Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Why is David Seymour hesitant to defend his bill?

For immediate release


Why is David Seymour hesitant to defend his bill?


David Seymour, MP for ACT, withdrew from an interview when he heard that Euthanasia-Free NZ would also be represented.

Earlier this week Mr Seymour accepted the invitation to discuss his End of Life Choice Bill on this week's Wireless Watchdog. At the time, Renee Joubert, executive officer of Euthanasia-Free NZ, had not yet been invited onto the programme by Plains FM host Kenny Ardouin.

“As soon as I found out that Renee would be joining us too, I informed David and he told me that I, quote, ‘have got to be kidding’”, recalled Mr Ardouin. “I invited him back but he declined. I also invited him for an individual interview, but he has not responded. This is disappointing as I really had hoped he would join in on the discussion – not a debate, but an open discussion on a human rights issue.”

The programme, aired live last night and repeated this morning, went ahead in Mr Seymour’s absence.

Ms Joubert interprets Mr Seymour’s withdrawal as an indication that he has already realised his bill is unworkable and indefensible. “He has rushed ahead where angels fear to tread and produced a seriously flawed proposal.”

On the programme, available via podcast, Ms Joubert voiced her reservations about the bill, which proposes euthanasia and assisted suicide by lethal drugs.



She is concerned that virtually every New Zealander 18 years or older would be eligible for death under the “grievous and irremediable medical condition” clause.

“Disabilities, chronic physical and mental conditions as well as ageing-related conditions would fall into this category,” warns Ms Joubert. “Whether a condition is “grievous” is an entirely subjective judgement. Any condition can become “irremediable” when a person refuses further treatment.”

She argues that the “terminal illness” clause is also fraught with difficulties, as it has no universally accepted definition. The boundary between terminal illness and chronic illness is blurred, because some conditions such as diabetes, high blood pressure, asthma and allergies can become life-threatening within minutes. The line between terminal illness and disability is also unclear, because some would define any condition that is potentially life-shortening as “terminal”. The “six months” threshold is arbitrary and also redundant, since any terminal illness is by definition irremediable.

Ms Joubert submitted on air that none of the bill’s proposed safeguards would be enforceable.

She pointed out that, under this bill, anyone who ended a person’s life and claimed that they have done so in good faith, would be immune from prosecution, even if they have not followed other requirements in the bill.

“A doctor could, for example, ignore the safeguard that there has to be a voluntary request… and then not be prosecuted.”

"Are David Seymour and ACT proposing more than voluntary euthanasia in order to cut health care costs? After all, death is cheaper than treatment…"

Dr David Richmond, a retired geriatrician and a spokesperson for Euthanasia-Free NZ, is concerned about the quality of the medical advice Mr. Seymour has accessed in preparing this bill. “It’s drafting is more akin to a document produced by an enthusiastic layperson than by a credible medical expert,” he says.


ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Mosque Shooting Response: Ban On Military Style Semi-Automatics And Assault Rifles

Military style semi-automatics and assault rifles will be banned in New Zealand under stronger new gun laws announced today, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says... Related parts used to convert these guns into MSSAs are also being banned, along with all high-capacity magazines.

“An amnesty will be put in place for weapons to be handed in, and Cabinet has directed officials to develop a buyback scheme...All semi-automatic weapons used during the terrorist attack on Friday 15 March will be banned." More>>

RNZ Report: No Mention Of Right-Wing Threat In 10 Years Of GCSB/SIS Docs
There is not one specific mention of the threat posed by white supremacists or right-wing nationalism in 10 years of public documents from the Security Intelligence Service or the GCSB. More>>

Two Minute Silence Friday: Auckland Mosques Opening Their Doors To All
Mosques in the four corners of Auckland will open their doors on Friday night for people of all faiths to gather in remembrance of the 50 lives lost in the Christchurch shootings. More>>

SCOOP COVERAGE: CHRISTCHURCH MOSQUES TERROR ATTACK
For the Latest: Scoop Search - Christchurch
 

Gordon Campbell: On The School Climate Strike

Locally, the school strike has won a ton of support for bringing climate change to the fore. Yet the strikers don't want mere expressions of support. They want action. More>>

ALSO:

"Grabbed And Struck In The Face": Greens Co-Leader Attacked While Walking To Work

Green Party co-leader James Shaw was the victim of an unprovoked attack when he was walking to work in Wellington. More>>

ALSO:

████████ ████ ███: Latest OIA Statistics Released

The latest statistics cover 110 agencies that collectively completed 18,106 official information requests between July and December 2018, a 16.4% increase on the 15,551 requests for the previous six months. More>>

ALSO:

'Hit And Run' Inquiry: New Legal Action Over Secrecy

The lawyer representing the Afghan villagers in the inquiry into Operation Burnham has launched legal proceedings calling for a judicial review in the investigation. More>>

ALSO:

From Hydro Plan To...: Mokihinui River Land To Join Kahurangi National Park

A total of 64,400 hectares of conservation land in the Mokihinui River catchment on the West Coast north of Westport, including 15 km of riverbed, is being added to Kahurangi National Park. “Adding this area, roughly half the size of Auckland City, to Kahurangi is the largest addition of land to an existing national park in New Zealand’s history,” Eugenie Sage said. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels