Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 


Judgment: ChristChurch Cathedral Demolition May Continue

High Court of New Zealand

30 May 2014


MEDIA RELEASE
THE GREAT CHRISTCHURCH BUILDINGS TRUST v THE CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES and CANTERBURY EARTHQUAKE RECOVERY AUTHORITY (CIV-2012-409-001761)


and
THE CHURCH PROPERTY TRUSTEES v ATTORNEY-GENERAL and THE GREAT CHRISTCHURCH BUILDINGS TRUST

(CIV-2012-409-002745)
[2014] NZHC 1182
PRESS SUMMARY

This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at https://www.courtsofnz.govt.nz/from/decisions/judgments.html

In March 2012 the Church Property Trustees (CPT) resolved to deconstruct the Cathedral down to a level of two to three metres. The Great Christchurch Buildings Trust applied to judicially review that decision. Chisholm J found that the CPT held the Cathedral on terms of trust which required them to maintain a cathedral on the site, not necessarily the Cathedral as it was before the earthquakes. However, he ordered a stay on deconstruction until the CPT committed to rebuild a cathedral of whatever design.

In September 2013 the CPT resolved to deconstruct the old Cathedral and construct a new cathedral of contemporary design. The CPT requested the Court to lift the stay.

The stay has been lifted in this judgment. The Court concluded that it was for the opposer, the Great Christchurch Buildings Trust, to establish grounds which justified retention of the stay.

The Court found:

• CPT has committed to the construction of a new cathedral and hence the original justification for a stay no longer existed.

• CPT gave fair consideration to relevant issues before reaching its decision to deconstruct and build a new contemporary cathedral.

• There was no evidence that improper motive, dishonest of intention or conflict of interest affected the CPT’s decision.

• The merits of the decision to rebuild in a contemporary design was a matter for the CPT, not the Court. This Court’s role was limited to ensuring that the decision was reached after fair consideration and not for improper reasons. Because this test was met, there were no grounds to judicially review the CPT decision.

In the second proceeding the CPT sought directions concerning proposed arrangements to restore over $4 m to the Cathedral Trust. This sum, being part of the insurance proceeds received for the damage to the old Cathedral, was improperly applied to construction of the Transitional Cathedral. The judgment contains orders concerning a resumed hearing of CPT’s application seeking directions and for relief against liability in relation to misapplication of the insurance proceeds.

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell:
On The Northland By-Election

Supposedly, Winston Peters’ victory in Northland has exposed the simmering dissatisfaction with the government that exists out in the provinces. Yet it remains to be seen whether this defeat will have much significance – and not simply because if and when Labour resumes business as usual in the Northland seat at the next election, Peters’ hold on it could simply evaporate.

On Saturday, National’s electorate vote declined by 7,000 votes, as the 9,000 majority it won last September turned into a 4,000 vote deficit – mainly because Labour supporters followed the nod and wink given by Labour leader Andrew Little, and voted tactically for Peters. In the process, Labour’s vote went down from nearly 9,000 votes six months ago, to only 1,315 on Saturday. More>>

 
 

PARLIAMENT TODAY:

Climate: Ministers Exclude Emissions From ‘Environment Reporting'

The National Party Government has today revealed that the national environmental report topics for this year will, incredibly, exclude New Zealand’s greenhouse gas emissions, the Green Party said today. More>>

ALSO:

No Retrial: Freedom At Last For Teina Pora

The Māori Party is relieved that the Privy Council has cleared the final legal hurdle for Teina Pora who was wrongfully convicted of murder and sent to prison for 22 years. More>>

ALSO:

Germanwings Crash: Privacy Act Supports Aviation Safeguards In New Zealand

Reports that German privacy laws may have contributed to the Germanwings air crash have prompted New Zealand’s Privacy Commissioner to reassure the public that the Privacy Act is no impediment to medical practitioners notifying appropriate authorities to a pilot’s health concerns. More>>

ALSO:

Treaty: Taranaki Iwi Ngāruahine Settles Treaty Claims For $67.5mln

The settlement includes a $13.5 million payment the government made in June 2013, as well as land in the Taranaki region. The settlement also includes four culturally significant sites, the Waipakari Reserve, Te Kohinga Reserve, Te Ngutu o te Manu and Te Poho o Taranaki. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On A Funeral In Asia, The Northland By-Election, And News Priorities

Supposedly, New Zealand’s destiny lies in Asia, and that was one of Foreign Minister Murray McCully’s rationales for his bungled reforms at MFAT. OK. So, if that’s the case why didn’t Prime Minister John Key attend the state funeral on Sunday of Singapore’s founding leader Lee Kuan Yew? More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf Satire: Not Flag-Waving; Flag-Drowning

The panel choosing the flag options has no visual artists at all. Now, I’ve kerned the odd ligature in my time and I know my recto from my French curve so I thought I’d offer a few suggestions before they get past their depth. More>>

ALSO:

IPCA Reports: Significant Problems In Police Custody

In releasing two reports today, the Independent Police Conduct Authority has highlighted a number of significant problems with the way in which Police deal with people who are detained in Police cells. More>>

ALSO:

Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security: Inquiry Into GCSB Pacific Allegations

The complaints follow recent public allegations about GCSB activities. The complaints, and these public allegations, raise wider questions regarding the collection, retention and sharing of communications data. More>>

ALSO:

TPPA Investment Leak: "NZ Surrender To US" On Corporates Suing Governments

Professor Jane Kelsey: ‘As anticipated, the deal gives foreign investors from the TPPA countries special rights, and the power to sue the government in private offshore tribunals for massive damages if new laws, or even court decisions, significantly affected their bottom line’. More>>

ALSO:

Werewolf: The Myth Of Steven Joyce

Gordon Campbell: The myth of competence that’s been woven around Steven Joyce – the Key government’s “Minister of Everything” and “Mr Fixit” – has been disseminated from high-rises to hamlets, across the country... More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 

LATEST HEADLINES

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Politics
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news