Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Not a job for Ministers, says Law Commission

Not a job for Ministers, says Law Commission

Decisions about the on-going detention and status of „special patients committed indefinitely to compulsory care by the criminal courts should be made by a specialist tribunal rather than the Minister of Health.

This is one of the key recommendations contained in the Law Commissions latest report Mental Impairment Decision-Making and the Insanity Defence (NZLC R120, December 2010), published and tabled in Parliament today.

The recommendation relates to those cases where criminal charges end in an acquittal by reason of insanity, or a finding of unfitness to stand trial.

A judge then decides under section 24 of the Criminal Procedure (Mentally Impaired Persons) Act 2003 whether to indefinitely commit the mentally-impaired person, in the interests of public safety.

Depending on whether they are mentally disordered, or intellectually disabled, a person committed under section 24 usually then become a „special patient or „special care recipient.

Currently the Minister of Health is responsible for deciding when such patients may be discharged from compulsory care, or reclassified as a civil patient, or permitted long leave of more than seven days. Sometimes, the Attorney-General is also involved.

Instead, the Law Commission says that a new „Special Patients Review Tribunal should be established. It would be chaired by a judge, and would sit in panels of three to five experts, dealing with discharge, reclassification, and long leave decisions.

“It is not appropriate for this to be a job for Ministers,” said the Commissioner responsible for the project, Warren Young.

“These decisions need to be managed expertly and independently. This is as desirable for Ministers, as it is for the patients. For everybodys benefit, our proposal would remove the risk or perception of politicisation around what are sometimes quite controversial decisions.”

The Commission considered recommending that decisions be made by the existing Mental Health Review Tribunal, which already reviews the status of civilly-committed mentally disordered patients. But there was concern about bringing intellectually disabled people under the mental health framework, and implicitly labelling them as „disordered. These people have quite different needs.

The Commission concluded that a Tribunal, capable of managing both types of cases, was required, chaired by a judge. The number of hearings each year would be small (around 50 a year). A Tribunal, in the Commissions opinion, was the most robust, and relatively low cost, solution to address the issues. This is what happens in most other jurisdictions.

The Commission also considered the insanity defence in section 23 of the Crimes Act 1961, concluding that it should not be reformed.

“Section 23 is quite an old-fashioned sounding defence, based on legal rules developed in 1843. But when we looked at all of the reform options, none of them were better than the status quo,” said Dr Young.

“The current defence, despite the problems with the way in which it is framed, is working well in practice. The people we consulted by and large did not want it to be overhauled. Even simply updating the old-fashioned language (to refer, for example, to „mental impairment rather than „insanity, „intellectual disability rather than „natural imbecility, and „mental disorder rather than „disease of the mind) would create undesirable uncertainty.”

Insanity defences overseas are generally based on similar rules as those currently existing in New Zealand. Literature reviewed by the Law Commission suggested that when reform of those rules has been attempted overseas, it has generally made no difference to outcomes.

The full report can be found at www.lawcom.govt.nz

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Now-Former Cyclone: States of Emergency Declared

A state of emergency has been declared in Buller, Greymouth and Christchurch, with fears some homes are at a high risk of flooding over the next day.

High tides overnight were likely to bring large waves to Kaikōura and Christchurch about 9pm, and to Taranaki, Kāpiti and Nelson about 2am.

The latest severe weather update has upgraded watches for heavy rain in Christchurch, Banks Peninsula and North Otago to full warnings...More>>

 
 

Kauri Protection: Waitākere Forest Closure Proposed

At the 20 February meeting of the Environment and Community Committee, the council proposed to close the forested areas of the Waitākere Ranges Regional Park, with some exceptions, by 1 May 2018. More>>

ALSO:

'Hit And Run' Raid: NZDF Had Reports Of Civilian Casualties

The NZDF received intelligence updates within one or two days of the August 2010 SAS raid in Afghanistan that reported civilian casualties, including the death of a child, new OIA documents reveal... it appears they did not bother to investigate nor made any effort to help the victims. More>>

ALSO:

Christchurch Public Meeting: Complete U-Turn By Labour And NZ First On TPP

The TPP might have been re-branded as the CPTPP but it's still the same bad deal says Professor Jane Kelsey, New Zealand's expert on international economic regulation. More>>

ALSO:

Commerce, Etc: Thicker Bright Line For Real Estate

Revenue Minister Stuart Nash has confirmed the bright-line test on residential property sales will be extended from two years to five years in legislation currently making its way through Parliament.More>>

ALSO:

Prison Inspections: Reports on Manawatu and Paremoremo Released

The Office of the Inspectorate today released reports into Manawatu Prison and Auckland Prison (Paremoremo), the first two resulting from a programme of inspections of New Zealand prisons. More>>

Whistle Blowers: Government To Review Law On Protection

Work has begun on a review of the Protected Disclosures Act 2000, Minister of State Services Chris Hipkins said today. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages