blindly she stated, "It is taken for educational purposes. It is not designed to be put into the stock market and we shall consider whether there are ways in which we can address that."
Kim Hill: "You haven't found ways yet?
Helen Clark: "Well, not yet we haven't".

Is upton-on-line reading too much into this to say, these people fundamentally misunderstand human nature. He is reminded powerfully of her blind faith in "good faith bargaining".


Ms Clark "hates" bulk funding. She puts "enormous emphasis on a nation-wide system of education." Her answer to Kim Hill's suggestion that "uniformity is often synonymous with mediocrity" was hardly persuasive (in fact it offered no argument at all):

"I don't agree at all. I think a nation-wide education system is just a very, very compelling thing for me and I will not subscribe to any policy that breaks it up".

Kim Hill brought up the example of a Steiner school, a special character school, which relies on bulk funding to maintain its special character (leaving it free to allocate the money as it wishes). Ms Clark's only response was that there must be “some problems with the economics of it”.

Kim Hill got it right: "well, that seems to indicate that your desire for uniformity from Cape Reinga to the Bluff, means that a whole lot of schools such as this one, are going to have to toe the line or disappear. It's a Steiner school, it's got 300 kids".

Other delicious quotes:
"The worst thing you can accuse the Alliance of, is wanting free health and education". [Does this mean land taxes, wealth taxes and so on are lesser evils?]
"The Labour party has a history of fiscal orthodoxy. Our first finance Minister was Walter Nash. We moved on to Arnold Nordmeyer, we've moved on through Bill Rowling… orthodox people".

Helen Clark lives in "a pretty miserable society', one where the "cry of the Hikoi" resonates. "I am absolutely confident", she says, "that New Zealanders want an end to the nightmare we've been living through". [Yet Upton-on-line understands that 70% of the children in Helen Clark’s electorate attend bulk-funded schools that have voluntarily made the switch]

Perhaps we're being cruel, but upton-on-line suggests that she starts getting some more up-beat friends. Not everybody he meets is depressed and miserable. Sure, it's not the 1950s when Europe was in rubble and everything was handed to us on a plate. We have to work harder, but this is a great country. Inspired Opposition leaders can make people feel good about themselves and their country. Helen seems determined to depress everyone. And it is a stunning country after all.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Commerce Commission: Retail Fuel "Not As Competitive As It Could Be"

The Commission has outlined some options it considers could improve competition. There are two broad sets of options it thinks may have the potential to help create a competitive wholesale market. These are:

• Greater contractual freedom to make it easier for resellers to switch between suppliers; and
• Enabling wider participation in the majors’ joint infrastructure, notably the shared terminals and supporting logistics involved in their borrow-and-loan system.
Further options, including improving the transparency of premium petrol prices, are discussed in the draft report. More>>


Promises: Independent Election Policy Costing Unit A Step Closer

The creation of an entity to provide political parties with independent and non-partisan policy costings is a step closer today, according to Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Associate Finance Minister James Shaw. More>>


School's In: Primary And Intermediate Principals Accept New Offer

Primary and intermediate school principals have voted to accept a new settlement from the Ministry of Education, which includes entrenched pay parity with secondary principals. More>>


IPCA On 'Rawshark' Investigation: Multiple Police Failings In Hager Searches Confirmed

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that the Police's unlawful search of Nicky Hager's property in October 2014 resulted from an unwitting neglect of duty and did not amount to misconduct by any individual officer... More>>


Broadcasting Standards: Decisions On Coverage Of Mosque Attacks

The Authority upheld one of these complaints, finding that the use of extensive excerpts from the alleged attacker’s livestream video on Sky News New Zealand had the potential to cause significant distress to audiences in New Zealand, and particularly to the family and friends of victims, and the wider Muslim community. More>>

PM's Post-Cab: Bad Mail

Cabinet was updated on the process around prisoners sending mail, following the accused Christchurch gunman sending letters that "should have been stopped". All mail of "high concern prisoners" will now be checked by a specialist team and a changes to the legal criteria for witholding mail are expecting to go to a cabinet committee in this parliamentary session. More>>

Welfare: Ongoing Drug-Test Sanctions Contradicts Govt’s Rhetoric

Reports that two-thirds of beneficiaries who fail drug tests are still having their benefit sanctioned contradicts the Government’s so-called health approach to drugs. More>>


Welfare: More Measures To Help Those Facing Homelessness

Ministers have announced $54 million in Government funding for initiatives which will support at-risk individuals and whānau to stay in their existing tenancies. The funding will also provide additional wrap around services. More>>


Corrections: New Strategy On Māori Reoffending And imprisonment

Authentic co-design with Māori, incorporating a Te Ao Māori worldview, and greater connectedness with whānau are key elements of Hōkai Rangi, Corrections’ new departmental strategy designed to address the long-term challenge of Māori reoffending and imprisonment. More>>





InfoPages News Channels