Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search

 

Quebec Court Challenge to Affect End of Life Choice Bill

Media Release from Euthanasia-Free NZ

Quebec Court Challenge to Affect End of Life Choice Bill

A few hours ago two disabled Quebecers appeared in a Montreal court to challenge the provincial and federal ‘assisted dying’ laws.

Euthanasia-Free NZ is following the 33-day trial with interest, as its outcome could affect the way the proposed End of Life Choice Bill is interpreted in New Zealand.

Jean Truchon has cerebral palsy and Nicole Gladu has post-polio syndrome. Both use wheelchairs and have incurable medical conditions that are allegedly also degenerative.

Since Truchon and Gladu are not yet at the end of their lives, they are not eligible to have a doctor end their lives by lethal drugs.

The proposed New Zealand End of Life Choice Bill has a similar wording to that of the Canadian and Quebec Medical Assistance in Dying laws. To be eligible a person needs to be “in an advanced state of irreversible decline in capability” and “experience unbearable suffering that cannot be relieved in a manner that he or she considers tolerable”.

David Seymour claims that disabled people would not qualify under the End of Life Choice Bill, because, he argues, a disability does not involve “irreversible decline”. However, Truchon and Gladu claim to be eligible under similar clauses and restricted only by the additional requirement in the Quebec law specifying that a person needs to “be at the end of life”.

Along similar lines, the Canadian federal euthanasia law requires that the person’s “natural death has become reasonably foreseeable” although with no specific time period before death is expected to occur.

Canadian euthanasia laws are being challenged by others too.

Julia Lamb, in her late 20s, has spinal muscular dystrophy and is arguing that the “reasonably foreseeable” clause is discriminating against her. The trial is expected to take place in the British Columbia Supreme Court in November 2019.

Robyn Moro. 68, had Parkinson’s disease and is also a plaintiff in the upcoming trial. She was initially denied eligibility for lethal drugs because her death was not “reasonably foreseeable”, but died by lethal drugs in 2017 after an Ontario Supreme Court ruling lead her doctor to change her mind.

An expert panel, commissioned by the Canadian government, released their reports on 12 December 2018 on whether the law should be extended to mature minors under 18, to people who have made advance requests before they lost mental competency, and to people with a mental disorder as their sole underlying medical condition.

The End of Life Choice Bill would be challenged also.

Gladu and Truchon argue that the requirement to be at the end of one’s life is ambiguous. They say it creates uncertainty, leading some people to die by suicide or a hunger strike.

Their lawyer, Jean-Pierre Menard, plans to argue that the Canadian and Quebec euthanasia laws infringe on their right to life and security as well as their right to equality.

Euthanasia-Free NZ is concerned that, if the End of Life Choice Bill is passed, it would also be challenged and extended in the name of “equality”.

“Once society moves from a blanket ban on assisted suicide to a law allowing exceptions, there would be no logical defense against adding more and more exceptions”, says Renée Joubert, Executive Officer of Euthanasia-Free NZ.

“A law that allows death by lethal drugs to a certain group of suffering people discriminates against other people who also feel they are suffering unbearably.

Since the Attorney-General’s report stated that the Bill discriminates on the basis of age, it is likely that eligibility would be extended to people younger than 18.

“Suffering is subjective and universal. It wouldn’t make sense to discriminate against people with non-terminal conditions or even people who are healthy but suffering in other ways.

“We don’t want anyone to suffer. The current law is not broken – the health system is. Many New Zealanders don’t have timely access to the tests, treatment and care they need. Many doctors are not trained in end-of-life care and pain management. There are too few Hospice beds. The mental health system is failing many families.

“Without equitable access to care and services, assisted suicide and euthanasia would not be a free choice.”

Euthanasia-Free NZ implores politicians to reject the End of Life Choice Bill and focus their energy on ensuring equitable access to health services in New Zealand.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Discussion Doc: 'Firearm Prohibition Orders' Power For Police

“FPOs would prevent people from being around others who have firearms, using them under supervision, or being at a location that enables access to guns. FPOs set conditions which people must follow, allow Police to monitor the conditions, and create penalties for breaches.

“In practice this may mean a person subject to a FPO could not live in or visit a property where firearms are held, even if the firearm owner is licensed. They could not be in a vehicle which is carrying a firearm. They could not go hunting even under supervision. They could still associate with lawful gun owners, but not if a firearm is present." More>>

 

Police: Armed Response Team In Low Level Arrest, 'Preventative' Patrols

Police later said the stop was entirely appropriate, and resulted in the man being arrested without incident for "breaching conditions". More>>

ALSO:

Startable Political Party: Sustainable NZ Party Holds Launch

The party's leader, Vernon Tava, told supporters at their launch over the weekend that the party will be pro environment, science and business. More>>

  • Out-Link - Sue Bradford: Is Sustainable NZ an endangered species from its birth? Or are friends in the wings? — Pundit
  • Children's Commissioner Comment: Damning Oranga Tamariki Review Of Uplift Case

    “The practice review released by Oranga Tamariki today is rigorous and robust. However, it describes a litany of failure at every step. It is a damning indictment of inadequate social work practice. Many social workers will welcome the light being shone on this case." More>>

    ALSO:

    Environment Commissioner: ‘Huge’ Data Gaps Undermine Stewardship

    Environment Commissioner Simon Upton says ‘huge’ gaps in data and knowledge undermine our stewardship of the environment and is calling for concerted action to improve the system. More>>

  • Image via Out-Link - Focusing Aotearoa New Zealand’s environmental reporting system
  • Science Media Centre - Measuring changes to our environment – Expert Reaction
  • Local Govt NZ - LGNZ backs call for better environmental reporting
  • Environmental Defence Society - EDS endorses Commissioner for the Environment’s report
  • Federated Farmers - Environment data gaps no basis for current policy swings
  • Zero Carbon Bill Passes: "Historic Day For Landmark Climate Change Legislation"

    The landmark legislation which provides a framework to support New Zealanders to prepare for, and adapt to, the effects of climate change delivers on the Government’s Coalition and Confidence Supply agreements, and is a key part of the Government’s plan to tackle the long-term challenge of climate change. More>>

    ALSO:

    Gordon Campbell: On National’s Anointing Of Christopher Luxon

    Clearly, the National Party hierarchy is very, very excited about Christopher Luxon... Such are the levels of anticipation that this week, Luxon was instantly forgiven for making up welfare policy, off the top of his head. More>>

    ALSO:

    "Serious Concerns": Officers Discuss Planting Drugs To Search Cars

    The Authority found that, while there was no proof this actually happened, some officers' comments demonstrated they were prepared to engage in improper and potentially discriminatory policing practices. More>>

    ALSO:

     
     
     
     
     

    LATEST HEADLINES

    • PARLIAMENT
    • POLITICS
    • REGIONAL
     
     

    InfoPages News Channels