Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Brother And Sister Surrogacy Should Be Outlawed

19 November 2001

Brother And Sister Surrogacy Should Be Outlawed

“The desire to seek surrogacy arrangements between family members may seem unproblematic to some, but is not in the best interests of the child and should be outlawed,” said Party Leader Graham Capill.

Mr Capill is deeply concerned at reports that a surrogacy arrangement might be allowed between a brother and sister. The sister is allegedly going to be paid expenses relating to the pregnancy, such as loss of wages.

“It is not unusual for surrogatees to change their mind after the birth. This is especially likely for women who have not had children. Such a turnaround would be a disaster for the whole family or whanau.”

“The child may well have to cope with a very confusing upbringing. There is a world of difference between a child being raised by the wider family when orphaned or given for adoption, and being raised in these circumstances. The former is not unusual in Maori circles; the latter does not appear to be part of Maori culture.

“It is only one short step between this intimate arrangement and permitting full sexual relations between family members. To reduce the situation to the sister merely acting as an incubator for her brother’s baby, is far too simplistic and fails to recognize the intimate nature of nurturing a child in utero. Hormonal and other physical changes mean the birth mother is involved with the child in a very personal and intimate way. The simple absence of sexual relations does not make it morally acceptable.

“Payment of expenses is the thin end of the wedge. Business regularly classifies certain income as payment for expenses, especially when it comes to matters of taxation. Most commercial surrogacy arrangements overseas actually do the same as that which is proposed in this particular case. Such payment can undermine the pure motives of offering to act as a surrogate,” Mr Capill concluded.

The Christian Heritage Party calls on the government to pass legislation dealing with these complex bioethical situations. The current case is not singular, as these possibilities have been around for some 20 years. CHP is opposed to surrogacy arrangements and would, instead, encourage adoption, especially when there are so many unwanted children - if the abortion statistics are anything to go by.

END

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Cyclone Gita: Metservice Forecasts Gita To Impact New Zealand - Be Prepared

Cyclone Gita is expected to approach New Zealand from the northwest early next week. There remains some uncertainty with regards to the speed and track of Gita, but the passage of this system across New Zealand on Tuesday and Wednesday is likely to bring a period of highly impactful severe weather.

People should be aware of the potential for coastal inundation, especially where high waves,low atmospheric pressure and strong onshore winds come together ... More>>

ALSO:

.

 
 

Commerce, Etc: Thicker Bright Line For Real Estate

Revenue Minister Stuart Nash has confirmed the bright-line test on residential property sales will be extended from two years to five years in legislation currently making its way through Parliament.More>>

ALSO:

Prison Inspections: Reports on Manawatu and Paremoremo Released

The Office of the Inspectorate today released reports into Manawatu Prison and Auckland Prison (Paremoremo), the first two resulting from a programme of inspections of New Zealand prisons. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On National’s Leadership Contest

National needs a new leader able to: (a) compete with, undermine and defeat a currently popular and politically adept Prime Minister; (b) define whether National now sees itself as being a traditional conservative party or a modern neo-liberal one; (c) devise a strategy that addresses National’s chronic lack of a viable coalition partner More>>

ALSO:

Whistle Blowers: Government To Review Law On Protection

Work has begun on a review of the Protected Disclosures Act 2000, Minister of State Services Chris Hipkins said today. More>>

ALSO:

Christchurch: PM Launches 100% Electric Car Share Offering

The Southern Hemisphere’s biggest deployment of pure battery electric cars and largest pure EV car sharing model was officially launched in Christchurch today by Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern. More>>

ALSO:

Carer Pay Equity: Mental Health And Addiction Workers To Be Included

Dr Clark met yesterday with unions and employers to confirm the Government has agreed to negotiate an agreement to extend the Care and Support Pay Equity Settlement to mental health and addiction support workers. More>>

ALSO:

Hybrid Plan: America’s Cup Village Proposal Released

The proposal incorporates elements of the Wynyard Basin option, agreed by the council in December and publicly notified last month, and the Wynyard Point variant explored by the Government. More>>

ALSO:

Sallies' State of the Nation: Poorest Left Behind in Economic Boom

This year’s report shows that for many New Zealanders incomes have hardly moved, welfare needs have increased and rents are rising faster than incomes. This comes despite more jobs being created and GDP rising... More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages