Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Judgment: ChristChurch Cathedral Demolition May Continue

High Court of New Zealand

30 May 2014


MEDIA RELEASE
THE GREAT CHRISTCHURCH BUILDINGS TRUST v THE CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES and CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE RECOVERY AUTHORITY (CIV-2012-409-001761)


and
THE CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES v ATTORNEY-GENERAL and THE GREAT CHRISTCHURCH BUILDINGS TRUST

(CIV-2012-409-002745)
[2014] NZHC 1182
PRESS SUMMARY

This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at https://www.courtsofnz.govt.nz/from/decisions/judgments.html

In March 2012 the Church Property Trustees (CPT) resolved to deconstruct the Cathedral down to a level of two to three metres. The Great Christchurch Buildings Trust applied to judicially review that decision. Chisholm J found that the CPT held the Cathedral on terms of trust which required them to maintain a cathedral on the site, not necessarily the Cathedral as it was before the earthquakes. However, he ordered a stay on deconstruction until the CPT committed to rebuild a cathedral of whatever design.

In September 2013 the CPT resolved to deconstruct the old Cathedral and construct a new cathedral of contemporary design. The CPT requested the Court to lift the stay.

The stay has been lifted in this judgment. The Court concluded that it was for the opposer, the Great Christchurch Buildings Trust, to establish grounds which justified retention of the stay.

The Court found:

• CPT has committed to the construction of a new cathedral and hence the original justification for a stay no longer existed.

• CPT gave fair consideration to relevant issues before reaching its decision to deconstruct and build a new contemporary cathedral.

• There was no evidence that improper motive, dishonest of intention or conflict of interest affected the CPT’s decision.

• The merits of the decision to rebuild in a contemporary design was a matter for the CPT, not the Court. This Court’s role was limited to ensuring that the decision was reached after fair consideration and not for improper reasons. Because this test was met, there were no grounds to judicially review the CPT decision.

In the second proceeding the CPT sought directions concerning proposed arrangements to restore over $4 m to the Cathedral Trust. This sum, being part of the insurance proceeds received for the damage to the old Cathedral, was improperly applied to construction of the Transitional Cathedral. The judgment contains orders concerning a resumed hearing of CPT’s application seeking directions and for relief against liability in relation to misapplication of the insurance proceeds.

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The Life And Times Of Peter Dunne

In the end, Mr Pragmatic calmly read the signs of impending defeat and went out on his own terms. You could use any number of clichés to describe Peter Dunne’s exit from Parliament.

The unkind might talk of sinking ships, others could be more reminded of a loaded revolver left on the desk by his Cabinet colleagues as they closed the door behind them, now that the polls in Ohariu had confirmed he was no longer of much use to National. More>>

 

Gordon Campbell: On Labour’s Campaign Launch

One of the key motifs of Ardern’s speech was her repeated use of the phrase – “Now, what?” Cleverly, that looks like being Labour’s response to National’s ‘steady as it goes’ warning against not putting the economic ‘gains’ at risk. More>>

ALSO:

Lyndon Hood: Social Welfare, Explained

Speaking as someone who has seen better times and nowadays mostly operates by being really annoying and humiliating to deal with, I have some fellow feeling with the current system, so I’ll take this chance to set a few things straight.. More>>

ALSO:

Deregistered: Independent Board Decision On Family First

The Board considers that Family First has a purpose to promote its own particular views about marriage and the traditional family that cannot be determined to be for the public benefit in a way previously accepted as charitable... More>>

ALSO:

Transport Policies: Nats' New $10.5bn Roads Of National Significance

National is committing to the next generation of Roads of National Significance, National Party Transport Spokesperson Simon Bridges says. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Why Labour Isn’t Responsible For Barnaby Joyce

As a desperate Turnbull government tries to treat the Barnaby Joyce affair as a Pauline Hanson fever dream – blame it on the foreigners! We’re the victims of the dastardly New Zealand Labour Party! – our own government has chosen to further that narrative, and make itself an accomplice. More>>

ALSO:

Rail: Greens Back Tauranga – Hamilton – Auckland Service

The Green Party today announced that it will trial a passenger rail service between Auckland, Hamilton and Tauranga starting in 2019, when it is in government. More>>

ALSO:

Housing: Voluntary Rental Warrant Of Fitness For Wellington

Wellington City Council is partnering with the University of Otago, Wellington, to launch a voluntary Rental Warrant of Fitness for minimum housing standards in Wellington, Mayor Justin Lester has announced. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election