Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Greenpeace ad hominem attack rejected

The New Zealand
Climate Science Coalition

7 March 2009

Ad hominem attacks no substitute for science in climate change debate

The personal criticism of Prime Minister John Key for his stance on climate change issues are typical of the ad hominem attack tactics that Greenpeace and similar zealots like Labour MP Charles Chauvel resort to when they lack scientific basis for argument, according to Terry Dunleavy, secretary of the New Zealand Climate Science Coalition.

He was commenting on the statement by Mr Chauvel in Parliament this week that John Key had told Investigate Magazine that he wanted to ‘have flexibility so that if the science deteriorates and the climate change sceptics are right we have an ability to alter the impact on our economy’. As a result of learning of the Prime Minister’s comments, Greenpeace, “one of the world’s leading NGOs in the climate change area”, advised that it would not be participating further in the ETS Review Select Committee. Greenpeace went on to say that John Key’s comments were ‘irresponsible’ and ‘embarrassing’ and that the Government has ‘no credible programme for tackling this growing global crisis’.

“To those of us involved in the debate about climate change, these ad hominem attack tactics are nothing new,” said Mr Dunleavy. “Greenpeace has been at it for years, causing one of its co-founders Dr Patrick Moore to quit in disgust at these tactics of shooting the messenger when unable to rebut the facts of the message. Now, it seems, they have attracted a new recruit, Charles Chauvel, whose assertion that Greenpeace is one of the world’s leading NGOs in the climate change area conveniently conceals the fact that it has no more scientific status or credibility than his own NGO, the New Zealand Labour Party. Both are political advocates blinded by mistaken belief that hysterical assertions of zealotry are acceptable substitutes for the truths of science.

“No wonder Greenpeace has taken the first excuse it could find to toss its toys out of the cot rather than participate in the forthcoming review of the Labour/Greens emissions trading scheme legislation by a special Parliamentary Select Committee. Far from being settled, as the zealots claim, the science of climate change is moving rapidly to belated recognition that there is no valid evidence for claims that human-caused emissions of carbon dioxide can or will cause dangerous ‘global warming’, a fact that becomes increasingly more obvious as world temperatures have cooled since 2002, in spite of a continuing small rise in levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere.

“Prime Minister Key and his National-led government are being highly responsible in keeping their options open pending the deliberations of the Select Committee in a review that was initiated by the only MP in the present Parliament who does possess credible qualifications: Act leader Hon Rodney Hide, who holds a master’s degree in environmental science, and who made the review a condition of his party’s confidence and supply agreement with National.

“Here is just one example of why it is so vital that New Zealand addresses the science of climate change: although our economy is so highly dependent on agriculture, the previous government made the astonishing decision to include agriculture in the activities it signed up to under the Kyoto Protocol, the only signatory to make such a concession. As a result, while US cattle farmers are now being ‘subsidised’ by their ability to sell carbon credits generated by the carbon dioxide sequestered by their annual pasture grasses, New Zealand cattle farmers would be penalised under our existing emissions trading scheme by the need to purchase carbon credits to compensate for the methane generated by their belching ruminants. The science supporting the American position is better founded than the science claimed to support our decision to include ruminant methane as an anthropogenic greenhouse gas. Cows don't run on fossil fuels. Indeed, US scientists have concluded that New Zealand pasture is a more effective carbon sink than American rangeland because our pasture grasses are perennial and have a deeper and more extensive root system.

“Whether or not there was the over-arching global financial meltdown now causing governments like those in Europe and Australia to re-think their emissions trading policies, the costs to New Zealanders of the measures legislated by the previous government to mitigate so-called climate change are of such a magnitude that it is highly responsible for the new Key Government to be absolutely certain of the science before committing us to costs well into the billions of dollars,” Mr Dunleavy concluded.

He was speaking from New York where, as executive vice-chairman of the International Climate Science Coalition, he is attending the 2nd International Conference on Climate Change, at which he will present a paper entitled ‘Consensus’ in climate science – an unsubstantiated urban myth, rebutting claims that assessment reports by the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) are the work of thousands of scientists.

Another New Zealander, Dr Kesten Green, of Wellington, an internationally respected expert on the principles of forecasting will speak at the same conference, on the topic: Validity of climate change forecasting for public policy decision making.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Ellen Rykers on The Dig: Community Conservation – The Solution To The Biodiversity Crisis?

There are backyard trapping networks doing their bit for Predator Free 2050, farmers planting native trees along their waterways, and iwi protecting whenua rāhui. There are 62 biodiversity sanctuaries across 56,000 hectares, with around two-thirds of them community-led. There are citizen scientists counting birds in their backyards and landowners conserving habitat in 3,500 Queen Elizabeth II National Trust covenants.

It’s increasingly clear that a government agency alone cannot combat the biodiversity crisis successfully. These grass-roots initiatives are a growing resource in the conservation toolbox. More>>

Closing This Weekend! Have Your Say On The Issues For NZ's New Biodiversity Strategy

Scoop and PEP invite you to help decide how we should protect and restore our biodiversity over the next 50 years using Scoop’s online engagement platform, HiveMind. HAVE YOUR SAY HERE>>


PM In Japan: Jacinda Ardern’s Remarks Following Abe Summit

Today we discussed a wide range of topics. Broadly the themes were: a deeper, high-value trade and investment relationship, greater cooperation in the Pacific; and strengthening our security partnership. More>>


Replacing All But Chair: Twyford Appoints Five NZTA Board Members

Transport Minister Phil Twyford today announced the appointment of five new members to the NZ Transport Agency Board... There remain two vacancies on the NZTA Board which will be filled in due course. More>>


Climate Change: Adaptation And Risk Assessment Framework Released

“We are already experiencing the effects of a changing climate such as coastal inundation and increasingly frequent and severe droughts, floods, fires and storms. This framework is an acknowledgement that we must start adapting”, James Shaw said today. More>>


Ihumātao: Mana Whenua Reach Decision On Land

Māori King Tūheitia says mana whenua have finally reached consensus over what to do with Ihumātao - they want it back. More>>


PM To Japan, New York: Ardern To Meet Trump During UN Trip

“I’m looking forward to discussing a wide range of international and regional issues with President Trump, including our cooperation in the Pacific and the trade relationship between our countries." More>>

PM's Post-Cab: "A Way Forward"

At Monday's post-cabinet press conference, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced a number of actions in response to the Labour Party's mishandling of sexual assault complaints. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Allegations Of Left Wing Media Bias

“Left wing bias” accusations date back at least to the mid 1990s... The charge of left wing bias was ridiculous then, and is ridiculous now. More>>

Next Wave Of Reforms: Gun Registration And Licensing Changes Announced

“The Bill includes a register to track firearms and new offences and penalties that can be applied extraterritorially for illegal manufacture, trafficking, and for falsifying, removing, or altering markings – which are a new requirement under the Firearms Protocol.” More>>





InfoPages News Channels