Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


The True Colours of Democracy

The True Colours of Democracy

By Michael Reid

Winston’s on a winner—at least so far as older New Zealanders are concerned. Immigration is an issue which polarises people, especially a few weeks out from an election. Passions are easily invoked.

A sensible approach lies somewhere in the middle between passion and apathy.

Whatever we may think about what Mr Peters says, he should be able to raise the issue without the knee-jerk response of ‘racism’. What that does is short-circuit and shut down debate. Who comes to live in our country, is after all, an important issue.

Migrants may come primarily to meet our needs or theirs: the former is usually in response to an economic need (as with an influx of skilled workers to fill an employment gap), while the latter is more humanitarian, as in taking refugees from countries torn apart by full-scale or civil war.

In both cases though, the people arriving will affect the social fabric and the consequences (for better or worse) will be on-going. So it’s is quite legitimate to question the philosophy guiding immigration policy, quotas, resettlement schemes, and so on. To ignore these issues is irresponsible government.

Like many other words, ‘racism’ is easy to bandy about and clobber people with because it has emotive import. But the important questions remain, and Winston Peters, like any other citizen in a parliamentary democracy should be free to ask them.

The same applies to the Treaty of Waitangi: to raise it and express a desire to debate does not equal ‘racism’. To make derogatory remarks and racial slurs about a people group because of their skin colour, does. But constructive debate avoids that.

Political Correctness (PC) doesn’t help because it sees the state as the authority and purveyor of morality. Not individuals, or communities, but the government and the media; they will tell us how to think and behave in ways deemed acceptable to themselves. Indeed, in many cases, it is the continuing impact of PC that hastily leads to the retort of ‘racism’ when immigration and the Treaty are mentioned.

PC also relies heavily on the attendant notions of tolerance and inclusion. Despite its appearance of being non-moral or ‘neutral’, it tries to promote the morality of no morality. But as most of us know, it has the irritating habit of dictating what is acceptable and what is not, especially in public settings.

Inclusion is a populist and compelling concept and one we have heard a lot about in recent years. But if we think about how it might relate to immigration, we’d have to conclude—logically—that we don’t need an immigration policy because no one would could legitimately be excluded. No parameters, no boundaries; open the doors to all and sundry.

What inclusion really means of course—and it is ironic—is that certain groups and ideas are to be promoted by the state and media to the exclusion of others. And what ideas? Those that are PC.

Tolerance and inclusion are fine until they are questioned; then their advocates tend to be anything but tolerant. If, as Winston Peters claims, the Treaty is meant to be about including all New Zealanders but gives preferential treatment to one particular group, then it’s easy to dismiss him as ‘playing the race card.’ However, his central claim about ‘preferential treatment’ needs to be carefully examined to determine if it has any factual basis.

Older New Zealanders love Winston because he talks their language. He appeals to their memories of more cohesive and homogeneous times.

Political correctness (PC) would have us embrace everyone else, but let’s be honest, communication and understanding are hard enough at the best of times, but doubly hard when language and ethnic barriers are present. And it’s harder for older people to accept the changes that come with an influx of a new people group. Winston’s telling his audiences what they already know, but he does it with plenty of kitsch and a very non-PC boldness.

More importantly, sound immigration policy rests on what we consider to be our goals and values as a nation. Thinking about who should or shouldn’t come to live here raises vital questions about who we are and where we want to go. Only when these questions are confronted can a coherent immigration philosophy be formed.

And that’s difficult in New Zealand in 2002. We live in a pluralist nation, where consensus on certain issues, particularly those of a moral nature, is difficult. What would be good for the nation? What should our immigration policy be?

There are no easy answers and the issues are complex. Economic factors alone can’t be the basis because there are social implications too.

The fact that Winston is so readily slated for expressing his views reflects more on those firing the shots than it does on him exercising his democratic rights to say what he says—even if we don’t agree with him.

(825 words)


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Joseph Cederwall: The End Of ‘Objectivity’ In Journalism

... and the dawn of something much better?
2019 looks like it might well be another really bad, terrible, not so good year for the traditional journalism model globally. Already in January three leading US digital outlets—BuzzFeed, the Huffington Post, and Vice announced layoffs that have left many accomplished journalists unemployed. Consolidation of journalism looks set to continue unabated as larger (sharky) media conglomerates swallow up smaller players globally. We also appear to be witnessing the death throes of the concept of ‘objective’ truth in journalism. However, perhaps that is not at all as bad as it sounds, and we are just finally waking up to the reality that it never really existed in the first place... More>>


Environment: Government To End Tenure Review

“Tenure review has resulted in parcels of land being added to the conservation estate, but it has also resulted in more intensive farming and subdivision on the 353,000 ha of land which has been freeholded. This contributed to major landscape change and loss of habitat for native plants and animals,” said Eugenie Sage. More>>


Bell Tolls: Big Changes, Grand Mergers Planned For Vocational Training

“At a time when we’re facing critical skill shortages, too many of our polytechnics and institutes of technology are going broke... More>>


Sallies' State Of The Nation: Progress Stalled In Reducing Inequality

The report shows a lack of tangible progress in key areas including record levels of household debt and a growing gap in educational achievement between poorer and more well off communities. More>>


Party Politics In Tax Morale Survey: SSC To Seek Answers From IRD

Minister of State Services Chris Hipkins has today asked the State Services Commissioner Peter Hughes to examine IRD’s reported inappropriate use of a public survey. More>>


Health: Prohibiting Smoking In Vehicles Carrying Children

Under the change, Police will be able to require people to stop smoking in their cars if children (under 18) are present. Police will also be able to use their discretion to give warnings, refer people to stop-smoking support services, or issue an infringement fee of $50... It is expected that this amendment will become law by the end of 2019. More>>


Waitangi Day: Nationwide Events Commemorate Treaty Signing

“From large-scale events attracting tens of thousands of people such as those at Hoani Waititi Marae in Auckland and the Porirua Waterfront, to smaller gatherings in areas as far flung as the Chatham Islands and to the significant commemorations at Waitangi, these events are an opportunity for us to reflect on the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi.” More>>





InfoPages News Channels