Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

NZ preventive detention violates human rights: UN experts


Preventive detention in New Zealand violates

human rights, UN experts find

GENEVA (19 April 2018) – New Zealand violated its obligations under the International Covenant for Civil and Political Rights by keeping two men convicted of rape in exceptionally lengthy preventive detention after they had served their sentences, the UN Human Rights Committee found. New Zealand must immediately reconsider the continued detention of the men, and take steps to facilitate their release, the Committee said in its decision, issued today in Geneva.

The full decision is available to read here: http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/_layouts/treatybodyexternal/Download.aspx?symbolno=CCPR%2fC%2f121%2fD%2f2502%2f2014&Lang=en
Allan Brian Miller and Michael John Carroll were each convicted of rape in 1991 and 1988, respectively. Despite being eligible for parole after 10 years of imprisonment, both remained imprisoned, and in individual complaints to the Human Rights Committee filed in 2014 alleged that New Zealand did not afford them access to adequate rehabilitative programs in prison, and that as a result, their continued detention was arbitrary and violated their right to personal liberty.

With the agreement of the parties, the Committee conducted the case through its first-ever oral hearing, allowing the parties’ legal representatives to respond directly, in person and through video conferencing, to Committee members’ questions on New Zealand’s preventive detention law and practice as applied to sex offenders in general, and to Mr. Miller and Mr. Carroll in particular.

In its decision in the case, the Committee found that New Zealand violated its obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, writing that "The Committee considers that as the length of preventive detention increases, the State party bears an increasingly heavy burden to justify continued detention and to show that the threat posed by the individual cannot be addressed by alternative measures. As a result, a level of risk which might reasonably justify a short-term preventive detention, may not necessarily justify a longer period of preventive detention.”

“The institution of preventive detention for sex offenders stands in tension with the right to liberty under the Covenant, which demands that criminal sentences fit the crimes committed. The Committee is of the view that states resorting to open-ended preventive detention must afford robust judicial safeguards applying strict proportionality analysis,” said Mr. Yuval Shany, Vice-chair of the Human Rights Committee.

The Human Rights Committee called on New Zealand to review its relevant legislation governing preventive detention.
ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Abortion Law Reform: "Yes" Wins In Ireland

ALRANZ congratulates the Republic of Ireland on the repeal of the 8th amendment. The Irish Times has reported exit polls predict a landslide in favour of changing the constitution to permit the government to introduce legislation allowing pregnant people to access abortion care in Ireland...

“The Irish government has promised to introduce legislation providing for abortion care on request up to 12 weeks, with no reason given. When the law is passed, Ireland’s abortion laws will be more progressive than New Zealand’s.” More>>

 

Welfare Reform: Expert Advisory Group Established

Minister for Social Development, Hon Carmel Sepuloni, has today announced the formation of an expert advisory group to support the overhaul of the welfare system. More>>

ALSO:

Self-Own Call: Phil Twyford’s CAA Responsibilities Transferred

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has agreed to transfer Transport Minister Hon Phil Twyford’s responsibilities for the Civil Aviation Authority to Associate Transport Minister Hon Julie Anne Genter, following his admission today of making a phone call on a domestic flight after the aircraft doors had shut in preparation for take-off. More>>

Gordon Campbell:
On The M Bovis Outbreak

As the public keeps on being told, there is no risk at all to human health from cows infected with Mycoplasma bovis… Even so, the M bovis outbreak is still doing the head in of Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor, who will be announcing on Monday whether the government intends going down the ‘eradication’ or the ‘management’ path with respect to the outbreak. More>>

ALSO:

Climate Change Adaptation: Technical Group Calls For Urgent Action

Proactively planning how we can adapt to climate change urgently needs to weave into the work of every organisation, at every level, in every sector of New Zealand if we hope to adapt to the effects of climate change... More>>

ALSO:

RNZ: Fishing Industry Lies Revealed In Leaked Report

Some of the country's biggest fishing companies have been under-reporting their hoki catch by hundreds of tonnes, according to a leaked fisheries report. The report has been kept secret from the public for seven years and environmentalists say it casts doubt on industry claims that lucrative hoki is being fished sustainably. More>>

ALSO:

Uni Cuts: VCs At Risk Of Opting Out Of Government’s Vision

Vice-Chancellors need to accept that cutting jobs to meet narrow performance metrics will do nothing to help rebuild an inclusive tertiary education sector that meets the needs of all New Zealanders, the Tertiary Education Union said today. More>>

ALSO:

Union Votes To Strike: Independent Panel Reports On DBH Nurses Agreement

The Independent Panel, which was set up to help reach a Multi-Employer Collective Agreement (MECA) between the New Zealand Nurses’ Organisation and the 20 District Health Boards, has made a series of recommendations to address issues impacting settlement. More>>

ALSO:

Cannabis: Legalisation Referendum Could Happen Sooner

The Drug and Alcohol Practitioners Association of Aotearoa New Zealand says any decision to hold a referendum on legalising cannabis use in 2019, rather than in an election year, would be a welcome one because the issue is too important to be treated like a political football. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages