Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Q+A Panel Discussion on Annette King and Te Ururoa Flavell

Panel Discussion in Response to Annette King and Te Ururoa Flavell Interviews

Hosted by PAUL HOLMES

PAUL                  Time to welcome the panel. This morning, Dr Raymond Miller from Auckland University. Very nice to have you back. And Deborah Coddington is with us, the former ACT MP and columnist. And we also welcome John Tamihere, former Labour minister, chief executive of the Waipareira Trust and radio talk-show host extraordinaire. So what do you make of the revelations, then? Howard Broad wants a meeting. Senior cabinet ministers are assembled. There's going to be an operation tomorrow. Tells nothing much about it. Next night on the news, it’s ninjas everywhere and an extraordinary scale, and it’s happening with David Collins’ approval under the Suppression of Terrorism Act.

DR RAYMOND MILLER – Political Analyst
                           Well, this is quite a remarkable interview, I think, because it adds another layer of intrigue to a sordid story. You know, here were two things going on, according to Annette King. One, the scale of the police operation was not revealed to them. She said she would only expect to be advised, but clearly they were surprised the next day when they saw the scale of the operation. The second thing is they would rely on the solicitor general for advice on legal matters. The solicitor general and the Crown Law Office are important, particularly given that Michael Cullen, who was attorney general, was not a trained lawyer – only the second time in history that that’s been the case. And so clearly they were deeply disappointed that they felt a sense of being misled.

PAUL                  Well, this is extraordinary. They turned to David Collins in the meeting and said, “Is the use of this act appropriate in this situation?” He assured them it was, and a month later, of course, dumps on them.

RAYMOND         Some fairness here to the extent that David Collins himself might have been surprised at the scale of the operation and not have known all the details about how much had been collected or how little had been collected as hard evidence.

JOHN TAMIHERE – Former Labour Minister
                           To his... I don’t know the detail, right, so we’re speculating here, but I would anticipate that once he went through the substance of the evidence – he would have been briefed by the police – he might well have said to them, “Well, there’s enough, if this is all hunky-dory, for you to proceed.” He wouldn’t have known the operational details. Then in retrospect, as you start to sieve through what exactly police evidence is, you have some problems.

DEBORAH CODDINGTON – Former ACT Party MP
                           Yes, but that’s not why he said for them not to proceed with all of the 18. The reason why he said not to proceed under the act was because he said the act was unwieldy and unnecessarily complicated,...

PAUL                  Yeah, suddenly decides it’s incoherent.

DEBORAH         ...not because of the evidence. I think a wider inquiry is necessary – not necessarily a royal commission. A select committee inquiry. A select committee is very powerful. It can summon anyone to appear before it. It’s very quick. You know, David Collins has now been rewarded with a High Court judge position. I mean, this is remarkable what Annette King has revealed.

PAUL                  Can I say, the other thing is in my discussions with Annette King on Friday, she said, “We were assured by David Collins that any charges laid would be under the Suppression of Terror Act.” Yesterday when I spoke to her again, she said, “No, no, we were told by David Collins the investigation had been conducted under the Suppression of Terror Act and he must therefore have been satisfied with that.” Therefore one can conclude, can one not, that he knew some of the substance of what the investigation was turning out?

JOHN                 Yeah, well, I don’t know. That’s why it probably needs another inquiry. The fact is, though, that they overcooked this one. When you send 300 policemen into a valley and you turn over a whole community, when you know you can count on one hand the number of possible suspects – we know that now. They turned over a whole village. Now, that’s just unacceptable police conduct.

DEBORAH         We’ve ended up with four people convicted on firearms charges and Molotov cocktails, and in the context of the history of that place – you know, there are startling and alarming parallels with Rua Kenana with Te Urewera. And, you know, this is just an appalling blot again on our history. I’m not saying people should be able to run around with firearms and things, but this was on private land. You know, the Supreme Court...

PAUL                  It wasn’t just the Ureweras. It’s like you have pictures of ninja policemen bursting into Aro St in Wellington. I mean to say it was like the country had gone mad.

