Gordon Campbell | Parliament TV | Parliament Today | News Video | Crime | Employers | Housing | Immigration | Legal | Local Govt. | Maori | Welfare | Unions | Youth | Search


Euthanasia vote tighter than public may think

Euthanasia vote tighter than public may think

Half of MPs allowed to exercise conscience votes rejected the End of Life Choice Bill at Second Reading.

Eighteen of the 120 votes were along party lines: namely NZ First, the Green and the sponsor of the bill, David Seymour. This meant that eighteen votes out of 120 were not in fact conscience votes.

Of the remaining 102 MPs who were allowed to vote free from party pressure, 50 voted against the bill and 52 voted in favour. This shows the real divide among MPs in an issue that has split parliament.

A recurring theme in Wednesday’s speeches, from MPs on both sides, was concern that vulnerable people could be at risk of pressure and coercion to request euthanasia. Several MPs referred to elder abuse specifically.

The serious concerns MPs have about this bill will not go away if eligibility were to be limited to the terminally ill. Since terminal illness involves disability, such a bill would still send a message to disabled people that their lives are valued less than the lives of able-bodied people.

There is a grey area between terminal illness and some with “grievous and irremediable medical conditions”. People with these conditions say there would be subtle pressure from society on them to intentionally choose to live and not choose euthanasia in their dark days and months.

It is concerning that a Kiwi with a serious medical condition, but expected to live a fairly long time, could simply refuse the treatment that is keeping them alive and thus become “terminal” and eligible for euthanasia.

#DefendNZ Creative Director Henoch Kloosterboer said the opposition voice will keep growing.

"It's not going to change. It's not going to stop. There are so many more conversations to be had between now and Third Reading," he said.

"This thing isn't going away. The risks aren't going away. The burden of proof is on the proponents to prove vulnerable New Zealanders will not be placed at risk. One wrongful death would be one too many."

#DefendNZ thanks the 50 out of 102 MPs who exercised their conscience vote against the Bill. We also commend the many MPs who voted for the bill, but expressed their concerns about the Bill and are open to reconsidering their vote at Third Reading.

MPs who voted against the bill are as follows. A ‘*’ denotes which MPs changed their vote since the first reading seeing the risks.

Kiritapu Allan* – Labour - List
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi – National – List
Maggie Barry – National – North Shore
Andrew Bayly – National – Hunua
David Bennett – National – Hamilton East
Dan Bidois – National - Northcote
Simon Bridges – National – Tauranga
Simeon Brown – National – Pakuranga
Gerry Brownlee – National – Ilam
David Carter – National – List
David Clark – Labour – Dunedin North
Jacquie Dean – National – Waitaki
Sarah Dowie – National – Invercargill
Paulo Garcia – National – List
Paul Goldsmith – National – List
Nathan Guy* – National - Otaki
Joanne Hayes – National – List
Harete Hipango* – National - Whanganui
Anahila Kanongata'aSuisuiki – Labour – List
Denise Lee – National – Maungakiekie
Melissa Lee – National – List
Agnes Loheni – National – List
Tim Macindoe – National – Hamilton West
Todd McClay – National – Rotorua
Ian McKelvie – National – Rangitikei
Todd Muller – National – Bay of Plenty
Alfred Ngaro – National – List
Damien O'Connor – Labour – West Coast
Simon O'Connor – National – Tamaki
Parmjeet Parmar – National – List
Chris Penk – National – Helensville
Maureen Pugh – National – List
Shane Reti – National – Whangarei
Adrian Rurawhe* – Labour – Te Tai Hauauru
Deborah Russell* – Labour – New Lynn
Jenny Salesa – Labour – Manukau East
Alastair Scott – National – Wairarapa
Aupito William Sio – Labour – Mangere
Nick Smith – National – Nelson
Jamie Strange – Labour – List
Rino Tirakatene – Labour – Te Tai Tonga
Anne Tolley* – National - East Coast
Phil Twyford – Labour – Te Atatu
Louise Upston – National – Taupo
Nicky Wagner – National – List
Hamish Walker* – National – Clutha-Southland
Meka Whaitiri* – Labour – Ikaroa Rawhiti
Michael Wood* – Labour – Mt Roskill
Michael Woodhouse – National – List
Jonathan Young – National – New Plymouth


© Scoop Media

Parliament Headlines | Politics Headlines | Regional Headlines

Hope For Nature: A New Deal For The Commons

Joseph Cederwall on The Dig: The current global paradigm is devastating life everywhere by disrupting vital “ecosystem services” like the food, water, and climate regulation systems that both humanity and biodiversity depend on in an interconnected balance.

It is increasingly clear that the primary driver of this crisis is the limiting and infectious worldview around land and resource use so central to the global capitalist system. To fully understand the biodiversity crisis and explore what comes next, it is necessary to address this mind-virus at the heart of our modern civilisation – the dominion worldview. More>>


SOP For Gun Bill: New Measures For Modified Pistols

The new controls will • Prohibit short-barrelled semi-automatic rifles which currently are defined as pistols because they are shorter than 762 millimetres. • Introduce tighter controls over pistol carbine conversion kits… • Prohibit firearms which contain a part known as a centrefire lower receiver… More>>

'Culturally Arranged Visitors Visa': Fix For Marriage Visa Issue

Earlier this year Immigration New Zealand issued guidance to front line Immigration staff that made it significantly harder for people to get visas to visit their partner. That guidance no longer applies with today’s announcement. More>>


Conflict Of Interest For Key Member: Budget Data Breach Investigation Shut Down

State Services Commissioner Peter Hughes has today terminated the investigation into how Budget-sensitive material was accessed at the Treasury and appointed a new inquirer. More>>

RNZ Report: Mysterious Foundation Loaning NZ First Money

A mysterious foundation that loans money to New Zealand First is under scrutiny, with a university law professor saying although it's lawful, it fails to provide the transparency voters need in a democracy. More>>

Justice: Criminal Cases Review Commission Established

“We’ve seen how our justice system can very occasionally get things spectacularly wrong, even with rights of appeals, and there needs to be a chance for the innocent on the right grounds to seek a final review of their case...” More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Why Sustainable NZ Isn't Self-Sustaining

Asking whether this new, environmentally focussed party can make the 5% MMP threshold may be the wrong question, though. It's more achievable goal would be to knock the Greens below the 5% threshold ... More>>


Report On Consultation: Future Of Tomorrow's Schools

“The 1989 Tomorrow’s Schools reform introduced one of world’s most devolved schooling systems where each school operates largely in isolation of each other... It empowered local communities and modernised an overly bureaucratic system but also led over time to uneven outcomes between schools.” More>>


National Education Doc:




InfoPages News Channels