Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Ombudsman criticises Pharmac's approach to rare diseases

Ombudsman criticises Pharmac's approach to rare diseases

NZORD - the New Zealand Organisation for Rare Disorders

The Ombudsman has criticised a Pharmac decision from September 2012 on an exceptional circumstances application for a specialised medicine to treat Freda Evans who has Pompe disease. He has suggested Pharmac consider any further comments that Ms Evans wishes to make and give further specific consideration to items they have glossed over in their decision.


In the opinion released to the patient on 31 May 2013 and published 12 July 2013 Ombudsman Dr David McGee, who has since retired, raised a number of concerns about Pharmac’s policies and procedures. Specifically in the opinion:

He mentioned Pharmac’s documentation describing the decision criteria was “unduly complicated”.
He noted that Pharmac has a general discretion to consider applications despite the tight eligibility criteria in the Named Patient Pharmaceutical Assessment (NPPA) policy, but noted that the information on the policy did not explain this.
Dr McGee was concerned that Pharmac’s NPPA policy does not record the decision criteria to be used under that policy. He also considered the decision criteria under the NPPA policy ought to be clearly differentiated from those under the Pharmaceutical Schedule.
He was concerned that Pharmac didn’t specifically consider the patient’s suggestion for a trial period of the medicine. The Ombudsman said they should revisit this and consider any further comments on this suggestion the patient wishes to make.
He noted the lack of evidence in regard to rare diseases and treatments inevitably puts their assessment at a potential disadvantage.
Dr McGee specifically noted that the principle of states not abandoning their citizens is of obvious relevance where there is no known alternative method of treatment.
He noted a contestable legal argument about whether Pharmac appropriately excludes social and ethical factors from their consideration, though he said it was not his role to make a definitive decision on that legal dispute.
He considered that Pharmac should allow submissions to be made by Ms Evans and her supporters about questions of fairness, equity and community values, and consider these alongside submissions made by her clinician when the application is reconsidered.



· He identified “matters of high policy to be addressed by the Government and Parliament”.

Ms Evans’ complaint to the Ombudsman has been supported by the New Zealand Organisation for Rare disorders (NZORD), Lysosomal Diseases New Zealand (LDNZ), and the Muscular Dystrophy Association of New Zealand (MDANZ). “Our groups are delighted that our concerns have been heard in the system and responses provided that recognise the weakness of individuals against the enormous power of the bureaucracy,” said John Forman, NZORD’s executive director.

The groups have been seeking better accountability and governance oversight of Pharmac for many years. “We were frustrated that approaches to Ministers, the Health select committee, and other officials over the past two years since the development of the NPPA policy, had not resulted in any external scrutiny of Pharmac or response to our concerns,”, says Forman. “At last we have found a part of the system willing to investigate Pharmac and hold them to account, and Pharmac has been found seriously wanting.”

The Ombudsman’s report includes criticism of aspects of the relationship between Pharmac and District Health Boards, and concern was expressed by Dr McGee at Pharmac’s apparent power to bind DHB’s medicine purchasing decisions through a provision it has put in the schedule. Dr McGee said, “I have seen no statutory authority which allows Pharmac to give directions to DHBs, whether through the schedule or otherwise.”

Forman concluded by saying that the report vindicates many years of detailed work the groups have invested in scrutinising Pharmac’s operations. “Pharmac should be commended for the significant achievements it has made with a Pharmaceutical Schedule that provide good savings and good pharmaceutical outcomes for a great number of New Zealanders. But it is time for Pharmac to acknowledge that a strict health economics focus without a moral compass is abandoning patients at the margins. We hope that this opinion will cause Pharmac, government, Ministers, the Health select committee and other officials, to respond with serious scrutiny and review of Pharmac’s policies regarding specialised medicines for rare diseases.”

NZORD will assist with a further application for funding of the treatment (Myozyme) that Ms Evans needs, as soon as discussions with clinicians and other advisors are completed.

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

SCOOP COVERAGE: CHRISTCHURCH MOSQUES TERROR ATTACK


Fair Pay Agreements Good: CTU Releases Report On Sector Bargaining

The Council of Trade Unions has today released an independent report conducted by economic research company BERL into the validity of sector bargaining.

And the findings are clear - there is no economic reason not to implement sector bargaining but many social and individual wellbeing reasons to do so. More>>

 

Goldsmith New National Finance Spokesperson: Amy Adams To Leave Politics In 2020

Amy Adams has announced she will retire from politics at the 2020 election and as a consequence of that decision she has chosen to stand down from the spokesperson roles she holds in the Party. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Government's Cosmetic Banking Reforms

The elephant in the room as the government carries out its latest bout of tinkerings with our banking practice is the extraordinary level of profit-taking still being extracted by the Australian Banking Gang from ordinary New Zealanders. Yes indeed, ... More>>

ALSO:

IPCA: Offensive Language, Misuse Of Pepper Spray

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that, following a pursuit in Auckland, a man was dealt with inappropriately and unprofessionally by a Police officer during his arrest. More>>

ALSO:

Stats NZ: Gender Inclusive Questions Introduced

More than 28,000 New Zealand households will be asked to take part in the upcoming Household Economic Survey. Starting this year, the survey will ask people to describe their gender – whether that is male, female, or if they see themselves another way, such as one of many non-binary genders. More>>

New Report: Are We Listening To Children?

A report released today is a sharp reminder that what children and young people say makes a difference, and that it’s time we paid more attention to their views, says Children’s Commissioner Andrew Becroft. More>>

ALSO:

The Nation: Canadian Euthanasia Practitioner Stefanie Green

The euthanasia debate is progressing, with the End of Life Choice Bill expected to have its second reading in Parliament on Wednesday. A similar bill was passed in Canada in 2016 ... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The Gun Buy-Back Scheme

Do gun amnesties and buy-backs save lives? Since it’s always difficult to exclude all of the socio-economic factors that may be operating in parallel, the die-hard denialists in the gun lobby will always be able to find a bit of wiggle room. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels