Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Closing the Gap statement on CGT decision

Today’s decision ruling out a Capital Gains Tax for New Zealand is hypocritical from a Government that campaigned on improving wellbeing, reducing inequality and governing on the basis of fairness, efficiency, and rationality, said Peter Malcolm, the spokesperson for the income equality group Closing the Gap.

“Improving wellbeing and cutting inequality requires a tax system that boosts the income of the those on lower incomes and reduces that of the very well-off,” Mr. Malcolm said. “But that is not going to happen under a government that previously ruled out more steeply progressive tax scales, and that has now decided against a comprehensive capital gains tax.”

Let’s revisit some of the rational arguments for a capital gains tax, Mr. Malcolm said.

Firstly New Zealand is the only western democracy to not tax capital income.

Secondly, economic efficiency and fairness mandate the introduction of a CGT. Not taxing capital profit skews investment toward property, which does nothing for workers or for the nation’s productivity.

“I feel really sad that a Government that has promised so much, has given way to the wealthy, the selfish and the greedy,” Mr. Malcolm said. Without a CGT there is an incentive to invest in assets where the capital profit is not taxed. Likewise with farming where too many farmers and their bankers ignored profitability because the farm was likely to inflate in value delivering tax free profits. Our productivity as a country has long been lower than equivalent western nations. One reason is that too much capital is invested in assets for tax free capital gain and not enough in better technology and mechanisation to boost productivity. As a result New Zealanders wages are lower and we all are poorer than we should be.

The other issue; that of fairness, needs careful thought. Many in the private sector and a number of politicians are claiming that small businesses will become less attractive to their owners. The argument is that owners of small businesses get up and go to work in the morning because they know that one day they will sell their business and make a tax free profit on that sale.

But what about all the other hard working New Zealanders who also get up early and work hard all day for wages. A sheep shearer is taxed on his or her income, as is a bricklayer, carpenter or school teacher. These are hard working people who have their earnings fully taxed. Where is the fairness in allowing owners of a business, farm or rental home be somehow exempt from tax on their capital profits.

In looking at the question of fairness it would be quite unfair to exempt the family home. Very expensive homes will become a favoured investment if the home is left outside the net. Certainly there are very good reasons to encourage the ownership of your own home. One is that home ownership creates greater financial resilience at retirement. But there could be exemption levels.

And to sum all this up, where is the fairness in, a person in a job paying $50,000 a year, paying approximately $8000 in tax and a person selling an asset with a profit of $50,000 paying no tax.

© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Gordon Campbell: On Reforming Parliament’s Toxic Culture

It would be nice to think Parliament was a forum where rationality ruled – and where policies are raised and evaluated in terms of their contribution to the greater good. Obviously, it isn’t like that... More>>

Historic Assualt Allegation: Parliamentary Service Staff Member Stood Down
Rt Hon Trevor Mallard said today: “I do not want to cut across any employment or possible police investigations, but I am satisfied that the Parliamentary Service has removed a threat to the safety of women working in the Parliamentary complex." More>>


Fatal 2018 Crash: Police Officer Should Not Have Engaged In Pursuit

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that a Police officer should not have tried to stop or pursue a car thought to contain young people in Palmerston North on 28 May 2018. More>>


New Poverty Targets: Goals Overlook 174000 Children In Worst Poverty

Child Poverty Action Group is pleased to see the Government set ambitious 10-year targets for child poverty reduction, but we are disappointed not to see a target set for improving thousands of young lives where the worst of poverty is found. More>>


Study: Guidelines Needed To Avoid Risks In Government AI

New Zealand is a world leader in government algorithm use – but measures are needed to guard against their dangers. This is the conclusion of a New Zealand Law Foundation-funded report from the University of Otago’s Artificial Intelligence and Law in New Zealand Project. More>>


Pike River: Families Welcome Opening Of Drift

The group representing 29 of the Pike River Families - the Pike River Family Reference Group - has welcomed the unsealing of the mine at a private family event this morning... More>>


Auckland Harbour Bridge: New Design For Walking And Cycling Crossing

The NZ Transport Agency has released plans for its preferred option for a shared path over the Auckland Harbour Bridge which will transform walking and cycling not only across the harbour, but throughout the city. The Transport Agency says its preferred ... More>>



Shaw First Reading Speech: Climate Change Response Bill

Madam Speaker, today we begin the task of amending the Climate Change Response Act [2002], to fulfil the commitment that we have made, as a country, to limit global warming to no more than 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. More>>


Housing: More Unsold Kiwibuild Houses Bought By Govt

The Crown underwrite for unsold Kiwibuild homes has been triggered for a second time. Now lack of sales in Mike Greer's development in Canterbury and Auckland means the government has had to buy back seven more homes. More>>





InfoPages News Channels