Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 


Judgment: GCSB added to Dotcom proceedings

[The following are extracts from the full judgment. The original PDF is at Dotcom__Ors_v_Atorney_General__DC_North_Shore.pdf]


IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV-2012-404-001928

[2012] NZHC 3268
UNDER the Judicature Act 1972
IN THE MATTER OF an application for judicial review
BETWEEN KIM DOTCOM First Plaintiff
AND FINN BATATO Second Plaintiff
AND MATHIAS ORTMANN Third Plaintiff
AND BRAM VAN DER KOLK Fourth Plaintiff
AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL First Defendant
AND THE DISTRICT COURT AT NORTH SHORE Second Defendant
Hearing: 14 November 2012
Counsel: P J Davison QC, W Akel and R Woods for First Plaintiff GJ Foley for Second, Third and Fourth Plaintiffs J C Pike and FRJ Sinclair for First Defendant DPH Jones QC, Amicus SBW Grieve QC, Special Advocate
Judgment: 5 December 2012

JUDGMENT OF WINKELMANN J

This judgment was delivered by me on 5 December 2012 at 2.15 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar


[1] The plaintiffs apply to join an additional defendant, amend the statement of claim, and for additional discovery. The background to these applications is as follows. I have previously determined that aspects of a Police search and seizure in January 2012, in connection with the plaintiffs, were illegal. Following on from that finding, there was a hearing in August 2012 to consider the plaintiffs’ allegations that the Police search and seizure of the Dotcom mansion was unreasonable because it was illegal, and because the force used was excessive in all the circumstances. I refer to this hearing as the remedies hearing.

[2] Following the conclusion of the remedies hearing, material came to light which showed that the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) had been intercepting the communications of the first and fourth plaintiffs, Mr Dotcom and Mr van der Kolk. The first defendant concedes that those interceptions were unlawful.

[3] The revelation that the Police had access to intercepted communications gathered by the GCSB created difficulty in the conduct of this litigation. This is material which is likely relevant, at least in part, to an assessment of the circumstances as the Police understood them to be, when they planned the search of the Dotcom property. If so, it is material which should have been available for the remedies hearing. There is further difficulty, however, because the GCSB claims that disclosure of those communications will prejudice New Zealand’s national security interests as it will tend to reveal intelligence gathering and sharing methods. The first defendant also challenges the relevance of the documents, and says, even if they are relevant, I should direct, pursuant to s 70 of the Evidence Act 2006, that they should not be disclosed in the proceeding.

[...]

[42] A summary of my rulings is as follows:

(a) The GCSB is joined as a defendant to these proceedings.

(b) Leave is granted to the plaintiffs to amend their claim, in accordance with the draft pleading filed, to seek declarations about the legality of the GCSB’s actions and to seek damages against the Police and the GCSB.

(c) I will inspect any documents relating to the topics identified at pages 76 and 172 of the blue folder (other than those relating to the financial institutions briefing) in order to determine relevance.

(d) The GCSB is to provide discovery of documents in accordance with paragraphs [27] – [30].

(e) Detective Superintendent Pannett is to provide an affidavit in which he deposes whether he viewed a live feed of any aspect of the New Zealand termination operations and, if he did, provides details particularising the timing and enabling identification of the source of that feed and the locations and events being filmed.

(f) Detective Inspectors Jones and Wormald are to file affidavits setting out all their dealings in respect of “the stationary cameras” (attaching any relevant documentation).

[43] There will be a further conference in this proceeding in the second week of December 2012, to resolve any outstanding matters in terms of the judgment, and to address any necessary timetabling in connection with the judgment.

ENDS

Full judgment: Dotcom__Ors_v_Atorney_General__DC_North_Shore.pdf

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Digital Evolution: Scoop Independent News Launches "Operation Chrysalis"

From today Scoop is beginning a process of public consultation with the political, business and civil society groups it has served for the past 15 and a half years.

"It is hoped that in time - with new leadership and increased community engagement - the chrysalis will incubate a new kind of Scoop, one which can sustainably continue Scoop's Mission 'to be an agent of positive change'", says Scoop Founder, Editor and Publisher Alastair Thompson.

"As big publishing shrivels, public participation in contributing and spreading news has grown. Scoop has evolved with this wave by providing an independent platform, committed to upholding democracy, providing a voice to all, and providing the public easy access to information about decisions which affect them." More>>

 

Parliament Adjourns:

Greens: CAA Airport Door Report Conflicts With Brownlee’s Claims

The heavily redacted report into the incident shows conflicting versions of events as told by Gerry Brownlee and the Christchurch airport security staff. The report disputes Brownlee’s claim that he was allowed through, and states that he instead pushed his way through. More>>

ALSO:

TAIC: Final Report On Grounding Of MV Rena

Factors that directly contributed to the grounding included the crew:
- not following standard good practice for planning and executing the voyage
- not following standard good practice for navigation watchkeeping
- not following standard good practice when taking over control of the ship. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell:
On The Pakistan Schoolchildren Killings

The slaughter of the children in Pakistan is incomprehensibly awful. On the side, it has thrown a spotlight onto something that’s become a pop cultural meme. Fans of the Homeland TV series will be well aware of the collusion between sections of the Pakistan military/security establishment on one hand and sections of the Taliban of the other… More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf Satire:
The Politician’s Song

am a perfect picture of the modern politic-i-an:
I don’t precisely have a plan so much as an ambition;
‘Say what will sound most pleasant to the public’ is my main dictum:
And when in doubt attack someone who already is a victim More>>

ALSO:

Flight: Review Into Phillip Smith’s Escape Submitted To Government

The review follows an earlier operational review by the Department of Corrections and interim measures put in place by the Department shortly after prisoner Smith’s escape, and will inform the Government Inquiry currently underway. More>>

ALSO:

Intelligence: Inspector-General Accepts Apology For Leak Of Report

The Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security, Cheryl Gwyn, has accepted an unreserved apology from Hon Phil Goff MP for disclosing some of the contents of her recent Report into the Release of Information by the NZSIS in July and August 2011 to media prior to its publication. The Inspector-General will not take the matter any further. More>>

ALSO:

Drink: Alcohol Advertising Report Released

The report of the Ministerial Forum on Alcohol Advertising and Sponsorship has been released today, with Ministers noting that further work will be required on the feasibility and impact of the proposals. More>>

ALSO:

Other Report:

Leaked Cabinet Papers: Treasury Calls For Health Cuts

Leaked Cabinet papers that show that Government has been advised to cut the health budget by around $200 million is ringing alarm bells throughout the nursing and midwifery community. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Politics
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news