RAYMOND         Yeah, well, this is the other thing about police action. In fact, there's a long history, I think, of what one defence lawyer described as the police world and the other – the real world. In a sense, the police, for a long period of time, have tried to identify and get inside criminal groups, as they see them, back to the Springbok Tour, 1981, unions, and you could go on. And really this overreaction, this over-zealotry on the part of...

PAUL                  Yes, it was like the boys got overexcited.

RAYMOND         Yes, exactly.

DEBORAH         It took four years for these people to come to trial. Four years!

PAUL                  Yes, yes, there's also that.

DEBORAH         I mean, the whole thing does need, I think, an inquiry to make sure it doesn’t happen again.

PAUL                  Yeah, alright. So a select committee, you would think?

DEBORAH         Well, something like a select committee.

PAUL                  Something outside of Lowell Goddard’s province.

DEBORAH         Yeah, well, that’s just focused on the police. It goes wider than that.

PAUL                  That’s cool. Now, what about, in defence of the police, to finish our discussion – are you pleased with what you heard Peter Marshall...

DEBORAH         Very pleased, yes.

PAUL                  ...say in his statement to us? He obviously knows...

RAYMOND         Yeah, it’s taken a long time, I might say. It’s taken a long time.

PAUL                  Well, it does with the cops.

RAYMOND         Yes, right.

JOHN                 Look, they wouldn’t... Context is important, but if they had four or five suspects... They didn’t turn the whole of that community over in Aro St. They went straight in and got the suspects they wanted. They had no right to go into the community and turn the whole bloody thing over. I felt violated by that, right, for them. I just don’t think they’re regretful enough. I don’t think they’ve apologised to Tūhoe enough, and they’ve got some work to do.

DEBORAH         The Supreme Court said...

PAUL                  Especially... I’ve got to go, but especially when you look at the whole history of New Zealand government’s actions towards the Tūhoe.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

ETS Entry Delayed To 2025: "World-First" Plan On Farm Emissions

The Government and farming sector leaders have agreed to a world-first partnership to reduce primary sector emissions in one of the most significant developments on climate action in New Zealand's history.

Today farming leaders and the Government announced a plan to join forces to develop practical and cost-effective ways to measure and price emissions at the farm level by 2025, so that 100 per cent of New Zealand's emissions will be on the path downwards. More>>

 

RNZ Live Updates: SkyCity Fire Fighting Continues

The fire at the centre across from SkyCity in Auckland has been burning since about 1pm on Tuesday and firefighters are allowing the roof to be destroyed by flames so they can get better access to the building to fight the fire. Flames are still visible this morning and smoke is billowing out. More>>

ALSO:

Terrorism Suppression Bill: Rights, Procedure Proctection Win Green Support

The Green Party has negotiated important civil liberties changes in the proposed which will now establish human rights and process safeguards. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Simon Bridges And Political Correctness

Having failed all year at being a credible alternative Prime Minister, National leader Simon Bridges has lowered his aspirational target this week to something more within his range. More>>

Bullying: Police Commissioner Announces Review

Police Commissioner Mike Bush has today announced an independent review of the systems and processes NZ Police has in place to address complaints of bullying. More>>

ALSO:

PM's Post-Cab: Now We Are Two

Questions covered Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters' comments on the potential closure of Mediaworks' television channels, the Auckland light rail planning process, the select committee report on the Zero Carbon Bill and its methane target range... More>>

Court Issues New Guildines: Revamp Of Meth Sentencing Welcomed

The court accepted submissions by both the New Zealand Bar Association and the New Zealand Law Society that rather than solely focusing on the quantity of meth involved, there should be greater focus on the role of the offender. More>>

ALSO:

'Armed Response Teams': Armed Police "Will Cause American-Style Shootings"

The Police Commissioner's announcement that squadcars of officers with automatic rifles will patrol New Zealand's streets is dangerous and unnecessary, according to the criminal justice community organisation People Against Prisons Aotearoa. The ... More>>

ALSO:

Control Orders: Amnesty Says Don't Rush Terrorism Bill

"The problem is, we often see the word “terrorism” being applied broadly by oppressive regimes to detain innocent people who're simply rallying for a better life." More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels