Video | Business Headlines | Internet | Science | Scientific Ethics | Technology | Search

 

Sporting Hunters Group Says Deer Repellent is a “Hoax”

Sporting Hunters Group Says Deer Repellent is a “Hoax”


Deer repellent used with 1080 poison to supposedly deter deer from eating the toxic baits is a hoax according to Laurie Collins of the Sporting Hunters’ Outdoor Trust.

West Coaster Laurie Collins of Hector who has had a lifelong association with wild animals and mountains, said the repellent was used by the Department of Conservation to allay hunters’ fears of deer being killed by 1080.

“Deer repellent is a blood product so why would one herbivore i.e. deer as vegetarian be repelled while another herbivore (a possum), is not, according to DOC’s illogic?”

Laurie Collins who began work as a Forest Service cadet in the late 1950s with the first trials of 1080, said the simple fact was deer repellent did not work. The only reason for DOC’s use of it was to “con” gullible deerstalkers and groups who feared deer might be wiped out. Reports indicated that in the Kahurangi National Park 1080 drop hunting groups had naively paid half the cost of using deer repellent.

There was doubt it was legal to spread a blood product haphazardly around as DOC did with 1080 baits laced with deer “repellent.”

Laurie Collins said sporting hunters were predominantly concerned about the nature of 1080 as an “ecosystem poison”. First developed in the 1920s as an insecticide, 1080 was found to kill any living organism that came in contact with it.

“It was then adopted by bureaucrats as an animal poison. They use it to kill animals while turning a blind eye to the enormous ecological damage it does to birds, bees, invertebrates and other life.”

Laurie Collins said the total experience of hunting was not just about deer but being in the environment of mountains and forests and seeing bird life.

“We don’t want silent forests. Who wants to be in a morgue?” he said.

Laurie Collins had experienced areas where 1080 had been used and with an aftermath of a deathly silence which could remain for years until life gradually recovered. Claims of abundant bird life after 1080 lacked keen observation.

“The only birds that survive are the nectar eaters like tui and bellbirds. Predators like the falcon and morepork and insectivorous birds like robins, tomtits and fantails suffer mortality or with insects wiped, numbers are limited by the heavily reduced food supply.”

Laurie Collins said it was “hypocritical and unjust” that a citizen could be fined for killing one native bird, but the Minister of Conservation and DOC could knowingly kill thousands of birds with their 1080 programme.

He described Minister Nick Smith’s “Battle for the Birds” and 1080 drops based on a super-seeding year of beech trees and an imagined rat population explosion as “demented and destructive”. The campaign aimed at reducing rats was “ill-conceived and ignorant.”

“Anyone with half a brain would know beech trees have seeded for millions of years. The kiore rat has been here 800 years and the ship rat 150 years. Why suddenly is one year - 2014 - so special out of 800 years?”

Laurie Collins said the rise of the “Ban1080” political party showed the deep concern about 1080 of people acquainted with the back country. NZ First and United Future were other political parties with equally deep concerns reflected in policies against aerial 1080 drops.

“For an increasing number of Kiwis it’s an election issue,” he said.

ends


© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
Business Headlines | Sci-Tech Headlines

 

NZ's Space Programme: Rocket Lab Makes It To Space (But Not Orbit)

Electron lifted-off at 16:20 NZST from Rocket Lab Launch Complex 1 on the Mahia Peninsula in New Zealand. It was the first orbital-class rocket launched from from a private launch site in the world. More>>

ALSO:

Earlier:

Budget: Irrigate (Good Times, Come On!)

Additional grant funding of $26.7 million over the next three years plus a capital boost of $63 million towards irrigation investments in Budget 2017 will deliver economic and environmental benefits through better use of water... More>>

ALSO:

Silver Fern Farms: Proposal To Close Fairton Sheepmeat Plant

Silver Fern Farms has advised its people of the proposal to permanently close the site, and has discussed potential transfer options to its other sites in the region as part of the consultation process...
More>>

ALSO:

MPI: Myrtle Rust Appears In Taranaki

The nursery in Waitara (just north of New Plymouth) reported suspected myrtle rust symptoms on young plants to the Ministry’s 0800 number yesterday (Tuesday). More>>

ALSO: