Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


PN Lawyer Challenges AG Re. Street Racing Bill


Date: Tue, 11 Jun 2002 20:29:34 +1200

Subject: Re: submission

To Bruce Thomson, CARM [Citizens Against Rowdy Motoring]

My name is Richard Fisher. I am a qualified barrister and solicitor of the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia, and of the High Court of New Zealand.

I have followed with interest the development of New Zealand's street racing bill. I was particularly interested in media reports which indicated that the Attorney General considered that the proposed bill offends the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act. The media refers to a "report" by the AG to that effect. I have not seen the report. In the absence of further information, I felt compelled to submit to the Committee in respect of the proposed bill. The gist of my submission follows:

1) The proposed bill may very well provoke a prima facie breach in the Act.

2) The Act contains provisions which allows legislation to breach the Act, provided that the breach can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society. I have seen no media reference to this very obvious feature of the Act.

3) In determining what exactly can be "demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society", a sophisticated legal analysis is used in both NZ and Canada, borrowed from the Supreme Court of Canada. I have not seen evidence of its application in this case.

4) Canada has much more experience than NZ in interpreting demonstrable justification. In fact, NZ's Bill of Rights Act is based upon Canada's Charter of rights and freedoms, so comparing the two countries experience is both justified, and worthwhile, in light of NZ 's smaller size and less litigious character, as well as its lesser experience in interpreting offended rights under the BRA.

5) Canada (that is, British Columbia) has promulgated legislation with regard to street racing which is similar to that in the proposed bill. The legislation is new, but has been subject to robust legal inquiry with regard to whether it will withstand a Charter (ie Bill of Rights) challenge. The view of the government, based on extensive legal experience in dealing with Charter challenges, is that it will.

6) Clearly then there is a dichotomy between the NZ and Canadian responses to street racing legislation, in terms of its possibly minimal impact on rights under the BRA. My submission supports deference to the Canadian decision, in light of Canada's much vaster experience in this area, in light of an absence of evidence of a substantial BRA legal analysis, and finally in light of the pervasiveness of this problem throughout NZ, which, I gather from media reports, is now of concern to a very large number of citizens.

RM Fisher, BSc, PhD, LLB

Bruce Thomson Coordinator, Citizens Against Rowdy Motoring

bthomson@e3.net.nz 20 Lyndhurst Street, Palmerston North, New Zealand Tel. 64-6- 3577-773 or 3577-889 Mobile 021-158-5513 (omit that 0 if overseas)

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Peters/Ardern Triumph

There are a lot of good reasons to feel joyful about this outcome. It is what so many young voters – the best hope for the country’s future – wanted.

Far more important than the implications for the Economy Gods ( is the dollar up or down? ) last night’s outcome will also mean many, many vulnerable New Zealanders will have a better life over the next three years at least.

Yet the desire for change was in the majority, across the country..>>>More


Labour on its agreement |Peters: Post-Election Announcement Speech | Greenpeace “cautiously hopeful” about new Government | ACT - Madman on the loose | E tū ecstatic | Chamber welcomes the outcome | Greens on their joining Govt | EDS welcomes new govt | Immigrant groups worry | Feds ready to engage new coalition government | Labour Ministers of the Crown announced


Climate: Increasing Greenhouse Emissions Hit NZ

New Zealand is seeing impacts of excess greenhouse gas emissions in our climate and oceans, according to the latest national report from the Ministry for the Environment and Stats NZ about the state of the atmosphere and climate…More>>


Wellington.Scoop: Arrests At Blockade Of "Weapons Expo"

“We encourage people in Wellington to get down to the Westpac Stadium now for a day of awesome peace action. There will be plenty of food, music and activities to keep us sustained through the day.” More>>


Rorschach Restructuring: PSA Taking Inland Revenue To Court Over Psychometrics

The Public Service Association will be seeing Inland Revenue in Employment Court over its intention to psychometrically test employees reapplying for their roles at the department as part of its controversial Business Transformation restructuring plan. More>>


Nuclear Disarmament: Nobel Peace Prize 2017 Awarded To ICAN

Congratulations from iCAN Aotearoa New Zealand to international iCAN, the other iCAN national campaigns and partner organisations, and the countless organisations and individuals who have worked so hard for a nuclear weapons-free world since 1945. More>>


Expenses: Waikato DHB CEO Resigns

An independent inquiry has identified that Dr Murray had spent more than the agreed $25K allocated for relocation costs, and other unauthorized expenses involving potential financial breaches of the chief executive’s obligations. More>>


Wellington.Scoop: Sad About The Trolley Buses?

The Regional Council’s MetLink is today spending money to tell us that it really loves Wellington’s trolley buses, even though they’re all being taken off our roads by the end of this month. More>>


Post-Election: Preliminary Coalition Talks Begin

New Zealand First will hold post-election preliminary discussions in Wellington with the National Party tomorrow morning and the Labour Party tomorrow afternoon. More>>




Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election