Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

No Commission Inquiry Into MPs Referendum

17/10/01

No Commission Inquiry

The Human Rights Commission today released its decision not to conduct an inquiry into aspects of the Citizens Initiated Referendum (“CIR”) on the number of MPs in Parliament.

Chief Human Rights Commissioner Rosslyn Noonan said that Margaret Robertson had asked the Commission to:

a) inquire into whether human rights are, or may be, infringed by a decision by a Government to do nothing to implement the results of the CIR;

b) inquire into whether or not the decision to have a Committee of the House undertake the review of the CIR was both fair and appropriate, when there was considerable public support to have the review undertaken by an independent body;

c) inquire into whether or not principles of natural justice were breached by having the review of the CIR undertaken by nominees of political parties, some of which (both parties and nominees) had strong reason to retain the current level of representation;

d) report to the Prime Minister indicating whether or not it is desirable to take actions to protect the peoples right to choose the political system of their preference and to take actions to ensure better compliance with standards laid down in international instruments on human rights.

Ms.Noonan said that Mrs Robertson also felt that New Zealand’s international human rights obligations required the Government to implement the outcome of the CIR and had asked the Commission to report to the Prime Minister on the human rights aspects of her concerns.

“Given the significance and public importance of the issues raised the Commission first undertook its own review of the issues and then sought an independent legal opinion. Many factors were carefully considered before a decision was reached,” said Ms.Noonan.

The Commission found that if it conducted an inquiry into any aspect of the establishment, conduct and report of the MMP Review Committee it would breach the privileges of the House of Representatives. There is a longstanding legal principle that certain aspects of Parliament’s activities cannot be questioned outside of Parliament.

The Commission does have the power to report to the Prime Minister on any matter affecting human rights including the desirability of legislative, administrative or other action to give better protection to human rights and ensure better compliance with standards laid down in international human rights instruments. Before undertaking such a report, the Commission must establish whether there is some basis on which to proceed.

Both the Commission’s own investigations and the opinion of George Barton QC concluded that contrary to Mrs Robertson’s claim, neither New Zealand’s international or domestic human rights obligations would appear to be breached should the Government decide to take no action on the referendum. The Commission notes that the Government has not yet announced a decision as to how it intends to respond to the outcome of the MMP Review Committee’s report following the CIR.

The Commission therefore has taken the view that:

- Article 2 of the International Covenant on Civil & Political Rights (ICCPR) did not appear to have been breached.

- Article 25 of the ICCPR, and the general comments of the Human Rights Committee established under the ICCPR, do not support the suggestion that the Government is required to implement the results of a non-binding citizens initiated referendum.

- Section 27(1) of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 does not cover determinations by the “Government” in this particular situation.

Ms. Noonan added, “References to “the will of the electors” in Article 25 of ICCPR refer to freely chosen representatives elected by genuine periodic elections. Article 25 does not impose an obligation on a freely elected government to implement the outcome of a non-binding citizens initiated referendum”.

“The Commission’s decision that there is no basis on which to undertake an inquiry and report to the Prime Minister on the question of the Parliamentary process for considering the referendum, in no way reflects on the validity of the substantive issue of the number of MPs raised by the referendum.”


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Supreme Court: Worksafe Decision On Whittall Pike River Prosecution Unlawful

The question in issue on the appeal was whether WorkSafe New Zealand acted to give effect to an unlawful agreement of this nature when it offered no evidence on charges against Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992...

The Supreme Court... has found that the decision to offer no evidence was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. It has granted a declaration to that effect. More>>

 

Cullen To Chair: Tax Working Group Terms Of Reference Announced

Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Revenue Minister Stuart Nash today announced the Terms of Reference for the Tax Working Group and that the Group will be chaired by Sir Michael Cullen. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The New Pike River Agency (And The Air Strike Wing)

Much of the sympathy the public still feels for the families of the Pike River miners has been sustained by the sense that the previous government – let alone the mining company and the processes of receivership and litigation – has never dealt honestly, or fairly, with them. More>>

ALSO:

Not Going Swimmingly: Contractor Cut, New Dates For Christchurch Sports Centre

“As an incoming Minister, I have been conducting a thorough review of progress on the Anchor projects and to learn of a $75 million budget blowout on this project was very disappointing..." More>>

ALSO:

Tertiary: Allowances, Loan Living Costs To Get Boost

“From 1 January, student allowance base rates and the maximum amount students can borrow for living costs will rise by a net $50 a week,” says Education Minister Chris Hipkins... further adjusted from 1 April 2018 in line with any increase in the CPI. More>>

ALSO:

Foreign Affairs: Patrick Gower Interviews Jacinda Ardern

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says discussions have already begun on how to bring climate change refugees into New Zealand under a Pacific seasonal employment plan... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Centre Right’s Love Of ‘Nanny State’

You’d almost think it was 2005 again. That was a time when the rugged individualists of the centre-right were being beset by government regulations on the nature of light-bulbs, the size of shower heads, the junk food available at school tuck shops and other such essentials... More>>

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election