Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Refugee advocate seeks assurances of evidence-based review

Refugee advocate seeks assurances of evidence-based quota review


Documents obtained under the Official Information Act show the 2013 advice to Cabinet on the refugee quota was based on the preferences of the Prime Minister and did not allow for the relevant Ministers or Immigration officials to put forward a previously suggested case for an increase.

Doing Our Bit spokesperson Murdoch Stephens is seeking a reassurances that the department can put forward their preferred case. “The 2013 quota review may have been based on the same misunderstanding of the facts, so we ask for an assurance that the forthcoming review will allow Immigration New Zealand to put forward an evidence-based case.”

On Monday the Prime Minister admitted that he thought the nation’s annual refugee quota was “three or four thousand”. He later corrected himself by acknowledging just over one thousand total places were available every year.

Editorials in every major daily newspaper have backed the call for an increase to the quota - including support for doubling it from the NZ Herald and Dominion Post. Many service providers have also noted there is capacity for an increase. Similarly every other political party has commented at some point in the last year that they support an increase to at least a 1000 places per annum.

The documents obtained from an Official Information Act request show Immigration New Zealand were making a case for Cabinet that included a option of raising the quota to 900 places. However, public comments by Key at the time meant that advice did not go forward.

A February 2013 MBIE briefing contained the following point:

“4. Public statements by the Prime Minister have subsequently made it clear that his preference is for the Refugee Quota Programme to remain at 750. We seek confirmation that that is the recommended option to put forward to Cabinet.”

No subsequent papers or briefings mention the previous case for raising the quota.

“These documents show that our quota intake has remained low due to what we now know to be an unfortunate error in calculation by the Prime Minister.”

Stephens added, “We ask that the Prime Minister allow Immigration to put forward a neutral case based on relevant evidence such as capacity, reference to population increases since the quota was established and the current needs indicated by the United Nations High Commission for Refugees. We ask that he instructs them to ignore his previous comments on the quota and to take advice from Immigration Minister Michael Woodhouse who has noted that the government has ‘an open mind’ on the quota review.”

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Budget 2018: "Better Lives For Children"

Budget 2018 builds a better future for New Zealand children, with major investments in health, education, housing and justice to improve thousands of children’s lives, says Prime Minister and Minister for Child Poverty Reduction Jacinda Ardern. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On Budget 2018

To put it mildly, Budget 2018 has not been an outbreak of wild-eyed, tax and spend liberalism. “Unfortunately not,” says CTU economist Bill Rosenberg agrees laconically. “But what you're seeing and within the constraints [the government] have set themselves, they’ve done quite a good job of beginning to eat away at the deficits that have built up over the years. Not only the social deficits, but also in areas like economic development, the provinces, bio-security and so on.” More>>

Budget 2018 - Scoop Full Coverage

ALSO:

.

 
 

Gordon Campbell: On Regressive Taxes

The headlines would have you believe that inflation is safely under control, but a Statistics NZ press release indicates that isn’t the reality being experienced by the poor, given how the steeply rising costs of smoking, petrol, rent etc are falling disproportionately on low to middle income earners. More>>

ALSO:

Overlapping Treaty Claims: ‘You Are Taking Us To War’

Treaty Negotiations Minister Andrew Little was speaking about the treaty process and the importance of communication when he was challenged by a kaumatua from Tauranga Moana. More>>

ALSO:

Workplace Harrassment: Rights Body's Policy Inadequate

"Judge Coral Shaw’s report confirms what our members at the HRC have told us: that the workplace culture at the HRC needs to be addressed," PSA National Secretary Glenn Barclay says. More>>

ALSO:

Charter Schools: Transition Begins

As the next step in the transition of charter schools into the state school system, the formal process to end charter school contracts is starting today, Education Minister Chris Hipkins says. More>>

ALSO:

Labour & Labour: 'Not All Businesses Will Survive' Employment Changes

Q+A Transcript: Workplace Relations Minister Iain Lees-Galloway says New Zealand needs a high-skill, high-wage economy and accepts that some businesses will not survive some of its policy changes. More>>

ALSO:

Newshub Nation: Kiwirebuild

This week, the government admitted it’s had to tinker with its KiwiBuild policy to make it work. A three-bedroom home in Auckland will now cost $50,000 more than Labour promised during the election campaign. More>>

ALSO:

Budget 2018: Govt To Invest $42 Billion In Capital Spending

The Coalition Government will invest $42 billion in net capital spending over the next five years to support our plan to rebuild New Zealand’s infrastructure and critical public services, Finance Minister Grant Robertson said ... More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages