Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Process results in one sided and unreliable report

Process results in one sided and unreliable report that effectively denied Dr Murray the right to give evidence and fairly contribute to this inquiry.

The findings of the State Services Commission investigation into spending by former Waikato DHB CEO Dr Nigel Murray are rejected as one-sided, unjust and we believe have resulted from a flawed process.

Dr Murray’s legal advisors, Cullen – The Employment Law Firm, are deeply concerned that the investigation has breached accepted standards of proper process and fell well below the requirements of natural justice, transparency and fairness.

“Witnesses were allowed to give evidence in secret, and basic steps such as providing the complete statements of witnesses were not taken. Dr Murray still has no real idea what the witnesses have said about him apart from a limited number of extracts, some of which he has only very recently seen. How can he be expected to respond in those circumstances?” they say.

“It was quite unfair for the investigator to insist that his inquiry should proceed while the Serious Fraud Office was conducting its own investigation into the same issues. Mr Ombler accepts Dr Murray was entitled to refuse to participate in his investigation given the SFO investigation. Dr Murray followed legal advice in not participating in Mr Ombler’s investigation. However Dr Murray, at all times indicated his willingness to participate in the investigation and give full and frank answers once the SFO had completed its investigation. However the investigator refused this and Dr Murray was denied the opportunity to respond. If he had been given that right of reply the outcomes of this inquiry would most likely be quite different.

“The investigator has also made very confusing findings as to which expenses are unauthorised and/or are unjustified which are easily misunderstood. Mr Ombler has categorised certain expenses, which were according to agreed practice retrospectively authorised by the former Chair Mr Bob Simcock, as being unauthorised. We must emphasise that Mr Ombler’s report does not decide any civil or criminal liability.

“The findings have held Dr Murray to an artificially high standard and neglected the day to day practicalities of the approval process.

“For these reasons we consider that the report is one-sided and flawed. Dr Murray would nonetheless like to publicly express his regret and apologise for mistakes made over his expenses. Some expense forms were completed in a way that the justification was not fully obvious. Some expenses were not processed in a timely manner. He takes accountability for these errors.

“Dr Murray has agreed to pay the remaining amounts of $20,493.85 claimed by the Board which were in dispute. Dr Murray does this despite legal advice that he has a good defence for not paying these amounts. Dr Murray does this with a denial of liability. He does so as an act of good will and to resolve matters with his old employer, the Waikato DHB.

“The public needed and deserved a report that fully explored all of the issues regarding expenses. That has not occurred in large part because Dr Murray was unable to participate. We are surprised and disappointed the State Services Commissioner has released a report which we believe is neither accurate nor reliable. We will shortly be lodging a complaint with the Ombudsman regarding the investigation’s unfairness.”

“There will be no further comment.

Cullen – the Employment Law Firm

ends

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


HiveMind: Fair Enough? How Should New Zealanders Be Taxed? - Have Your Say

Scoop and PEP invite you to share your issues, ideas and perspectives on the NZ tax system with other New Zealanders using Scoop’s HiveMind tool. This Tax HiveMind is intended to complement and feed into the review being run by the Government-appointed Tax Working Group (TWG), which is looking at the fairness, balance and structure of the tax system with a 10-year time horizon.

We at Scoop and PEP believe that an issue as important as the fairness of the tax regime should be open for discussion, debate and dialogue. Unfortunately, a written submission process just doesn’t encourage the kind of public exchange we think is necessary in a well-functioning democracy. More>>

 

Gordon Campbell: On Thompson + Clark & Russia’s World Cup

Daily, the coalition government keeps running into examples of the toxic legacy left behind by National – and just as regularly, even the simple fixes are proving stubbornly difficult to enact. Take the case of the security firm Thompson + Clark ... More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On The GCSB’s Security Hang-Up With Russia

So our GCSB has chimed in, alongside its British, Australian and US allies, with warnings about a “fresh wave” of Russian cyber attacks, although the warning has been curiously framed. More>>

ALSO:

PM's Europe Trip: CHOGM & Bilateral Meetings

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern is in urope for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting (CHOGM) in London and meetings with counterparts in Paris and Berlin. More>>

ALSO:

Hit And Run: AG Gives Approval For Inquiry

Attorney-General David Parker has today announced a Government Inquiry will be held into Operation Burnham and related events. The operation undertaken in Tirgiran Valley, Afghanistan, ... More>>

ALSO:

Addressing Climate Change: No New Offshore Exploration Permits

The Coalition Government is taking an important step to address climate change and create a clean, green and sustainable future for New Zealand, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced today. More>>

ALSO:

Road Safety Summit: Actions To Improve Identified

The Local Government Road Safety Summit held last week identified actions that will lead to lasting changes to road safety in New Zealand, says Associate Transport Minister Julie Anne Genter. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages