Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 


TPPA could bypass cap on liability for tighter gambling laws

13 May 2013

For immediate release

TPPA could bypass cap on liability to Sky City for tightening gambling laws

“In theory, the New Zealand Parliament has the power to make and unmake our gambling laws. In practice, the backroom contract between the National government and Sky City could stymie effective regulation of gaming for the next 35 years”, according to Professor Jane Kelsey from the University of Auckland.

Parliament would still have the power to change the law to terminate or review the casino’s license before 2048, cut the number of gaming machines or tables it is guaranteed, or impose more onerous ‘harm reduction’ obligations. But at a price.

Under the Heads of Agreement released today, the government would have to pay compensation to the company, although the amount is capped. The agreement is silent about the forum for disputes. Normally, cases for breach of contract would be pursued in New Zealand’s domestic courts according to domestic contract law, which has been developed with reference to norms and interests as they evolved over time, although the parties could go to domestic arbitration.

Professor Kelsey warned that foreign investors could also sue the government of the day for breaching New Zealand’s international investment obligations, if a new law significantly reduced the profitability of the casino or the value of its shares.

That case would be heard before a private offshore tribunal under an increasingly discredited arbitration system that is costly and notoriously pro-investor.

Worse, the cap on liability would not apply because the claim is for breach of the investor’s rights under the agreement, not under the contract.

Under almost all of New Zealand’s existing agreements these guarantees are subject to a general exception that allows the government some room to regulate for public morals, or essential interests in the case of the investment agreement with Hong Kong.

This exception would have to be argued as a defence if a foreign investor brought a claim before an international investment tribunal. A dispute at the World Trade Organization between the US and Antigua agreed that ‘measures to protect public morals’ includes the regulation of gambling. However, the arbitral tribunal is not bound to follow WTO interpretations.

The proposed Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPPA) would be a totally different matter. It is clear from past US practice and discussions with negotiators that the US is opposing the application of a similar exception to the investment chapter of the TPPA.

According to the leaked investment text, if the government violated an explicit undertaking in a legal document it is ‘particularly likely’ to be interpreted as an indirect expropriation, irrespective of the circumstances in which the undertaking was given and even if the Parliament has declined to enact it in legislation.

Foreign investors could also allege a breach of fair and equitable treatment because the rules were changed on them after the investment was made.

The New Zealand government would be open to such claims from investors of ten of the other eleven TPPA countries, including the US. Currently Australia has not agreed to adopt the investor-state dispute section of the investment chapter.

SKYCITY Auckland Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of SKYCITY Entertainment Group and SKYCITY Casino Management Limited are both listed companies on the Australian and New Zealand stock exchanges. Shares in the parent company have reportedly risen from $4.55 when the proposed deal became public to $5.13 after it was announced today.

Among SKYCITY Entertainment’s ten largest shareholders are four US finance companies: US private equity and finance firms Black Rock Inc, with over 23 million shares, currently worth nearly NZ$120 million. State Street Corporation has nearly 20 million shares, Mondrian Investment Partners more than 17 million and a subsidiary of Lazard Asset Management owns nearly 16 million. Most of the remaining top ten shareholders are Australian firms.

Ownership could, of course, change at any time, including by existing shareholders manipulating ownership to bring them within the jurisdiction of investment chapters in agreements.

“While Opposition parties and ordinary Kiwis are right to be outraged about the National government’s convention centre-for-pokies deal, they need to ensure that the TPPA does not give foreign investors in the casino and similarly toxic activities more ammunition to protect their profits at our expense”, Professor Kelsey concluded.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Joint Statement: Establishment Of NZ-China Strategic Partnership

At the invitation of Governor-General Lt Gen The Rt Hon Sir Jerry Mateparae and Prime Minister The Rt Hon John Key of New Zealand, President Xi Jinping of the People’s Republic of China made a state visit to New Zealand from 19 to 21 November 2014.

During his visit, President Xi Jinping met with Governor-General Jerry Mateparae, and held talks with Prime Minister John Key. The leaders had an in-depth exchange of views on bilateral relations as well as regional and international issues of common interest. More>>

 
 

Parliament Today:

Savings Targets: Health Procurement Plan Changes Direction

Next steps in implementing DHB shared services programme Health Minister Jonathan Coleman says the Government has agreed to explore a proposal put forward by DHBs to move implementation of the shared services programme to a DHB-owned vehicle. More>>

ALSO:

More on Health Policy:

Auckland Unification: 'No IT Cost Blowout' (Just More Expensive)

Following discussion of an update on Auckland Council’s Information Services Transformational Programme at today’s Finance and Performance Committee, council has released the report publicly. More>>

ALSO:

Other Expensive Things:

Gordon Campbell: On The SAS Role Against Islamic State, And Podemos

Only 25% of the US bombing runs are even managing to locate IS targets worth bombing. As the NYT explains at length, this underlines the need for better on-the-ground intelligence to direct the air campaign to where the bad guys have holed up... More>>

ALSO:

Public Service: Commission Calls For Answers On Handling Of CERA Harassment

EEO Commissioner Dr Jackie Blue is deeply concerned about the way in which the State Services Commission has handled sexual allegations made against CERA chief executive Roger Sutton this week and is calling for answers. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell:
On Andrew Little’s Victory

So Andrew Little has won the leadership – by the narrowest possible margin – from Grant Robertson, and has already been depicted by commentators as being simultaneously (a) the creature of the trade unions and (b) the most centrist of the four candidates, which would be an interesting trick to see someone try in a game of Twister. More>>

ALSO:

China President Wishlists: Greens Welcome Xi, But Human Rights Need To Be On Agenda

“President Xi has made some progress on climate change, but he must also lift the Chinese government’s game on human rights issues,” Green Party Co-leader Dr Russel Norman said... It is important that our Government continues to urge the Chinese government to show restraint and respect human rights in both Tibet and the Xinjiang province.” More>>

ALSO:

Airport Security Breach: CAA Fines Minister

Minister Brownlee has been issued an infringement notice and is required to pay a $2000 infringement fine for breaching Civil Aviation Rule 19.357(b), which states no person may be in an airport security area without an appropriate identity card or document. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Politics
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news