Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search

 


Cooper's Comments About GE Challenged

Cooper's Comments About GE Challenged


Scientific reaction has been swift to comments by Oxford University’s Professor Alan Cooper about the implications of a study of ancient DNA on the release of genetically modified organisms into the environment.

Professor Cooper argued that the New Zealand Government should continue its moratorium on the release of GE organisms for at least another five years because a study reported in Science magazine showed persistence of DNA in the soil for many thousands of years.

Scientists who spoke to the Life Sciences Network said Professor Cooper appears to have made a very significant leap of judgement well beyond the evidence reported in the study he co-authored.

“The best interpretation of his study is that it shows DNA has been around for a very long time and that it hasn’t done anything outside the realms of what you’d expect in an evolutionary sense. There’s no reason to expect the future is going to be any different,” says NZ Association of Scientists President, Dr Mike Berridge.

“He’s done some good science on ancient DNA, but that’s as far as it goes. Anything else is mere speculation and is not supported by any of the relevant knowledge we have from other research.”

Dr Val Giddings believes Professor Cooper is “way beyond his expertise. It’s as if we’re being warned about the evils of alcohol because we may be drawn to a pub which may be hit by a meteor!”

“What he appears to be saying,” says Dr David Penny, Director of the Alan Wilson Centre for Molecular Ecology and Evolution, “is that there might be some serious negative impact if we allow GE crops and animals into the environment which will only become apparent in future years.”

“The problem with that scenario is that his science shows we have had clumps of DNA in the soil for thousands of years already, and these haven’t had any significant impacts that we’ve been aware of so far, so its obviously not a serious problem.”

Part of the answer may lie in the fact that ancient DNA has only been found in permafrost and in caves which have provided a very sheltered environment.

Dr Neal Stewart from University of Tennessee says it would be relatively simple task to assay soils from various agronomic fields to establish if there are any ancient DNA sequences of significant length present and then determine what kinds of genes they are.

“But the issue is, so what? Dr Cooper’s flagellations don’t appear to be commensurate with any of the risks I can imagine. There’s no evidence that any of the ancient DNA has caused any harm. The DNA used in gene technology is exactly the same as DNA which has been around for thousands of years.”

“If he’s right, should we be afraid of old pathogenic DNA that is no longer in current living species?” asks Dr Paul Atkinson, rhetorically. “Would it mean old DNA ex-viruses could perhaps rise up and bite us on the bum? Wouldn’t you expect that to have happened already, and be evident for science to see?

“By the same logic this all pre-supposes that broken down DNA from genetically modified organisms would somehow be different in genes, regulators etc than those “natural” DNA components currently found in huge abundance in the environment in various stages of decomposition. It doesn’t really work out. You can’t build active genes from repetitive sequences, or even degraded ones (something Dr Cooper himself has pointed out in his public talks in New Zealand).”

David Penny sums up the illogicality of Dr Cooper’s comments with “if he’s right, cow pats should be banned! They are obviously a haven for soil and intestinal bacteria to meet and mix and therefore this should be stopped instantly.”

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Watch This Space: Mahia Rocket Lab Launch Site Officially Opened

Economic Development Minster Steven Joyce today opened New Zealand’s first orbital launch site, Rocket Lab Launch Complex 1, on the Mahia Peninsula on the North Island’s east coast. More>>

Earlier:

Marketing Rocks!
Ig Nobel Award Winners Assess The Personality Of Rocks

A Massey University marketing lecturer has received the 2016 Ig Nobel Prize for economics for a research project that asked university students to describe the “brand personalities” of three rocks. More>>

ALSO:

Nurofen Promotion: Reckitt Benckiser To Plead Guilty To Misleading Ads

Reckitt Benckiser (New Zealand) intends to plead guilty to charges of misleading consumers over the way it promoted a range of Nurofen products, the Commerce Commission says. More>>

ALSO:

Half A Billion Accounts, Including Xtra: Yahoo Confirms Huge Data Breach

The account information may have included names, email addresses, telephone numbers, dates of birth, hashed passwords (the vast majority with bcrypt) and, in some cases, encrypted or unencrypted security questions and answers. More>>

ALSO:

Rural Branches: Westpac To Close 19 Branches, ANZ Looks At 7

Westpac confirms it will close nineteen branches across the country; ANZ closes its Ngaruawahia branch and is consulting on plans to close six more branches; The bank workers union says many of its members are nervous about their futures and asking ... More>>

Interest Rates: RBNZ's Wheeler Keeps OCR At 2%

Reserve Bank governor Graeme Wheeler kept the official cash rate at 2 percent and said more easing will be needed to get inflation back within the target band. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Sci-Tech
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news