Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search

 


Greenpeace claims about ice shelf "ignore reality"

The New Zealand
Climate Science Coalition

12 April 2009 FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Greenpeace claims about Antarctic ice shelf ‘ignore scientific reality, yet again’

“Greenpeace has yet again ignored scientific reality in the recent misleading claims by its political advisor Geoff Keey about the threatened collapse of the Wilkins Ice Shelf on the Antarctic Peninsula,” says Terry Dunleavy of the New Zealand Climate Science Coalition.

“Even while climate campaigners such as Greenpeace, Al Gore and David Suzuki become increasingly shrill in their demands for action on the part of Governments towards the impossible goal of ‘stopping climate change’, the science that supposedly supports such actions is falling apart,” said Mr Dunleavy. “Greenpeace’s citation of the threatened collapse of the Wilkins Ice Shelf on the Antarctic Peninsula is a case in point. There is little evidence that such an event is abnormal or unnatural when seen in a significant time perspective and there is even less evidence that human greenhouse gas emissions have anything whatsoever to do with events in the Antarctic.”

Leading Canadian climatologist Dr Tim Ball agrees. “Relating the ice shelf deterioration to human activities is an illogical, unsubstantiated, public relations link typical of Greenpeace. As they are always doing, they are taking natural events and presenting them as unnatural.

“Keey’s concerns about the speed with which change is occurring in some parts of the Antarctic speaks to the false premise underlying the mistaken view called uniformitarianism - the idea that natural change is gradual over long period of time. In reality, climate change occurs all the time and is often quite rapid, the sudden cooling and then equally sudden warming during the Younger Dryas period ten millennia ago is a case in point. In the space of only about a decade, the Earth cooled as much as five degrees Celsius (perhaps more in some locations such as Greenland), stayed that way for about a millennium and then warmed equally quickly. That warming was about 100 times faster than the modest temperature rise that many believe occurred during the 20th century. Younger Dryas cooling and warming was, of course, entirely natural, occurring before civilization even started, but ignorance of such events allows Greenpeace, Gore and others to claim that sudden climate change today is unnatural. It is not”, said Dr Ball.

Referencing a paper in the scientific journal Nature last month, New Zealand Climate Science Coalition member Dr Willem De Lange, of the Earth Sciences faculty at Waikato University, explains that, in the vicinity of the Wilkins Ice Shelf that has so concerned Greenpeace, “there was a rapid rise in air temperature 40-50 years ago [but] it has been fairly stable since then.

“There are many factors involved in the destabilization of an ice shelf,” said Dr De Lange. “Warmer ocean waters circulating underneath (moving water melts ice faster than warm air), tidal rises and falls, and wave action all contribute to the fracture and eventually breakup of the ice. Now that the ice shelf is breaking up, it will be possible to sample the underlying sediments and determine the history of the shelf. We do not know if the shelf has undergone cycles of expansion and contraction during the last 10,000 years or has been shrinking since the last glacial period. One thing we do know however is that the break up of this shelf is not solely a consequence of current, or even recent weather changes. It is the consequence of changes over long periods, perhaps 1,000-10,000 years in this case, although we can't tell for certain until the necessary data are collected.

“And an event like the Wilkins Ice Shelf break-up does not provide any evidence as to the causes of the weather conditions that are occurring. Data for similar areas around the West Antarctic Peninsula indicate that changes in glacier and ice shelf mass balances correlate very well with indicators of the activity of the sun, but do not correlate at all with levels of greenhouse gases,” concludes Dr De Lange.

Greenpeace’s claims were apparently based on statements by British Antarctic Survey Glaciologist Dr David Vaughan. Dr Ball says that statements by Dr. Vaughan about the long time periods taken for ice shelves to build up and the rapid change occurring now were “clearly exploitive because he should know that tabular icebergs break off constantly. Ice close to shore may have indeed been there ‘for 10,000 years’, as Vaughan claims, but it is not the same ice since it is constantly expanding, the outer portions breaking off and massive ice masses then often floating well up into subtropical latitudes, as happened in November 2006 when icebergs drifted as far north as Canterbury, New Zealand. And, of course, the Wilkins break-up will have negligible direct impact on sea level because the ice is already floating in the ocean.

“Events such as we are seeing in Wilkins Sound today are anything but new. There is one report of a huge drifting ‘ice island’, 160 km long and 65 km wide - only slightly smaller than the complete Wilkins Ice Shelf - that was circumnavigated in 1840 by a ship sailing to Australia. Log books of sea captains are replete with records of a similar nature over past centuries as well,” said Dr. Ball

Dr Ball says the motive that drives some scientists to make sensationalist claims about events such as the Wilkins Ice Shelf break-up is research funding. “Many of these types of statements originate from those whose research is dependent on continued high levels of government funding”, says Dr Ball. “Without constantly priming the political pump with a series of excited forecasts about future climate crises, problems that their research is critical to understanding of course, scientists fear much of the funding for their work will simply dry up. Such obvious vested interests should make media and governments strongly suspicions of such forecasts of climate doom.”

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

Half Empty: Fonterra's 2017 Opening Forecast Below Expectations

Fonterra Cooperative Group raised its forecast farmgate milk payout for next season by less than expected as the world's largest dairy exporter predicts lower prices will crimp production and supply will pick up. The New Zealand dollar fell. More>>

ALSO:

Pest Control: Mouse Blitz Team Leaves For Antipodes

The Million Dollar Mouse project to rid Antipodes Island of mice is underway with the departure of a rodent eradication team to the remote nature reserve and World Heritage Area. More>>

Gongs Got: Canon Media Awards & NZ Radio Awards Happen

Radio NZ: RNZ website The Wireless, which is co-funded by NZ On Air, was named best website, while Toby Manhire and Toby Morris won the best opinion general writing section for their weekly column on rnz.co.nz and Tess McClure won the best junior feature writer section. More>>

ALSO:

Pre-Budget: Debt Focus Risks Losing Opportunity To Stoke Economy

The Treasury is likely to upgrade its forecasts for economic growth in Budget 2016 next week but Finance Minister Bill English has already signalled that more of his focus is on debt repayment than on fiscal stimulus or tax cuts... More>>

ALSO:

Fulton Hogan's Heroes: Managing Director Nick Miller Resigns

Fulton Hogan managing director Nick Miller will leave the privately owned construction company after seven years in charge. The Dunedin-based company has kicked off a search for a replacement, and Miller will stay on at the helm until March next year, or until a successor has been appointed and a transition period completed. More>>

ALSO:

Gordon Campbell: On Electricity, Executions, And Bob Dylan

The Electricity Authority has unveiled the final version of its pricing plan for electricity transmission. This will change the way transmission prices (which comprise about 10% of the average power bill) are computed, and will add hundreds of dollars a year to power bills for many ordinary consumers. More>>

ALSO:

Half Empty: Fonterra NZ, Australia Milk Collection Drops In Season

Fonterra Cooperative Group says milk collection is down in New Zealand and Australia, its two largest markets, in the first 11 months of the season during a period of weak dairy prices. More>>

ALSO:

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Sci-Tech
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news