Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Six Days Left to Sign Climate Petition

Climate Change Response (Zero Carbon Emissions Act) Amendment Bill critique

By Anna Dobson


There are 6 days left to sign the petition Sign Petition: NZ, Declare a Climate Emergency. 6129 people have signed and we need 16,000 people minimum to sign before May 30 2019.

We are asking tangata whenua to Declare a Climate Emergency as Kaitiaki of Aotearoa, so our MPs will Declare a Climate Emergency and make the Climate Change Response Amendment Bill 2019 a coordinated new independent piece of legislation that requires amendments to the CMA, RMA and EEZ-CS Act so that the Agriculture, Energy and Transport Industries of Aotearoa are legally obliged to comply with legislation demanding that they limit their carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide emissions in their existing business activities, and in future activities proposed by permit/consent applicant/applications.

All industrial short lived and long lived greenhouse gas emissions from the Agriculture, Energy and Transport industries will comply with enforceable carbon emission targets, and that those industries emissions targets are accountable to, and audited by, an independent regulatory authority with powers to penalise industries that fail to limit their emissions, and powers to halt trading, fine and prosecute, industries that continue to flout carbon emission targets established in an RMA + CMA + EEZ-CS coordinated independent new zero carbon emission law, rather than the non legally binding Zero Carbon Act 2019 proposed by James Shaw.

The Climate Change Response (Zero Carbon Act) Amendment Bill proposed by James Shaw fails to make the industries whom are responsible for, on an industrial scale, emitting most methane and nitrous oxide, and carbon dioxide, respectively, Agriculture, Energy and Transport, legally obliged, and legally accountable, to achieving their proposed limited emission targets. There is no independent Greenhouse Emission Target Regulatory Authority charged with enforcing legal compliance and prosecuting, non compliant industries, named in this new Zero Carbon Act 2019.There is no legal requirement in James Shaw’s proposed Act, which makes Agriculture, Energy or Transport obliged to comply with emission targets proposed in The Climate Change Response (Zero Carbon Act) Amendment Bill. The lack of legal compulsion in this proposed Act in obliging industrial compliance with limiting and achieving, each industries emission targets is obscenely conspicuous and is a failure of duty of care to tangata whenua, making this proposed Act hopeless. See excerpt below from


Subpart 5—Effect of 2050 target and emissions budgets

5ZJEffect of failure to meet 2050 target and emissions budgets


No remedy or relief is available for failure to meet the 2050 target or an emissions budget, and the 2050 target and emissions budgets are not enforceable in a court of law, except as set out in this section.


If the 2050 target or an emissions budget is not met, a court may make a declaration to that effect, together with an award of costs.


If a declaration is made and becomes final after all appeals or rights of appeal expire or are disposed of, the Minister must, as soon as practicable, present to the House of Representatives a document that—


brings the declaration to the attention of the House of Representatives; and


contains advice on the Government’s response to the declaration.

5ZK2050 target and emissions budget are permissive considerations


A person or body may, if they think fit, take the 2050 target or an emissions budget into account in the exercise or performance of a public function, power, or duty conferred on that person or body by or under law (subject to other requirements that apply by or under law).


However, a failure by any person or body to take the 2050 target, an emissions budget, or guidance issued undersection 5ZL into account does not invalidate anything done by that person or body.

We endorse the Climate Change Response Group Generation Zero’s submissionhttp://zerocarbonact.nz/assets/Uploads/Generation-Zero-Zero-Carbon-Bill-consultation-submission-July-2018.pdf

Following excerpt from http://zerocarbonact.nz/assets/Uploads/Generation-Zero-Zero-Carbon-Bill-consultation-submission-July-2018.pdf

Importance of a well-designed, long-term framework Climate change is bigger than politics. We need political parties to work together and look beyond election cycles. To date, New Zealand’s climate change response has been incoherent and inadequate. A long-term legal framework will help to ensure that New Zealand’s transition to a resilient, zero carbon economy occurs by the fairest, and most cost-effective and sustainable pathway possible. Generation Zero agrees with the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment and the Productivity Commission that the UK’s Climate Change Act 2008 provides a useful model for developing a strong legal framework in New Zealand. We also agree that the UK model must be appropriately tailored to suit the New Zealand context. This approach has underpinned the development of our Zero Carbon Act policy blueprint to date.

We submit that a well-designed Zero Carbon Act, based on the UK model, and backed by cross-party support, will promote the following interrelated outcomes: • Accountability: The mandatory duties and legally-binding targets in the Zero Carbon Act, combined with the oversight provided by the Climate Change Commission, will ensure that the Government is held to account politically and legally. Accountability drives action and promotes certainty. It must be a central pillar of New Zealand’s climate change response. • Long-term certainty: The long-term focus of the Zero Carbon Act is valuable for two reasons. The first is to provide communities and businesses with the certainty they need to: • plan ahead; • take up opportunities created by a zero carbon economy; • invest with confidence in low emission options; • take complementary steps to reduce emissions; and • understand what New Zealand’s transition to a zero carbon future will mean for them.

Accountability mechanisms We submit that emission budgets (and other legal duties in the Zero Carbon Act) must be capable of legal enforcement. This will increase certainty for communities and businesses, and promote accountability, which drives action. It is generally understood that the targets and duties in the UK Climate Change Act are legally binding. However, this has not yet been tested in the courts, and the UK Act’s vague drafting means there is considerable uncertainty around what the courts could do.38 We must learn from these oversights. In particular, the Zero Carbon Act should clarify the legal implications of the Government failing to (a) set an appropriate emissions budget; or (b) set policy plans capable of meeting future budgets. We recommend that the Zero Carbon Act is drafted to facilitate judicial review of these matters. This would allow the courts to compel compliance through the usual forms of relief for unlawful government decision-making. The Act should expressly state who has standing to bring a claim, and the parameters these legal duties should be reviewed against.39

An advantage of the long-term nature of the Zero Carbon Act is that these accountability mechanisms can properly focus on addressing problems prospectively. In other words, it is more impactful to rectify, by legal means if necessary, a poorly set budget or an inadequate policy plan well in advance of New Zealand going off-track, as opposed to retrospectively dealing with an emissions budget being exceeded. However, it is also necessary to guard against the latter. We recommend that the Zero Carbon Act contain an internal penalty regime for this purpose. One possible penalty for failing to meet a budget is requiring the Government to invest additional funds (equivalent to the cost of purchasing international carbon credits to remedy the emission overshoot) into domestic mitigation policies and/or infrastructure.

Please sign and share this petition https://www.parliament.nz/en/pb/petitions/document/PET_87778/petition-of-phillip-clarke-declare-climate-change-a-national?fbclid=IwAR3GuGf4ehoMr2dbUKxtpMXtrvOniPftd2BUKUgZrsftAU2XlU38dPgtDd8

to Declare a Climate Emergency in Aotearoa, to support Generation Zero’s Zero Carbon Bill Consultation Submission in favour of the current Climate Change Response Amendment Bill.


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines


Principals Reject Offer: Primary Teachers Vote For Settlement

Primary teachers have voted to ratify a proposed settlement that will give them pay parity with their secondary colleagues, but disappointed primary principals have rejected a settlement that was unchanged from a previously rejected offer.

NZEI Te Riu Roa President Lynda Stuart said the outcome was a big win for teachers, who had campaigned alongside principals for 18 months and held three strike days - including New Zealand's largest ever strike alongside their secondary colleagues. More>>


Remaking Elections: Call For Four-Year Term, More MPs

A Victoria University report is proposing extending the parliamentary term to four years, and increasing the number of MPs, so politicians can plan better for the future. More>>


Health: Ban On Smoking In Cars With Children Passes First Reading

The Smoke-free Environments Amendment Bill would allow police to issue $50 fines for those smoking with passengers under 18 years of age. More>>


Fair Pay Agreements Good: CTU Releases Report On Sector Bargaining

The Council of Trade Unions has released an independent report conducted by economic research company BERL into the validity of sector bargaining. More>>


Goldsmith New National Finance Spokesperson: Amy Adams To Leave Politics In 2020

Amy Adams has announced she will retire from politics at the 2020 election and as a consequence of that decision she has chosen to stand down from the spokesperson roles she holds in the Party. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Government's Cosmetic Banking Reforms

The elephant in the room as the government carries out its latest bout of tinkerings with our banking practice is the extraordinary level of profit-taking still being extracted by the Australian Banking Gang from ordinary New Zealanders. Yes indeed, ... More>>


IPCA: Offensive Language, Misuse Of Pepper Spray

The Independent Police Conduct Authority has found that, following a pursuit in Auckland, a man was dealt with inappropriately and unprofessionally by a Police officer during his arrest. More>>


Stats NZ: Gender Inclusive Questions Introduced

More than 28,000 New Zealand households will be asked to take part in the upcoming Household Economic Survey. Starting this year, the survey will ask people to describe their gender – whether that is male, female, or if they see themselves another way, such as one of many non-binary genders. More>>

New Report: Are We Listening To Children?

A report released today is a sharp reminder that what children and young people say makes a difference, and that it’s time we paid more attention to their views, says Children’s Commissioner Andrew Becroft. More>>





InfoPages News Channels