Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Scientist Upset At Being Misrepresented By Greens

Australian Scientist Upset At Being Misrepresented By Greens
Green Party co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons has misunderstood the content and relevance of a recent Australian study on canola to New Zealand, says one of the study's co-authors.

Associate Professor Rick Roush expressed surprise at the Greens' comments, and surprise that the Greens had apparently not read the original paper.

“The paper Jeanette Fitzsimons refers to was actually published in the 28 June issue of the journal Science, not in the New Scientist as implied in the Green Party's press release.

"I don't normally even read the New Scientist, which is not a science journal, but a popular magazine about science, and one that I find to be less than generally balanced on the GM issue", said Dr Roush. "I am thus surprised that the Greens have made claims about our science without actually reading it".

"I have no interest in New Zealand politics, but I am not thrilled that our research has been misrepresented by politicians in an effort to gain some advantage."

"Jeanette Fitzsimons has also misunderstood the science. First, canola is recognized around the world as one of the crops most likely to spread pollen. The great majority of other crops, including soybeans, wheat, cotton and maize, are known to have much less dispersal of pollen", Dr Roush noted.

"So far as I can find, canola production isn't a significant industry in New Zealand, so the study is pretty much irrelevant there."

"There also wasn't any surprise that we found canola pollen at 3 kilometers. Organic farmers, Greenpeace, and green politicians had been predicting that the pollen flow would extend for tens of kilometers. If anything, the surprise was that pollen flow was so little", Roush added.

"The average level of pollen flow in our study was 0.009%, and even the highest level was 0.07%, both of which are far lower than the 0.5% upper limit for accidental mixing recently passed on a narrow margin in the EU Parliament with support from Greenpeace. That means that even conventional farmers have nothing to fear from pollen flow in canola."

"With respect to organic growers", Roush responded, "I phoned a list of supposed organic canola farmers provided yesterday by Biological Farmers of Australia, and could not find one that was actually producing any organic canola. After repeated unsuccessful efforts over the last two years to find and talk with organic canola growers, I doubt there is any significant organic canola industry in Australia."

Ms Fitzsimons also claimed that because the Australian study did not involve planting GE canola, the study shows a lot can be learned from studying conventional crops, as well as from lab research.

Roush replied that "Of course scientists have learned a lot of relevant information for GM crops by studying other systems, but you simply cannot understand the environmental benefits and risks of GM crops without studying the real thing in the field"

"Insect resistant GM cotton is now reducing insecticide use and human poisonings in China by some 75-80%. You couldn't find that out from lab studies or studies on non-GM cotton", concluded Roush.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Supreme Court: Worksafe Decision On Whittall Pike River Prosecution Unlawful

The question in issue on the appeal was whether WorkSafe New Zealand acted to give effect to an unlawful agreement of this nature when it offered no evidence on charges against Peter William Whittall for breaches of the Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992...

The Supreme Court... has found that the decision to offer no evidence was made under an unlawful agreement to stifle prosecution. It has granted a declaration to that effect. More>>


Cullen To Chair: Tax Working Group Terms Of Reference Announced

Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Revenue Minister Stuart Nash today announced the Terms of Reference for the Tax Working Group and that the Group will be chaired by Sir Michael Cullen. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The New Pike River Agency (And The Air Strike Wing)

Much of the sympathy the public still feels for the families of the Pike River miners has been sustained by the sense that the previous government – let alone the mining company and the processes of receivership and litigation – has never dealt honestly, or fairly, with them. More>>


Not Going Swimmingly: Contractor Cut, New Dates For Christchurch Sports Centre

“As an incoming Minister, I have been conducting a thorough review of progress on the Anchor projects and to learn of a $75 million budget blowout on this project was very disappointing..." More>>


Tertiary: Allowances, Loan Living Costs To Get Boost

“From 1 January, student allowance base rates and the maximum amount students can borrow for living costs will rise by a net $50 a week,” says Education Minister Chris Hipkins... further adjusted from 1 April 2018 in line with any increase in the CPI. More>>


Foreign Affairs: Patrick Gower Interviews Jacinda Ardern

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says discussions have already begun on how to bring climate change refugees into New Zealand under a Pacific seasonal employment plan... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Centre Right’s Love Of ‘Nanny State’

You’d almost think it was 2005 again. That was a time when the rugged individualists of the centre-right were being beset by government regulations on the nature of light-bulbs, the size of shower heads, the junk food available at school tuck shops and other such essentials... More>>




Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election