Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Why is David Seymour hesitant to defend his bill?

For immediate release


Why is David Seymour hesitant to defend his bill?


David Seymour, MP for ACT, withdrew from an interview when he heard that Euthanasia-Free NZ would also be represented.

Earlier this week Mr Seymour accepted the invitation to discuss his End of Life Choice Bill on this week's Wireless Watchdog. At the time, Renee Joubert, executive officer of Euthanasia-Free NZ, had not yet been invited onto the programme by Plains FM host Kenny Ardouin.

“As soon as I found out that Renee would be joining us too, I informed David and he told me that I, quote, ‘have got to be kidding’”, recalled Mr Ardouin. “I invited him back but he declined. I also invited him for an individual interview, but he has not responded. This is disappointing as I really had hoped he would join in on the discussion – not a debate, but an open discussion on a human rights issue.”

The programme, aired live last night and repeated this morning, went ahead in Mr Seymour’s absence.

Ms Joubert interprets Mr Seymour’s withdrawal as an indication that he has already realised his bill is unworkable and indefensible. “He has rushed ahead where angels fear to tread and produced a seriously flawed proposal.”

On the programme, available via podcast, Ms Joubert voiced her reservations about the bill, which proposes euthanasia and assisted suicide by lethal drugs.

She is concerned that virtually every New Zealander 18 years or older would be eligible for death under the “grievous and irremediable medical condition” clause.

“Disabilities, chronic physical and mental conditions as well as ageing-related conditions would fall into this category,” warns Ms Joubert. “Whether a condition is “grievous” is an entirely subjective judgement. Any condition can become “irremediable” when a person refuses further treatment.”

She argues that the “terminal illness” clause is also fraught with difficulties, as it has no universally accepted definition. The boundary between terminal illness and chronic illness is blurred, because some conditions such as diabetes, high blood pressure, asthma and allergies can become life-threatening within minutes. The line between terminal illness and disability is also unclear, because some would define any condition that is potentially life-shortening as “terminal”. The “six months” threshold is arbitrary and also redundant, since any terminal illness is by definition irremediable.

Ms Joubert submitted on air that none of the bill’s proposed safeguards would be enforceable.

She pointed out that, under this bill, anyone who ended a person’s life and claimed that they have done so in good faith, would be immune from prosecution, even if they have not followed other requirements in the bill.

“A doctor could, for example, ignore the safeguard that there has to be a voluntary request… and then not be prosecuted.”

"Are David Seymour and ACT proposing more than voluntary euthanasia in order to cut health care costs? After all, death is cheaper than treatment…"

Dr David Richmond, a retired geriatrician and a spokesperson for Euthanasia-Free NZ, is concerned about the quality of the medical advice Mr. Seymour has accessed in preparing this bill. “It’s drafting is more akin to a document produced by an enthusiastic layperson than by a credible medical expert,” he says.


ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

New Reports: Flood Risk From Rain And Sea Under Climate Change

One report looks at what would happen when rivers are flooded by heavy rain and storms, while the other examines flooding exposure in coastal and harbour areas and how that might change with sea-level rise.

Their findings show that across the country almost 700,000 people and 411,516 buildings worth $135 billion are presently exposed to river flooding in the event of extreme weather events...

There is near certainty that the sea will rise 20-30 cm by 2040. By the end of the century, depending on whether global greenhouse gas emissions are reduced, it could rise by between 0.5 to 1.1 m, which could add an additional 116,000 people exposed to extreme coastal storm flooding. More>>

ALSO:

 
 

Gordon Campbell: On The Commerce Commission Fuel Report

The interim Commerce Commission report on the fuel industry will do nothing to endear the major oil companies to the New Zealand public... More>>

ALSO:

Emergency Govt Bill: Overriding Local Licensing For The Rugby

“It’s pretty clear some clubs are having difficulty persuading their district licensing committees to grant a special licence to extend their hours for this obviously special event, and so it makes sense for Parliament to allow clubs to meet a community desire." More>>

ALSO:

Leaving Contract Early: KiwiBuild Programme Losing Another Top Boss

Ms O'Sullivan began a six-month contract as head of KiwiBuild Commercial in February, but the Housing Ministry has confirmed she has resigned and will depart a month early to take up a new job. More>>

ALSO:

Proposed National Policy Statement: Helping Our Cities Grow Up And Out

“We need a new approach to planning that allows our cities to grow up, especially in city centres and around transport connections. We also have to allow cities to expand in a way that protects our special heritage areas, the natural environment and highly productive land." More>>

ALSO:

Ombudsman's Report: Ngāpuhi Elder 'Shocked' By Conditions At Ngawha Prison

A prominent Ngāpuhi elder is shocked to find inmates at Ngawha Prison are denied water and forced to relieve themselves in the exercise yard... Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier has released a report highly critical of conditions at the Northland prison. More>>

ALSO:

Promises: Independent Election Policy Costing Unit A Step Closer

The creation of an entity to provide political parties with independent and non-partisan policy costings is a step closer today, according to Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Associate Finance Minister James Shaw. More>>

ALSO:

School's In: Primary And Intermediate Principals Accept New Offer

Primary and intermediate school principals have voted to accept a new settlement from the Ministry of Education, which includes entrenched pay parity with secondary principals. More>>

ALSO:

IPCA On 'Rawshark' Investigation: Multiple Police Failings In Hager Searches Confirmed

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that the Police's unlawful search of Nicky Hager's property in October 2014 resulted from an unwitting neglect of duty and did not amount to misconduct by any individual officer... More>>

ALSO:

Broadcasting Standards: Decisions On Coverage Of Mosque Attacks

The Authority upheld one of these complaints, finding that the use of extensive excerpts from the alleged attacker’s livestream video on Sky News New Zealand had the potential to cause significant distress to audiences in New Zealand, and particularly to the family and friends of victims, and the wider Muslim community. More>>

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

InfoPages News Channels