Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Former Nat MPs call for Commission of Inquiry

Former Nat MPs & author call for Commission of Inquiry



25 November 2008

Hon. Simon Power Minister of Justice Parliament Buildings WELLINGTON

Dear Minister Congratulations on your appointment to the role of Minister of Justice. We are confident that you will undertake this challenging role with the competence and acumen you demonstrated while in Opposition.

The subject of this letter will come as no surprise to you. We have held serious concerns about the Peter Ellis/Christchurch Civic Creche Case for a long time. In our view, the time is long overdue for the Minister responsible for our justice system to demonstrate the political will and moral courage necessary to ensure that a comprehensive and genuinely independent inquiry is held into what is widely regarded as New Zealand’s most egregious miscarriage of justice. We ask you to commission an overseas judge to review the entire case. We believe this is the only realistic option left. In support of this proposal, we offer the following points: • Though fifteen years have passed since the controversial conviction of Peter Ellis, disquiet over the Civic Creche case remains widespread and ongoing. Despite the best efforts of the previous government to bury the problem, the public has refused to let the matter rest.

• In the history of New Zealand criminal justice, no petition to Parliament has been supported by such a weight of political, legal and scholarly authority as the 2003 petition calling for A Royal Commission of Inquiry, presided over by a judge or judges from outside the New Zealand jurisdiction, to inquire into all aspects of the investigation and legal processes relating to the Christchurch Civic Creche case. Among the hundreds of petitioners were two former Prime Ministers, 12 former Cabinet Ministers, 28 MPs from every party in the House, 12 Law Professors, 10 Queen’s Counsel, a retired High Court Judge and four Psychology Professors.

• The Civic Creche case is recognised internationally as a manifestation of a wave of child abuse hysteria that swept the western world in the 1990s. Hundreds of innocent childcare workers were convicted of bizarre and often impossible crimes against very young children. Yet in all these cases there was no reliable evidence that any crime had ever taken place. The convictions were based solely on the coerced evidence of very young children. Most of the overseas cases have now been overturned. In the Creche case some of the accusing children have retracted their allegations. New academic research has highlighted the unreliability of the children’s testimony. That the wrongs done in the Creche case have not been righted after all this time is nothing short of a scandal.

• Among the charges faced by Peter Ellis was an allegation that he was party to an offence committed by an unknown man at an unknown place on an unknown time and date. Despite the absurdity of that charge, not only did the jury convict him, but their verdict was upheld twice by the Court of Appeal, and again by a Ministerial Inquiry conducted by former Chief Justice Sir Thomas Eichelbaum. Clearly, in the Creche case, the justice system has failed repeatedly, and has been unable to self-correct.

• The Creche case began with the ambiguous comment of a 3-year-old boy and ended with a bitterly divided city, scores of families thrown into turmoil, 12 childcare workers stripped of their jobs and their previously unblemished reputations, four childcare workers arrested and discharged, and one (Peter Ellis) convicted and sentenced to 10 years in jail. For everyone involved in the case, that was too high a price to pay. A full enquiry is needed to ensure that the mistakes made in the Creche case will not be repeated.

• This is exactly the sort of rare occasion when it is incumbent on the Minister of Justice to restore public confidence in the justice system by invoking his constitutional power to order a Commission of Inquiry into a criminal case. As well as inquiring into “all aspects of the investigation and legal processes relating to the Christchurch Civic Creche case” (as requested by the 2003 petition) the presiding judge should be given the power to recommend a pardon for Peter Ellis if he or she finds that a miscarriage of justice has occurred.

• Because many senior New Zealand judges have had some involvement in the Creche case, it is imperative that an overseas judge be brought in to head the inquiry.

• The last Commission of Inquiry into a criminal case in New Zealand was ordered by the Rt. Hon. Sir Robert Muldoon into the conviction of Arthur Allan Thomas. That inquiry was conducted by an Australian judge.

• The Commission of Inquiry into the Thomas case was completed early and under budget. An inquiry into the Creche case need not be an unduly expensive exercise.

• Calls for an inquiry into the Thomas case were strenuously opposed by the officials advising government, but their predictions of dire consequences for the justice system proved to be without foundation. The opposition of officials to calls for an inquiry into the Creche case has been equally vehement. Nevertheless, the Minister has the constitutional power to override the vested interests of his advisors and order an inquiry. In our view, to do so will be widely hailed as a brave and necessary act.

• Two mutually-contradictory arguments frequently advanced by Justice officials opposed to an inquiry are that, on the one hand, the accused has not exhausted his legal options, and that, on the other hand, the case has been repeatedly examined and should be allowed to rest. At the time of Arthur Allan Thomas’s pardon his case had been the subject of two trials, four Court of Appeal hearings, three petitions to the Governor General and one hearing before Privy Council. The Peter Ellis case has been the subject of one trial, two Court of Appeal hearings, three petitions to the Governor General, an enquiry by a High Court Judge, a Ministerial Inquiry and a petition to Parliament resulting in a Select Committee inquiry. But just as Thomas’s legal options were not exhausted, so Ellis’s legal options are not exhausted. The soul-destroying legal merry-go-round could go on forever. It is time for the Minister to put a stop to this cynical game-playing with a comprehensive and genuinely independent Commission of Inquiry.

• In view of the complexity of this case, the time that has already elapsed and the scores of people whose lives have been blighted by the case, the resolution of this matter cannot be deferred for consideration by a yet-to-be-established Criminal Case Review Commission. Further, unlike the other criminal convictions currently causing public disquiet, in the Creche case there was no reliable evidence that any crime was ever committed. For all these reasons the Creche case warrants its own comprehensive inquiry without delay.

• In Australia the notion that the justice system is sometimes unable to correct its own mistakes seems to be better understood. Between 1940 and 1990, Frederick McDermott, Edward Platt, the Ananda Marga trio, Douglas Rendall, Lindy Chamberlain and Ziggy Pohl were all pardoned following Commissions of Inquiry. These inquiries proved to be constructive and worthwhile exercises. The Australian justice system is more robust and transparent as a result.

We trust you will give this ongoing source of public distrust in our justice system your urgent and serious attention.

We would be happy to discuss this request with you further at any time.

Yours sincerely

Katherine Rich, Dunedin Lynley Hood, Dunedin Don Brash, Auckland

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Crowdsale And Crowdfunding Campaign: Help Create The Future Of Independent News

Two weeks to go! The Scoop 3.0 plan aims to create NZ’s first community-owned, distributed news and media intelligence ecosystem in 2019. We believe this ScoopPro media monetisation approach can be scaled and spread globally to support local and independent news efforts in regional New Zealand and around the world.

Scoop is an ecosystem, it would not exist without those who contribute to it, read it and rely on it for professional media purposes. Generous past support from this ecosystem has enabled us to come this far in developing our business model. Support our PledgeMe Campaign>>

 

14/11: Two Years’ Progress Since The Kaikoura Earthquake

Mayor John Leggett said it was a day for reflection, but also a time to recognise the work by many people to support progress towards recovery made across Marlborough since November 2016. More>>

ALSO:

Pike River: Mine Drift Re-Entry Plan To Proceed

“I’ve decided the Te Kāhui Whakamana Rua Tekau Mā Iwa - Pike River Recovery Agency, recommended course of action to enter the drift, using the existing access tunnel, is by far the safest option,” said Andrew Little. More>>

ALSO:

Appointments: New High Commissioner To Australia Announced

“Dame Annette King needs no introduction given her long running career as a parliamentarian where she has previously held a number senior Cabinet portfolios, including Justice, Police and Health. She also was Parliament’s longest serving female MP with 30 years’ service,” said Mr Peters. More>>

ALSO:

Two Years Since Kaikoura: Silvia Cartwright To Lead Inquiry Into EQC

“The inquiry will be the first of its kind under the Public Inquiries Act 2013 and will have all the powers of a Royal Commission, be independent of Government and make its report directly to the Governor-General. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Royal Commission Into Child Abuse

Obviously, it is good news that the coalition government has broadened the scope of its Royal Commission into the abuse of children, beyond its previous focus on children in state care. More>>

ALSO:

Cases Delayed: Court Staff Refuse To Handle Sentencing Papers

Dozens of court cases have reportedly been delayed, as court staff escalate industrial action at two Auckland courts by enforcing a ban on handling sentencing papers. More>>

ALSO:

Education: Primary Teachers Rolling Strikes

RNZ Report: More than 100,000 primary school students in Auckland will be home from school today as teachers and principals walk off the job for the second time this year. It's the start of a week of rolling one-day strikes around the country, after the collapse of contract negotiations last Thursday. More>>

ALSO:

"Process Was Sound": Inquiry Into Haumaha Appointment Released

The Inquiry’s purpose was to examine, identify, and report on the adequacy of the process that led to the appointment. It found the process was sound and no available relevant information was omitted. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels