Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Tough on Crime or Smart on Crime – the End of an Era?

Tough on Crime or Smart on Crime – the End of an Era?

In a hard-hitting address to the Wellington Combined Probus Meeting this morning, Dr Kim Workman, Research Associate at the Institute of Criminology, Victoria University, urged those present, to ignore the ‘fear of crime’ messages promoted by politicians and the media.

He discussed the key messages that political parties have promoted at elections over the last thirty years, whether those political messages are evidence-based, and whether they will reduce crime. He concluded by talking about what happens when a political party proposes a new way of doing things, and its likelihood of success.

“We have to stop believing that talkback radio and social media sites represent public opinion,” he said. :”We have to stop dressing up an extreme position and parading it as evidence. The public is not a uniform entity with one single, static viewpoint. It is made up of many differing and changing opinions. Whilst a majority of people may think that the courts are too soft, they also recognise that prison is expensive and damaging. People support alternative, non-punitive responses, once they have the opportunity to consider a case in detail. The idea that everyone supports harsh punishment is a vote-gathering delusion.

“The problem we have is that the government has not commissioned a comprehensive survey of public attitudes toward crime and punishment since 2003, so we don’t know accurately know what current public opinion is. We need one urgently, for two reasons. First, public attitudes heavily influence political motivation, and judicial behaviour. Good public policy on crime and punishment issues establishes what social scientists call “the boundaries of political permission” i.e. the limits or borders within which public policy will be supported, or tolerated, by the public.”

“Understanding how the public frames an issue, will help us attain a better understanding of public opinion, and map out our public thinking. We know from recent research overseas, that the same people that call for increased imprisonment for violent offenders, are also highly supportive of policies that favour rehabilitation over imprisonment, supported expanded drug and alcohol treatment, and the use of noncustodial, community based or alternative sentences with both non-violent and violent offenders. Claims by politicians and “tough on crime” lobby groups that the public want a more punitive approach are not supported by evidence.”

“He urged the audience to look at what was happening overseas. “Where do we go next? In the 1990’s, we turned to the United States for a solution. We need to pay them another visit. Over the last decade, the US prison population has reduced by 14%, and 38 of the 50 States have introduced legislation to reduce the prison population; abandoning three strikes legislation, doing away with restrictive bail laws, making it easier for prisoners to be released on parole, reducing sentence lengths for non-violent prisoners, and reinvesting resources into community-based alternatives. This has all been achieved without a risk to public safety. “

“The Minister of Justice is planning a Criminal Justice Summit, to discuss and develop a long-term criminal justice strategy. It is likely to provide for wide public consultation, and an effort to determine what the public are thinking.”

Let’s start by reading Dr Ian Lambie’s two reports; ‘Using evidence to build a better justice system, and the Prevention of Youth Offending.

“We have to decide as a nation, whether to rely on policy-based evidence, or evidence-based policy. We have to decide whether we want to be tough on crime, or smart on crime. The government has signalled an intention to take a different approach for the first time in thirty years. We owe it to the government to listen, to debate, and to discuss. “

The full speech is available at: https://www.criminologycollective.nz/2018/06/13/tough-on-crime-or-smart-on-crime-the-end-of-an-era/
Further Reading:
Recommended Reading
1. Dr Ian Lambie, Using evidence to build a better justice system: The challenge of rising prison costs, Office of the Prime Minister’s Chief Science Adviser, March 2018
http://www.pmcsa.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/Using-evidence-to-build-a-better-justice-system.pdf

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Gordon Campbell: On The EU Trade Talks With NZ

In the very unlikely event that all will be smooth sailing in negotiating access to Europe for agricultural products from this part of the world, the EU/NZ negotiations could be wrapped up in about two years – which is relatively fast when it comes to these kind of deals. At best then, we won’t see any concrete benefits until half way through the next term of government.

There is however, a far more pressing trade problem facing this country, and Europe (via Malmstrom) is right at the centre of it. This involves the fate of our – and Europe’s – booming trade with Iran, which has been targeted with sweeping punitive sanctions by US President Donald Trump, and these are due to take effect on November 4. More>>

 

World Refugee Day: What 7 Former Refugee Kids Love About New Zealand

RASNZ asked 7 members of their specialist youth service (along with two staff members who work with refugee background youth) how they felt about New Zealand – and filmed the responses. More>>

ALSO:

DHBs: Nurses Plan Strike Action For Next Month

Nurses across the country have confirmed a notice of a 24-hour strike, starting on 5 July. District Health Boards (DHB) were working on contingency plans following a notice to strike by the New Zealand Nurses Organisation. More>>

ALSO:

Oranga Tamariki: Children's Ministry Shifts Away From Putting Kids In Care

Children's Minister Tracey Martin is signalling a shift away from putting children into care, and towards intensive intervention in a child's home. More>>

ALSO:

But No Way To Tell Why: Significant Drop In HIV Diagnoses

A new report shows that for the first time since 2011, the number of annual HIV diagnoses in New Zealand has fallen. But without funding for a repeat of ongoing surveys to monitor changes in behaviour, testing and attitudes, health workers can’t be sure what’s driving the decrease. More>>

ALSO:

On Her Majesty's Public Service: Inquiry Into Spying Claims Extended To All Govt Agencies

In March, State Services Commissioner Peter Hughes announced an inquiry after it was revealed the firm spied on Canterbury earthquake claimants for Southern Response. The inquiry was furthered widened to include the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, who had been spying on Greenpeace staff. More>>

ALSO:

 
 
 
 
 

LATEST HEADLINES

  • PARLIAMENT
  • POLITICS
  • REGIONAL
 
 

Featured InfoPages