|
| ||
Workers not helped by superannuation proposal |
||
27 October 2011
Workers not helped by superannuation proposal
Labour’s superannuation policy would backfire on workers, says BusinessNZ.
Chief Executive Phil O’Reilly says the plan for compulsory employer contributions equivalent to 7 percent of employees’ wages would impose grim costs on businesses, to the detriment of business and economic growth.
“But this would also mean lower wages as employers take the contributions into account when setting wages.
“It could also potentially lead to some job loss at the margins.”
Mr O’Reilly said many employees would be worse off with the abolition of the opt-out provision.
“Compulsion does not suit everyone’s needs. Compulsory saving even at 2 percent of wages will cause real hardship to some, making it harder to care for a family, save for a home or provide for children’s education.”
Mr O’Reilly said it was questionable whether there was a need for further compulsion given KiwiSaver’s enrolment success as a voluntary scheme.
“In setting this policy the Labour Party refers to Australia’s Age Pension scheme – but Australia’s compulsory scheme has significant differences from Labour’s proposal, including income and asset testing.
“It is not a valid comparison to imply that the scheme proposed by Labour would achieve the same savings levels as Australia’s.
“There is no strong evidence that KiwiSaver in its current form has increased net savings, nor any evidence that Labour’s proposal would do any better.
“However one area of Labour’s policy that employers will agree with is the lifting of the entitlement age. This element of Labour’s policy is realistic and positive.”
ENDS


Meridian dumps West Coast hydro plan
Fisheries: Slave Labour And Foreign Vessels
Budget 2012: Crime And Punishment
Elections: Time Running Out to Take Part in Electoral Commission’s MMP Review
Christchurch: More Green Zoning And More Red Zoning
Budget 2012: Squeezing Every Drop Out Of A Zero Budget
Housing: Social Housing Money Handed Out

Budget 2012: Prescription Charges Help Fund Health
Court of Appeal: Govt Should Pay Family Caregivers
Police: 120 Positions Axed In Fine Tuning
Water: Call For Quality Bottom Lines
MFaT: Cuts Scaled Back, Embassies Closed
Budget 2012: Education – Larger Classes For More Money
