Scoop has an Ethical Paywall
Fonterra's false alarm - what are Clostridium sporogenes?
Fonterra's false alarm - what are Clostridium sporogenes? Experts respond
28 August 2013
The Ministry
for Primary Industries has completed testing on Fonterra's
whey protein concentrate and found no trace of the
potentially deadly Clostridium botulinum, but Clostridium
sporogenes which at worst could be responsible for food
spoilage, but pose no risk to human health.
MPI will soon release a full diagnostics report.
MPI's acting director-general Scott Gallacher said: "a failure of hygiene during processing remains a concern for customers incorporating whey protein concentrate into their products. However, the concern primarily relates to quality and the potential for spoilage when used in foods that support growth of Clostridium sporogenes from spores".
Experts respond:
Dr Siouxsie Wiles, a microbiologist and infectious disease specialist at the University of Auckland told the SMC.
"C. sporogenes is the name given to isolates of C.botulinum which do not produce toxin. In essence, they are considered virtually identical except for the presence of the genes for botulinum toxin.
"There are different ways of of identifying contaminating organisms, the cheapest of which is to isolate the microbe by growing on selective agar and then performing biochemical tests to determine species. Species can also be identified genetically by looking for particular DNA sequences - like a barcode. On these kinds of tests, C. botulinum & C. sporogenes would be identical.
"Next comes the test to determine if the strains have the capacity to produce toxins - again this can be done by looking for the presence of the specific genes. If positive for toxin genes, the strains are tested to see if they actually produce toxin and if that toxin is active using a mouse bioassay. The mouse bioassay could take some weeks to carry out, but the genetic identification of the presence or absence of the toxin genes can be done in hours to days.
"It sounds to me like Fonterra alerted their customers to the presence of C. botulinum in their product before confirming whether the contaminating strain could produce toxin and was therefore really C. botulinum. From a public relations point of view this was the right decision as the backlash against Fonterra would have been fierce if they had waited for confirmation of toxin production, had it proven to be positive.
"The information Fonterra should have released initially was how much contamination they had actually identified. This would have allowed experts in the field to have made an educated guess as to the likelihood of any children becoming ill from consuming the contaminated product in the event it had contained a toxin-producing strain. This was information worried parents were desperate for.
"Fonterra have a lot to learn about how they could have handled the situation better. Just publicising the fact they didn't know if the strain they had identified had the ability to produce toxin or not, rather than staying silent, would have shown they were being proactive in ensuring the safety of their product.
As an aside, it looks like
researchers are trying to use C. sporogenes to help
kill tumours. I've just read something from a couple of
years ago where scientists in Europe have engineered the bug
with an enzyme that activates a drug to kill cancers.
Apparently they may be moving into clinical trials. Just
shows how context is everything when thinking of whether
bacteria are friend or
foe!".
ends
Science Media Centre NZ
Our aim is to promote accurate, evidence-based reporting on science and technology by helping the media work more closely with the scientific community.
The Science Media Centre is New Zealand's only trusted, independent source of information for the media on all issues related to science. Thousands of news stories providing context from and quoting New Zealand researchers have been published as a direct result of our work.
Fix & Fogg: NASA Hand-picks Kiwi Nut Butter Brand To Travel To Space In NZ First
Citizens of the Sea: Sailors To Revolutionise Our Understanding Of Pacific Biodiversity
Netsafe: Making A Splash With Online Safety: Netsafe Launches New Flagship Programme For Kids
NZGBC: Flood Resilience PhD Student Widi Auliagisni Named Future Thinker Of The Year 2024
Business Canterbury: European Free Trade Agreement A Game-changer For Canterbury
Business Canterbury: Urges Council To Cut Costs, Not Ambition For City
