Cablegate: Vietnam's Ambitious Nuclear Power Plans

DE RUEHHI #1405/01 3590724
R 240724Z DEC 08




E.O. 12958: N/A

Ref: A. HANOI 1352 B. HANOI 1252 C. HANOI 1267 D. HANOI 1048 E.
HANOI 966 F. HANOI 898 G. HANOI 610 H. 07 HANOI 1867

HANOI 00001405 001.2 OF 006


1. (SBU) Summary: Vietnam has ambitious plans to develop its
civilian nuclear power sector. In the face of rapidly expanding
demand for power and few other domestic sources of energy, the
Government of Vietnam (GVN) wants to move quickly to construct the
nation's first nuclear power plants. Acknowledging its limited
capacity to build, operate, and regulate this industry, Vietnam will
rely upon foreign partners for substantial assistance. The United
States has developed close cooperation with the GVN to support
safety and security infrastructure, which will facilitate access to
the market for U.S. companies. However, competition will be stiff
as many other nuclear suppliers are targeting Vietnam. End

2. (U) This cable responds to State 12743 and follows its format.

Vietnamese Plans for the Development
of Nuclear Power

3. (SBU) Vietnam currently does not have any nuclear power
facilities. However, the country has an ambitious plan for the
commercial nuclear sector. In 2006, the Prime Minister approved a
strategy for the development of the nuclear power for civilian
purposes (power and other applications) through 2020. Subsequently,
in July 2007, the GVN adopted a "Master Plan for Implementation of
the Long-term Strategy." Vietnam's National Assembly passed a
comprehensive Atomic Energy Law on June 3, 2008. Pursuant to the
master plan approved by the Prime Minister, Vietnam intends to
produce 10,000 megawatts from nuclear energy by 2030. Per the
Vietnam Agency for Radiation and Nuclear Safety (VARANS, formerly
VARANSAC), Vietnam hopes to generate 3.3 percent of its energy from
nuclear power by 2020 and 4.7 percent by 2025 (Note: Vietnam
Electricity (EVN), the state-owned electricity provider provides
somewhat more conservative estimates -- 1 percent of Vietnam's
energy from nuclear power by 2020 and 6 percent by 2030).

4. (SBU) In several meetings with the Embassy, USG delegations, and
other Embassy contacts, GVN officials have set forth proposed
timelines for the development of nuclear power. However, given the
many players within the GVN, the difficult and time consuming
process to receive intra-GVN policy consensus, and the GVN's
still-evolving understanding of the practical requirements of
developing the nuclear power sector, the timeline described below
needs to be seen as highly preliminary and likely to change. Though
GVN officials initially informed USG delegations of their intention
to construct a 2,000 MW nuclear power plant (NPP) near the coast at
Phuoc Dinh (in rural, southern Ninh Thuan province), those officials
subsequently have told Embassy contacts that the GVN now envisions a
4,000 MW NPP consisting of twin double 1,000 MW reactor units in
Ninh Thuan province, which would be integrated by an exclusive line
into a 500 kv grid, which would then be integrated into the national
grid (ref F). (Note: per VARANS, exact power production figures
could vary slightly depending upon negotiations between the
state-owned national electricity company, EVN and contractors). The
Phuoc Dinh site and the proposed site in Vinh Hai (also in Ninh
Thuan province) for the second NPP are in rural areas far from
population centers.

5. (SBU) EVN recently finalized a Pre-feasibility Report, which it
will soon submit to the Prime Minister for approval. Following the
Prime Minister's okay, EVN will present the study to the National
Assembly in May 2009 for the final go ahead. The GVN expects the
completion of a feasibility study, with technology preference, in
2009/10 and the submission(s) of the NPP license application(s) by
2011, followed by the development of the technology technical
description. In 2012-2013, the GVN would receive bids for
engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) contract(s) with
bid and vendor selection and nuclear design and construction

HANOI 00001405 002.2 OF 006

approvals in 2013-14. Construction would begin around 2015, and the
first of the possible four reactors would come online around 2020,
with additional reactors entering service through 2022. MOST
officials commented that since Vietnam lacked the experience
necessary for the development of a nuclear power program, it would
rely heavily on nuclear cooperation with advanced nuclear energy

Existing or Planned Nuclear Power Related
Facilities, Such as Uranium Mining

6. (SBU) Vietnam does not have any existing nuclear power related
facilities, though it continues to operate a nuclear research
reactor in Dalat built by the United States for the Republic of
Vietnam in the 1960s and modified by the Soviet Union in the 1970s.
Currently, the United States is negotiating to finalize conversion
of the facility from dependence on highly enriched uranium (HEU) to
low enriched uranium (LEU). In 2007, the United States, Russia, and
Vietnam completed the return of fresh HEU to Russia. We hope to
return spent HEU to Russia in 2010.

7. (SBU) In the long-term, Vietnam is contemplating the creation of
certain nuclear support sectors, but has not developed any concrete
plans. EVN stated that Vietnam had some nuclear mining and milling
capability, though it did not have the capacity to enrich uranium.
According to VAEC, Vietnam only has low-content uranium ores.
Though VAEC has been working on plans to mine these ores for many
years, such plans are not close to finalization.

Underlying Motivations for
Development of Nuclear Power

8. (SBU) The GVN has focused on the development of nuclear power to
resolve anticipated power shortages and to deepen Vietnam's energy
security. Vietnamese energy sector experts increasingly point to
nuclear energy to supplement Vietnam's limited domestic energy
generation capacity (ref F). The GVN's Energy Master Plan VI,
released in July 2007, predicts that demand for electricity will
grow 20 percent annually through 2015, while the Ministry of
Industry and Trade (MOIT) now predicts growth of 17 percent per
year, reflecting the expected impacts of the global economic
downturn. Vietnam will soon run out of new sources of hydropower
and by 2011 expects to begin importing coal (ref H). Vietnam also
plans to import electricity from planned Lao hydro-electric
facilities. Substantial offshore natural gas reserves may be blocked
by political maneuvering over control of the South China Sea.
Several interlocutors explained that a recent review of energy
production and demand figures led the GVN to upgrade the importance
of nuclear in Vietnam's planned energy mix. Though not a
significant factor in Vietnam's decision-making process, the lack of
greenhouse gas emissions from nuclear power makes it a more
attractive alternative to the continued expansion of domestic
coal-fired power.

Anticipated GVN Role
in the Civil Nuclear Sector Financing

9. (SBU) We do not believe that the GVN has made substantial headway
in determining how to finance the development of the nuclear sector.
In meetings with the State Department Special Envoy for
Nonproliferation, Ambassador Jackie Wolcott (ref D), Vietnamese
officials acknowledged that they had not yet seriously considered
this challenge and had assumed that financing could be secured via
loans from the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, or the
Asian Development Bank, or via export credits. MOIT Vice Minister
Do Huu Hao told a DOE delegation in August that while
State-controlled EVN would serve at the sole investor in the first
two nuclear reactors, Vietnam might open up subsequent facilities to
foreign investment, possibly up to 100 percent (ref F). EVN, in
turn, acknowledged possible financing problems and anticipated
requesting construction bidders to identify sources of funding. EVN

HANOI 00001405 003.2 OF 006

officials emphasized that all financing options remain on the table
though they also mentioned the possibility of a Build, Operate and
Transfer (BOT) arrangement. EVN noted that it could not rely on
Official Development Assistance for the reactors, though it might be
able to do so for other components.

