Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Working for Families breaches international law

2 July 2008

Working for Families breaches international law: policy research

Policy research from the University of Otago Wellington has found that in the initial development of Working for Families (WFF) (2002-May 2004) the Government failed to consider children’s rights, including their right to health, breaching binding international law.

Dr Janine Mardani presented the findings of her thesis at the Public Health Association Conference in Waitangi today. Her evaluation found that despite New Zealand being a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCROC), the Convention was not considered during policy development for Working for Families.

Dr Mardani found that in the development of WFF the New Zealand Government failed to apply the key UNCROC principles: participation of the policy’s stakeholders, equality and freedom from discrimination, the best interests of children as a primary consideration and the right to life with healthy development.

The evaluation reviewed policy development documents obtained under the Official Information Act and interviewed key external stakeholders. “I couldn't find a single piece of evidence to indicate they had taken on board UNCROC or its principles,” she says.

The research shows that in developing WFF, the Government not only neglected to consult appropriate stakeholders, but it refused to allow participation of key child advocates, the Child Poverty Action Group. The Government presented WFF as a ‘fait accompli’ to external stakeholders at the end of policy development, within days of its public release.

“Despite a human rights complaint already laid against the Crown for the Child Tax Credit, the developers didn't consult the Human Rights Commission or the Office of the Commissioner for Children.

“The Government has subsequently described in the UNCROC work programme how the WFF package is an initiative to improve the social wellbeing of disadvantaged children in New Zealand,” said Dr Mardani.

She found, although the package benefited many thousands of children, it cannot be seen as a package primarily for vulnerable children because it discriminates against those most at risk; children who have parents reliant on state benefits. The package not only offers them little or no advantage, but a relative disadvantage compared to less vulnerable children.

“Vulnerable children with parents reliant on state benefits did not have their best interests prioritised,” said Dr Mardani. Rather than using UNCROC’s principle that the best interest of the child should be a primary consideration, policy makers’ stated priority was that of economic performance. The new benefits were aimed squarely at working families earning $25,000-$45,000 prioritised above families on an income of $15,000-$25,000.

WFF also failed to take into account UNCROC’s principle of recognising children’s right to healthy development which includes access to the determinants of health like an adequate income. “Any child impact analysis would have told the policy makers that while WFF was going to help a number of families it would make others relatively worse off, and you would expect this to increase relative health inequalities.”

In the last two UN reviews of the New Zealand Government’s adherence to the Rights of the Child, it has requested the Government reviews all legislation affecting children and takes the necessary measures to harmonise legislation with the principles and provisions of the Convention.

In her conclusions, Dr Mardani recommends that UNCROC be recognised in legislation so that under New Zealand law, the rights of children are not disregarded in policy development.

“Even the Human Rights Act allows discrimination against children on the basis of age,” she said.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Back Again: Government Approves TPP11 Mandate

The Government has approved a negotiating mandate for Trans-Pacific Partnership 11 (TPP11), which will ensure New Zealand businesses remain competitive in overseas markets.

Trade Minister Todd McClay says New Zealand will be pushing for the minimal number of changes possible to the original TPP agreement, something that the remaining TPP11 countries have agreed on. More>>




Gordon Campbell: On Why Labour Isn’t Responsible For Barnaby Joyce

As a desperate Turnbull government tries to treat the Barnaby Joyce affair as a Pauline Hanson fever dream – blame it on the foreigners! We’re the victims of the dastardly New Zealand Labour Party! – our own government has chosen to further that narrative, and make itself an accomplice. More>>


Rail: Greens Back Tauranga – Hamilton – Auckland Service

The Green Party today announced that it will trial a passenger rail service between Auckland, Hamilton and Tauranga starting in 2019, when it is in government. More>>


Housing: Voluntary Rental Warrant Of Fitness For Wellington

Wellington City Council is partnering with the University of Otago, Wellington, to launch a voluntary Rental Warrant of Fitness for minimum housing standards in Wellington, Mayor Justin Lester has announced. More>>


Treaty: Agreement In Principle Signed With Moriori

“The Crown acknowledges Moriori was left virtually landless from 1870, hindering its cultural, social and economic development. The Crown also acknowledges its contribution to the myths that the people of Moriori were racially inferior and became extinct." More>>


Susan Devoy: Call For Inquiry Into State Abuse Reaches UN

Race Relations Commissioner Dame Susan Devoy is in Geneva and has asked a United Nations committee to urge the New Zealand government to initiate an inquiry into the physical and sexual abuse of children and disabled people held in state institutions. More>>


(Not National): Cross-Party Agreement On Pike River Re-Entry

The commitment was signed this afternoon by the leaders of Labour, United Future, The Maori Party, and the Green Party and, together with the earlier commitment by New Zealand First, means that there is now a Parliamentary majority behind the families’ fight for truth and justice. More>>






Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election
  • PublicAddress
  • Pundit
  • Kiwiblog