Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search

 

LSN Responds To Peter Wills Report

LSN Media Release: September 24, 2003

Despite some serious errors in his interpretation of the recommendations of the Royal Commission on GM, and a cherry picking approach to the weight of scientific evidence, Auckland scientist Peter Wills argues strongly for case-by-case assessment and conditional releases of GM crops.

Life Sciences Network Chairman, Dr William Rolleston, says, “If you look at the huge amount of scientific research reported since the Royal Commission you will find examples of incidents which bear further examination. Some will warrant new responses while others will be of no consequence. Dr Wills has obviously spent many hours getting his list together.

“What his incomplete study fails to take into account is the huge amount of successful use of GM technology in the same period.

“The fact that unexpected things happen is not surprising; that is why the Royal Commission recommended proceeding carefully. It is also why the Government accepted the Royal Commission’s recommendation for a new category of release with conditions. It is anticipated the conditions to be imposed by ERMA will mitigate against the reoccurrence of unexpected and untoward events.

“The results Peter Wills has quoted all show that New Zealand is right to take a cautious approach – they do not argue for an extension to the moratorium.

“Dr Wills approach is rather like taking your car into the garage to fix some defects and the Government then ordering all cars off the road.

“The threshold of precaution, rather than being lower, is now higher as a result of the Government’s proposed changes based on the Royal Commission’s recommendations. We welcome Dr Wills endorsement of the outcome of the Royal Commission,” concluded Dr Rolleston.

From the LSN news team

Francis Wevers - Executive Director
Christine Ross - Communications Assistant, Wellington

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

BusinessDesk: Body massages and Uber are in, DVDs are out, says Stats NZ

Statistics New Zealand has rejigged the consumers price index basket in its latest three-year review, adding body massages, Airbnb and Uber and removing DVD and Blu-Ray players…More>>

ALSO:


StuffMe: Commerce Commission Welcomes Dismissal Of Merger Appeal

In a summary of their judgment released today, Justice Dobson and lay member Professor Martin Richardson dismissed the appellants’ process criticisms and found the Commission was entitled to place significant weight on the prospect of reduced quality of the products produced by the merged entity. More>>

ALSO:

Digital Futures: New Chief Technology Officer Role Created

Communications Minister Clare Curran has called for expressions of interest for the new role of Chief Technology Officer position to help drive a forward-looking digital agenda for New Zealand. More>>

Dry: Beef + Lamb Launches Drought Resources

The resources include a fact sheet outlining strategies to manage and mitigate the effects of drought, coping with stress on the farm and advice on feed requirements and animal welfare during the dry period. More>>

ALSO:

InternetNZ: Net Neutrality Failure In US "Will Hurt All Users"

InternetNZ Chief Executive Jordan Carter has condemned the decision by the United States communications regulator to undo 2015 open Internet rules, warning that all Internet users will end up worse off as a result. More>>

ALSO: