Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 


CTU Evidence To Select Commitee Misleading

INSURANCE COUNCIL
Internet: http://www.icnz.org.nz
MEDIA RELEASE
16 February 2000

COUNCIL OF TRADE UNIONS EVIDENCE TO SELECT COMMITTEE MISLEADING

Evidence provided to the Select Committee on Accident Insurance by the Council of Trade Unions was misleading says the Insurance Council.

The claim by President Ross Wilson that 99% of all employers are paying higher premiums than they would have under ACC is preposterous and clearly unsupported by the evidence of a significant majority of the thousand submissions to the Select Committee.

Mr Wilson claims that only the largest 1% of employers have received benefits from premium reductions in the competitive market.

His interpretation of the Accident Insurance Regulator’s official data released in December has been examined by an independent actuary and found to be significantly flawed.

Firstly, he is basing his figures on a notional premium level that ACC might have charged, but which is highly challengeable and secondly, it ignores the fact that most of New Zealand’s largest organisations are in the service sector and are considered low risk in the setting of premiums. (Editor – please refer to paragraph 6 and Annexure E in attached material from Peter Davies, independent actuary).

Mr Wilson also challenged the assertion by the Insurance Council of a substantial reduction in workplace fatalities with the advent of a competitive insurance market. He used statistics supplied by the Occupational Safety and Health Division of the Department of Labour. These statistics are totally inappropriate for making comparisons and Mr Wilson should have known better than to quote them.

Again independent actuarial advice indicates that taking even the most conservative view, the reduction of fatalities has been at least 25%. The Council asserted in its submission, on the basis of ACC data, that the reduction could be as much as 50%.

Mr Wilson also quoted a Canadian study by Professors Burton and Thomason, asserting that costs may increase by shifting from a monopoly provision of accident insurance to a competitive market model. We have checked this reference with Professor Thomason and he confirms that the quote is out of context and misleading.

Professor Thomason says, “I do not believe our results clearly indicate that public funds are more necessarily more cost efficient than private insurance.” He goes on to say that the Canadian data is from only two provinces and that rates in Ontario at least, may not reflect the true cost of workers’ compensation. He also points out that costs in Washington State, an example of a state monopoly that is often heralded as a success story, are higher than average.

Professor Thomason goes on to say that there is substantial variation in the performance of monopolistic public funds relative to private insurance. This was a point highlighted by a US expert, Greg Krohm who was recently in New Zealand and appeared before the select committee. (Editor – e-mail from Professor Thomason attached)

There is enough doubt around key points in the CTU’s submission to cast significant doubt on its whole credibility. It is more a statement of ideology than of fact, says the Council.


For further information: Chris Ryan
Chief Executive
Insurance Council of New Zealand
025 441-767

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

 

Breed Laws Don’t Work: Vets On New National Dog Control Plan

It is pleasing therefore to see Louise Upston Associate Minister for Local Government calling for a comprehensive solution... However, relying on breed specific laws to manage dog aggression will not work. More>>

ALSO:

Corrections Corrected: Supreme Court Rules On Release Dates

Corrections has always followed the lawful rulings of the Court in its calculation of sentence release dates. On four previous occasions, the Court of Appeal had upheld Corrections’ practices in calculating pre-sentence detention. More>>

ALSO:

Not Waiting On Select Committee: Green Party Releases Medically-Assisted Dying Policy

“Adults with a terminal illness should have the right to choose a medically assisted death,” Green Party health spokesperson Kevin Hague said. “The Green Party does not support extending assisted dying to people who aren't terminally ill because we can’t be confident that this won't further marginalise the lives of people with disabilities." More>>

ALSO:

General Election Review: Changes To Electoral Act Introduced

More effective systems in polling places and earlier counting of advanced votes are on their way through proposed changes to our electoral laws, Justice Minister Amy Adams says. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Our Posturing At The UN

In New York, Key basically took an old May 2 Washington Post article written by Barack Obama, recycled it back to the Americans, and still scored headlines here at home… We’ve had a double serving of this kind of comfort food. More>>

ALSO:

Treaty Settlements: Bills Delayed As NZ First Pulls Support

Ngāruahine, Te Atiawa and Taranaki are reeling today as they learnt that the third and final readings of each Iwi’s Historical Treaty Settlement Bills scheduled for this Friday, have been put in jeopardy by the actions of NZ First. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Damage De-Regulation Is Doing To Fisheries And Education, Plus Kate Tempest

Our faith in the benign workings of the market – and of the light-handed regulation that goes with it – has had a body count. Back in 1992, the free market friendly Health Safety and Employment Act gutted the labour inspectorate and turned forestry, mining and other workplace sites into death traps, long before the Pike River disaster. More>>

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Politics
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news