Names and Titles of Key Nuclear Decision makers
--------------------------------------------- --

10. (SBU) Given the high risk and reward calculus for the
development of a civilian nuclear power sector, all nuclear
agreements/projects must be approved by the Prime Minister. Prime
Minister Nguyen Tan Dung played an active role in the decision to
site the first nuclear power reactors in Ninh Tuan province.
Additionally, large projects such as nuclear power plants, which are
related to energy security, must also receive final approval from
the National Assembly. Within the GVN, Deputy Prime Minister Hoang
Trung Hai has responsibility for all energy issues. (Note: In
Vietnam's consensus-driven decision making process, Hai must
coordinate input from several ministries and does not have the power
to force solutions or timetables on other participants). Hai met
with DOE and USTDA to discuss nuclear power and visited a nuclear
power plant during his November 2008 visit to the United States.

11. (SBU) The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT) has
responsibility for developing the Vietnamese power sector. Within
MOIT, Vice Minister Do Huu Hao supervises nuclear power issues. On
a practical level, the MOIT Department of Energy, headed by Ta Van
Huong, focuses on nuclear energy. State-owned EVN will develop
Vietnam's first nuclear power plants. Phan Minh Tuan, Head of the
Nuclear Power and Renewable Energy Projects Pre-investment Board,
supervises EVN's nuclear strategy discussions.

12. (SBU) VAEC and VARANS, together with their parent Ministry,
MOST, play key roles in developing the necessary infrastructure for
the planned civilian nuclear power sector. MOST exercises oversight
of Vietnam's nuclear program and serves as the designated regulator.
MOST Minister Hoang Van Phong does not focus on nuclear energy.
Vice Minister Le Dinh Tien's portfolio contains nuclear energy
(Note: Tien will be in Washington from January 2 to 7 and would like
to meet with DOE and State, ref A). MOST Vice-Minister Tran Quoc
Thanh covers general U.S.-Vietnam science and technology cooperation
and also plays a role in MOST nuclear policy considerations. The
VAEC, led by Chairman Vuong Huu Tan and with a staff of 600, an
administrative and scientific agency under MOST, advises MOST on
nuclear policy (and continues to support EVN in the development of
the pre-feasibility study for the first planned nuclear reactors)
and operates the Dalat nuclear research reactor. Dr. Ngo Dang Nhan,
serves at the director of VARANS, Vietnam's designated nuclear
regulatory body.

GVN Nuclear Regulatory Authority

13. (SBU) The Vietnamese nuclear regulatory agency, VARANS, was
established in 2003 under MOST and assists the MOST Minister in the
state management of radiation and nuclear safety and control.
VARANS has grown rapidly, from less than 10 employees in 2004 to
over 50 in 2008. In addition to its recent MOU with the U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission, VARANS has signed a technical
cooperation MOU with the Korean nuclear regulatory authority and
also has close ties with Australian nuclear regulators. Its main
roles include developing policies, programs, legal documents,
regulations and standards on radiation and nuclear safety,
licensing, regulatory inspections, environmental monitoring,
emergency response, and safety assessment. VARANS played a key role
in the drafting of Vietnam's new Atomic Energy Law. At the same
time, however, nuclear power's high profile and importance to energy
security and economic development ensure that the Prime Minister's
office will track, and perhaps direct, the progress of nuclear
development. In fact, despite VARANS's rapid growth and human
resource and training upgrades, EVN noted its belief that a special
task force headed by a deputy Prime Minister would supervise
preparation for the nuclear sector, including the creation of the

HANOI 00001405 004.2 OF 006

safety and security infrastructure.

Vietnamese Nuclear Liability Provisions

14. (SBU) Vietnam has not yet joined the Convention on Supplementary
Compensation for Nuclear Damage (CSC) and does not have a separate
law on domestic nuclear liability. According to VARANS, Vietnam is
not a party to any international liability regime and is not yet
considering joining any. The new Law on Atomic Energy (AEL), passed
by the National Assembly in June 2008 generally covers liability
issues. VARANS is drafting decrees to guide implementation of the
law which will be submitted to the GVN in early 2009. In
particular, the AEL stipulates that radiation damage compensation
levels shall comply with Vietnam's Civil Law and that nuclear damage
compensation levels shall be determined as agreed between concerned
parties. Where the parties cannot come to an agreement,
compensation levels for humans shall be determined in accordance
with Civil Law, while compensation level for environment shall be
specified in accordance with Vietnam's Environmental Protection Law.
Total compensation for damage resulted from each nuclear incident
shall not exceed 150 million Special Drawing Rights as determined by
the International Monetary Fund.

