Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Judgment: J v Accident Compensation Corporation



9 OCTOBER 2017



[2017] NZCA 441


This summary is provided to assist in the understanding of the Court’s judgment. It does not comprise part of the reasons for that judgment. The full judgment with reasons is the only authoritative document. The full text of the judgment and reasons can be found at www.courtsofnz.govt.nz.

1. The Court of Appeal has today dismissed an appeal brought by Ms J against a High Court decision in which she was denied weekly loss of earnings compensation under the Accident Compensation Act 2001 (the Act).

2. Ms J fell pregnant following a failed sterilisation procedure. She has previously been granted cover for personal injury under the Act for the duration of her pregnancy and the period of physical recovery that followed childbirth.[1] She then sought weekly loss of earnings compensation under the Act for the period that she was unable to work because of the need to care for her child.

3. The majority, Cooper and Asher JJ, found that while the pregnancy was an injury as defined by the Act, Ms J was not entitled to the weekly compensation sought. The Act is concerned with the physical and mental consequences of injury. It is not concerned with obligations that may arise to look after a child after there has been a complete physical and mental recovery from pregnancy and childbirth. Once the child was born Ms J was not prevented from working by her personal injury. She had recovered. Rather, she was prevented from working by the need to care for the child. Interpreted as a whole, the Act only provides weekly compensation insofar as the claimant is still experiencing the physical and mental effects of his or her injury.

4. Kós P disagreed with the majority, and found that Ms J was entitled to weekly loss of earnings compensation for the period that she was unable to work because of the need to care for her child.

5. Unlike the majority, Kós P took the view that the Act provides entitlements so long as a claimant is incapacitated as a consequence of his or her personal injury. A claimant may be incapacitated as a consequence of his or her injury beyond the period for which he or she is experiencing the physical and mental effects of that injury. Ms J’s child was the natural and inevitable consequence of the personal injury of pregnancy. She was entitled to weekly compensation for incapacity for so long as the need to care for the child precluded her return to employment..


6. A High Court order prohibiting the publication of the name, address, occupation or identifying particulars of the appellant remains in force.


[1] The Supreme Court found that pregnancy following a failed sterilisation constitutes personal injury for the purposes of the Act in Allenby v H [2012] NZSC 33, [2012] 3 NZLR 425. Ms J was granted cover for her pregnancy following the release of that decision.


Scoop copy of judgment: JvACC.pdf

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: Zimbabwe - Meet The New Bosses

At 75, Mnangagwa is not exactly what you’d call a new broom. As many observers have pointed out, his track record has been one of unswerving dedication to Mugabe ever since the days of anti-colonial insurgency...

The falling out with Mugabe two weeks ago came only after Mugabe attempted to build a dynastic succession around his wife, Grace. Mnangagwa fled to South Africa, from where he orchestrated an Army coup led by his long–time ally, General Constantino Chiwenga, head of the country’s armed forces. To these guys, things had to change in Zimbabwe, so that things could remain the same. More>>


Cullen To Chair: Tax Working Group Terms Of Reference Announced

Finance Minister Grant Robertson and Revenue Minister Stuart Nash today announced the Terms of Reference for the Tax Working Group and that the Group will be chaired by Sir Michael Cullen. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The New Pike River Agency (And The Air Strike Wing)

Much of the sympathy the public still feels for the families of the Pike River miners has been sustained by the sense that the previous government – let alone the mining company and the processes of receivership and litigation – has never dealt honestly, or fairly, with them. More>>


Not Going Swimmingly: Contractor Cut, New Dates For Christchurch Sports Centre

“As an incoming Minister, I have been conducting a thorough review of progress on the Anchor projects and to learn of a $75 million budget blowout on this project was very disappointing..." More>>


Tertiary: Allowances, Loan Living Costs To Get Boost

“From 1 January, student allowance base rates and the maximum amount students can borrow for living costs will rise by a net $50 a week,” says Education Minister Chris Hipkins... further adjusted from 1 April 2018 in line with any increase in the CPI. More>>


Foreign Affairs: Patrick Gower Interviews Jacinda Ardern

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern says discussions have already begun on how to bring climate change refugees into New Zealand under a Pacific seasonal employment plan... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Centre Right’s Love Of ‘Nanny State’

You’d almost think it was 2005 again. That was a time when the rugged individualists of the centre-right were being beset by government regulations on the nature of light-bulbs, the size of shower heads, the junk food available at school tuck shops and other such essentials... More>>




Featured InfoPages

Opening the Election