Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 


Why the CPAG Should Lose in Court

Why the CPAG Should Lose in Court

The Child Poverty Action Group is taking the government to court for discriminating against the children of beneficiaries. They want the existing child tax credit, soon to be replaced by the new in-work payment, to be extended to families on benefits - not just low income families who work.

The problem is, the in-work payment is intended as a reward for working.

A working parent might equally claim they were being discriminated against by having their "reward" granted to others who didn't earn it.

In which case, why not remove all discrimination? That is, all children, regardless of the source or level of their parents income, must be treated the same.

That's Green policy - a universal benefit for children, which would include redistribution of income from not so wealthy single people to wealthy Mums and Dads.

Or, it could be argued, provide no assistance at all. Both would solve the problem of discrimination but there is, understandably, little support for either. Most people want fairness and most people care about kids.

And the CPAG has no compunction in exploiting the second sentiment for all its worth.

Its submission to the Human Rights Commission repeatedly refers to the "best interests of the child" and New Zealand's collective obligations under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child.

But pause for a moment and consider; did the beneficiary put the best interests of their child (or potential offspring) first when; getting pregnant outside of a stable relationship; giving birth to a child they could not support, sometimes more than once; leaving a financially and emotionally supportive partner for trivial reasons; deciding that staying home was better than working, even if WINZ held the purse-strings?

(It goes without saying that some beneficiaries are on welfare for genuine reasons but they tend not to remain there long. They are not the "life-stylers".)

You see, I question the motives of the CPAG. They say children of beneficiaries are suffering material deprivation. But that is only part of the picture. A New Zealand study conducted a couple of years back clearly showed that children from comparably 'poor' families had worse outcomes when the parent's source of income was a benefit.

The children from poor working families are better off because they live in homes where there is routine, structure, better budgeting skills, fewer self-destructive behaviours and sometimes, there is even a father in the picture.

So, and I am sure the counsel for government will put this argument, it is in the best interests of the child, on balance, to have at least one working parent. That is taken into account with the in-work payment.

To discourage a child's parent from working or being part of a mutually supportive partnership would be to discriminate against that child. To "reward" all parents equally (it is the parent who receives the benefit payment and there is no guarantee it reaches the child anyway) will do exactly that.

But the CPAG don't understand that enforced equality does not guarantee equality of outcomes. Socialists don't, despite an abundance of grim evidence to the contrary. I wish the government well in their attempts to fight this ill-advised campaign.

Lindsay Mitchell
Petitioner for a Parliamentary review of the DPB

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

 

Ruataniwha: DOC, Hawke's Bay Council Developer Take Supreme Court Appeal

The Department of Conservation and Hawke's Bay Regional Investment Company (HBRIC) are appealing to the Supreme Court over a conservation land swap which the Court of Appeal halted. More>>

ALSO:

With NZ's Marama Davidson: Women’s Flotilla Leaves Sicily – Heading For Gaza

Women representing 13 countries spanning five continents began their journey yesterday on Zaytouna-Oliva to the shores of Gaza, which has been under blockade since 2007. On board are a Nobel Peace Laureate, three parliamentarians, a decorated US diplomat, journalists, an Olympic athlete, and a physician. A list of the women with their background can be found here. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Key Style Of Crisis Management

At Monday’s post Cabinet press conference Key was in his finest wide- eyed “Problem? What problem?” mode. No, there wasn’t really a problem that top MPI officials had been at odds with each other over the meaning of the fisheries policy and how that policy should be pursued... More>>

ALSO:

Mt Roskill: Greens Will Not Stand In Likely Post-Goff By-Election

“The Green Party’s priority is changing the Government in 2017, and as part of that we’ve decided that we won’t stand a candidate in the probable Mt Roskill by-election... This decision shows the Memorandum of Understanding between Labour and the Green Party is working." More>>

ALSO:

Wellington: Predator Free Capital Plan

Wellington City Council (WCC), the Greater Wellington Regional Council (GWRC) and NEXT Foundation, today announced a joint collaboration to make Wellington the first Predator Free capital city in the world. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Judith Collins’ Efforts At Self Correction

Thousands of prisoners currently in prison may be entitled to an earlier release than expected – and compensation – because Corrections has incorrectly calculated their term of imprisonment. Unless of course, the government buries its mistakes by changing the law and retro-actively getting itself off the hook… More>>

ALSO:

More Justice & Corrections

Sector Opposes Bill: Local Government Bill Timeframe Extended

The Minister of Local Government Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga has asked the Select Committee to extend the report back date for the Local Government Act 2002 Amendment Bill (No 2). More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Politics
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news