Nuclear-related Manufacturing Base

15. (U) Vietnam's manufacturing base is not involved in
nuclear-related products or services and has no plans to do so in
the short to medium term. The GVN would like to develop some of
these sectors over the next several decades, but acknowledges it
will take many years to develop the technical and human capacity to
do so.

Nuclear Workforce

16. (SBU) Currently, the GVN does not have a nuclear-trained
workforce, nor does it have a significant engineering, technician
and construction base that could be readily converted into a nuclear
workforce. Both EVN and GVN nuclear research and regulatory
authorities contain engineers who received nuclear training in the
Soviet Union and former Eastern Bloc. However, this relatively
small cadre has had limited exposure to modern nuclear technologies
and likely will have retired prior to the development of Vietnam's
civilian nuclear power sector. EVN acknowledges its limited human
resources capacity and anticipates contracting with foreign
technicians to operate Vietnam's first nuclear plants while training
EVN staff - a process which EVN believes will take 15-30 years. EVN
has also sent engineers for training to South Korea, France and

17. (SBU) Domestically, the Ministry of Education and Training
(MOET) is developing an HR training and development plan for the
nuclear sector, which it plans to finalize for intra-GVN review in
the next few months. The plan calls for Vietnam to send several
core experts to countries with developed nuclear power sector for
training and, in the long-term, to develop domestic capacity for
such training. MOET also is formulating a project to develop
nuclear power-related curricula in several universities by sometime
in 2009. MOST is considering a proposal to establish a center to
specialize in nuclear training, though the initiative remains rather
unclearly defined. VARANS has sought training for its personnel
from the U.S. DOE and NRC, along with other partners, such as

Nuclear-related Tenders

18. (SBU) Once the National Assembly approves the VAEC/EVN
pre-feasibility study for the initial nuclear reactor construction,
EVN will coordinate the tender process to draft a full feasibility
study, which is expected to be tendered right after the
pre-feasibility study has been approved by the National Assembly -

HANOI 00001405 005.2 OF 006

no earlier than the third quarter of 2009. Subsequently, according
to EVN, it will consider all options for nuclear vendors and
financing and the GVN would decide upon what type of contractor and
technology that it would use. (Note: VARANS stated that the first
plant would rely upon light water technology). By March or April
2010, EVN would tender the engineering, procurement, and
construction (EPC) contract, with the bid listed in the Vietnam
Economic Times and on the Ministry of Planning and Investment
website. GVN contacts have reported interest from
Westinghouse-Toshiba and General Electric-Hitachi (ref G).

Opportunities for U.S. Industry

19. (SBU) As Vietnam develops civilian nuclear power, U.S. industry
will have opportunities to participate in all facets of the nuclear
sector. Initially, U.S. firms will be able to bid on feasibility
and consulting services. Over time, we expect to see opportunities
for plant construction management, reactor sales, fuel cycle service
provisions, plant operations, management, and logistics.

Primary Companies (Domestic and Foreign)
Involved in Civil Nuclear Sector

20. (U) The GVN has designated state-owned EVN as the lead for the
development of Vietnam's first NPP. Though Vietnam has few
companies interested in other aspects of the nuclear sector, many
foreign companies and governments have expressed interest in
participation, though none have yet entered the market.

Foreign Competitors

21. (U) Several other nuclear suppliers have shown interest in
engaging with Vietnam. According to VAEC, Vietnam has signed five
cooperation agreements on atomic energy use for peaceful purposes
with Argentina, India, South Korea, China and Russia. Vietnam has
also signed an MOU on nuclear power cooperation with France. Japan,
China, South Korea, Russia and France have indicated interest in
commercial nuclear opportunities with French and Russian official
visits to Vietnam in 2008 promoting their nuclear sectors and
scheduled visits to those countries from senior MOIT officials.
France, Russia, China, South Korea and Japan participated in a May
2008 nuclear power exhibition sponsored by VAEC and EVN (Note:
France, Japan and South Korea had the largest commercial
delegations. No U.S.-affiliated companies attended).

