World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search


US Enemy Combatants Detained Indefinitely: Ruling

Court Rules U.S. Enemy Combatants Can Be Detained Indefinitely

Says president "unquestionably" has right to detain U.S. citizen Jose Padilla

By Alexandra Abboud
Washington File Staff Writer

Washington -- A U.S. federal appeals court ruled September 9 that President Bush indefinitely may detain a U.S. citizen captured as part of the global War on Terror who is alleged to have a close association with al-Qaida.

“The exceedingly important question before us is whether the president of the United States possesses the authority to detain militarily a citizen of this country who is closely associated with al-Qaida," appeals court Judge J. Michael Luttig wrote. "We conclude that the president does possess such authority."

The court ruled in the case of Jose Padilla, a U.S. citizen who was designated an “enemy combatant” by President Bush in 2002 because of his alleged activities and association with the al-Qaida terrorist group. “Under the facts as presented here, Padilla unquestionably qualifies as an 'enemy combatant,' " Luttig wrote.

Bush administration officials maintain that enemy combatants may be held legally until hostilities end and that such combatants are not entitled to prisoner-of-war status with the protections afforded by the Geneva Conventions, which deal with the international laws of war.

“The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has reaffirmed the president's critical authority to detain enemy combatants who take up arms on behalf of al-Qaida and travel to the United States to kill innocent Americans,” said Attorney General Alberto Gonzales in a September 9 statement. “As the court noted today, the authority to detain enemy combatants like Jose Padilla plays an important role in protecting American citizens ….”

Padilla has been held in a U.S. Navy prison in South Carolina since 2002 without being charged with a crime. The ruling by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals reverses a February 2005 lower court ruling that said President Bush did not have the authority to hold Padilla as an enemy combatant. In that case, the judge ruled that unless charged with a crime, Padilla must be set free.

Padilla is one of only two U.S. citizens designated as enemy combatants. The other, Yaser Hamdi, was released by the U.S. Department of Justice in 2004. Padilla and Hamdi petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court in 2004.

The Supreme Court in that case -- which included the cases of both Hamdi, Padilla, and a Guántanamo detainee -- concluded that “a state of war is not a blank check for the president" and that enemy combatants should be granted a trial.

However, the Supreme Court’s findings did not apply to the Padilla case because his attorneys originally had filed for appeal in New York, instead of North Carolina, the state that the Supreme Court said had jurisdiction over the case, and the state where Padilla is being held. The most recent ruling is from the appeals courts in South Carolina and Padilla’s attorney has said that Padilla likely will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to hear his case.

© Scoop Media

World Headlines


Gordon Campbell: Is This Guy The World’s Most Dangerous Thirtysomething?

Saudi Arabia has long been regarded as a pillar of stability in the Middle East, and is the essential caterer to the West’s fossil fuel needs. It is also the country that gave us Osama Bin Laden, al Qaeda, and 15 of the 19 terrorists who carried out the 9/11 attacks... More>>


Non-Binding Postal Vote: Australia Says Yes To Same Sex Marriage

Binoy Kampmark: Out of 150 federal seats, 133 registered affirmative totals in returning their response to the question “Should the law be changed to allow same-sex couples to marry?”. More>>


Bonn Climate Change Conference: Protecting Health In Small Island States

The vision is that, by 2030, all Small Island Developing States will have health systems that are resilient to climate change and countries around the world will be reducing their carbon emissions both to protect the most vulnerable from climate risks and deliver large health benefits in carbon-emitting countries. More>>


Camp Shut Down: Refugees Must Be Rescued From Manus

On 31st October 2017, the detention centre on Manus Island in which the Australian Government has been holding more than 700 refugees was closed, leaving those living there in a desperate situation. More>>



Rohingya Muslims Massacred: Restrictions On Aid Put 1000s At Risk

Amnesty: The Myanmar authorities’ restrictions on international aid in Rakhine state is putting tens of thousands of lives at risk in a region where mainly Rohingya people are already suffering horrific abuses from a disproportionate military campaign. More>>