ACT Free Press -The BCS Prime Minister
ACT Free Press -The BCS Prime Minister
The BCS Prime
Minister
Jacinda Ardern studied a Bachelor
of Communication Studies at Waikato University, where
students learn not to change how things are but how people
see them. She became Prime Minister by polling 37 per cent
with the exact same policies that Andrew Little polled 24
per cent. All of her experience tells her good
communications are more important than good policy.
Blandness
Ardern’s speech
this weekend was a master class in communications. She
walked out onto the stage with a cheek-mounted microphone,
TED-talk style, and spoke of a compassionate government in a
country to be proud of. It was so bland John Key could have
given a similar speech with the same policies and more dad
jokes, but Ardern is an even better communicator than
Key.
What Did She
Say?
Ardern wants a growing economy that is
working for all of us, wellbeing for New Zealanders and
their families, and a country we can be proud of. No doubt
all of these outcomes test well in focus groups, but how
will they be achieved? This could be good news, perhaps the
Government’s swarm of working groups are not groundwork
for radical transformation, just part of a giant marketing
exercise?
How to Tell if a Policy is
Absurd
If the opposite of a policy sounds
absurd, then the policy is absurd. Who would campaign for a
shrinking economy that doesn’t work, misery for New
Zealanders and their families, and a country we should be
ashamed of on the global stage? The opposite of ACT’s
policies are more state control in education, heavier handed
regulation of the economy, higher levels of taxation and
Government expenditure, and more Government ownership. All
inferior opposites of ACT’s actual policies, but not
absurd.
If You Don’t Use Political
Power…
…You lose it. Ardern has enormous
power. As the Prime Minister, any speech she gives is news.
People expect that the Prime Minister will say something
meaningful that affects their lives. We wonder how many
content-free speeches a Prime Minister can give before
people stop listening?
What She Should
Have Said
We are in big trouble. Poor people
around the world keep entering the global economy, driving
down the price of low skilled labour. The 21st century will
be the greatest yet if you are educated, but if you are
unskilled you are toast. Unfortunately, our education system
churns out one-in-five kids illiterate and innumerate. Our
approach to welfare has one-in-eight kids born onto a
benefit. Productivity growth across the economy is anaemic.
If we carry on like this we will become a two-speed society,
then a divided one, then worse.
The True
State of the State in New Zealand
Why does
the New Zealand Government own power companies, an airline,
a mail business, and a television station that makes reality
TV? How has it come to have over half of New Zealanders on
some form of government benefit? How can it take longer to
get permission for a building than to actually build it? If
the state is in education to level the playing field, why do
decile one schools get almost no students into Engineering,
Law, and Medicine?
What to
Do?
Rather than continuing the style and
policy of the Clark-Key era, Ardern could use her
communication skills to sell something that’s actually
challenging to sell, real reform. A good outline of what she
could do is still contained in the 2025 Taskforce reports.
No Government can move New Zealand closer to major markets,
significantly increase the population, or make us smarter.
Any Government can choose to rationalise its own activities
so that it is efficient, not holding the country back.
Starting from First
Principles
If we started again without the
souvenirs of decades of political horse trading, what would
Government own, spend money on, and regulate? Most of the
SOE’s would be gone. The Government would subsidise
education and regulate minimum standards, like it does with
Early Childhood Education, but it would not otherwise be
involved in schools. There would be income insurance with
strict obligations, but accommodation supplements and
working for families would be gone. Students would again
borrow money with interest.
Something
Truly Bold
Rebuilding Government from the
ground up, keeping only the activities that really can’t
be performed any other way would be bold. Real reform really
does require good communications. It would also make sure
the poorest New Zealanders have a shot at life in the 21st
century and thus would achieve Ardern’s stated goals. It
does seem unlikely though, and National who dismissed the
2025 taskforce out of hand are no better. That’s why New
Zealand needs
ACT.