22. (U) Besides the United States, France and Japan have developed
the most extensive ties to GVN nuclear developers and regulators.
French-Vietnamese nuclear cooperation dates to the 1990s and builds
from French support for the Vietnamese electricity industry
(including the recent construction of the Phu My 2-2 BOT Gas
Electric Plant). At the May 2008 VAEC/EVN exhibition, French
exhibitors noted that the Government of France had requested the
French Committee on Atomic Energy (CEA) to create the French
International Nuclear Agency to assist nations, such as Vietnam,
hoping to build their first nuclear power plant. France has also
assisted Vietnam through assessments of training needs, training,
guidance in drafting legal documents in the nuclear sector,
organizing technical seminars and public education. In mid-2008,
EVN and Electricite de France (EDF) held a public seminar on nuclear
power at the site of the proposed first Vietnamese NPPs in Ninh
Thuan province.

23. (U) Japan and Vietnam have cooperated on atomic energy since
1990, with a focus on the nuclear power sector beginning in 1997.
Since 2000, several high-ranking GVN delegations have visited
Japanese nuclear power plants and attended nuclear power seminars.
From 2002-2004, Japan assisted Vietnam to develop the
pre-feasibility study for the first nuclear power plants. Since
2005, Japan has trained EVN nuclear power technical officers. In
April 2006, the two countries began a cooperation program for the
peaceful use of atomic energy and nuclear power plant safety.

HANOI 00001405 006.2 OF 006

Political Considerations

24. (SBU) If past history is a guide, Vietnam's decisions on nuclear
technology and suppliers will be influenced as much by political
considerations as by commercial concerns. We expect Vietnam to try
to balance competing interests and, if possible, to split the
difference. Earlier this year, Vietnam Airlines split a major
long-range aircraft order between Boeing and Airbus, despite advice
that its fleet only needed one such model. VARANS Chairman Ngo Dang
Nhan stated his desire for one common design for the first several
units to promote better nuclear safety, but acknowledged that
political calculations would impact design decisions. More likely,
Vietnam will consider choosing different designs for its first
nuclear reactors, allowing companies from more than one key ally to
participate in the process. Vietnam has relied upon several
partners to support the development of its nuclear power sector,
particularly the United States, but also France and Japan, and will
do what it can to avoid alienating any of them. U.S. support,
evidenced by several existing MOUs and numerous visits to Vietnam by
U.S. technical experts, has well positioned the United States to
participate in the development of the Vietnamese nuclear sector.


© Scoop Media

World Headlines


Werewolf: Gordon Campbell On North Korea, Neo-Nazism, And Milo

With a bit of luck the planet won’t be devastated by nuclear war in the next few days. US President Donald Trump will have begun to fixate on some other way to gratify his self-esteem – maybe by invading Venezuela or starting a war with Iran. More>>

Victory Declared: New Stabilisation Funding From NZ As Mosul Is Retaken

New Zealand has congratulated the Iraqi government on the successful liberation of Mosul from ISIS after a long and hard-fought campaign. More>>

Gordon Campbell: On The Current US Moves Against North Korea

If Martians visited early last week, they’d probably be scratching their heads as to why North Korea was being treated as a potential trigger for global conflict... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The Lessons From Corbyn’s Campaign

Leaving partisan politics aside – and ignoring Jeremy Corbyn’s sensational election campaign for a moment – it has to be said that Britain is now really up shit creek... More>>


Another US Court: Fourth Circuit Rules Muslim Ban Discriminatory

ACLU: Step by step, point by point, the court laid out what has been clear from the start: The president promised to ban Muslims from the United States, and his executive orders are an attempt to do just that. More>>