World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search


Turkey: Compensation Law to Internally Displaced

Turkey: Call for Urgent Review of Compensation Law Payments to Internally Displaced Families

Joint letter to the Deputy Prime Minister

February 22, 2005

Mr. Abdullah Gül
Deputy Prime Minister and State Minister for Human Rights
06573 Ankara

Dear Minister,

We have followed with urgent interest the implementation of the July 2004 Law on Compensation for Damage Arising from Terror and Combatting Terror (Law 5233 – “Compensation Law”). According to a Ministry of Interior press release in August 2005, 104,734 internally displaced persons had applied for compensation under the law before the deadline of 27 July 2005. The fairness of the assessments and the level of the settlements will be determining factors in whether or not the displaced families will be able to return in safety and dignity to their homes.

In recent months, provincial damage assessment commissions have begun to make their first rulings. We wish to draw attention to the inconsistency in the rulings; some of the rulings have been realistic and acceptable, while others seem patently inconsistent with the government’s avowed intention to eliminate “the difficulties faced by our citizens who were obliged to leave their villages.”

One group of decisions by Batman provincial damage assessment commission was that forty-one internally displaced families, who were displaced from 1992 to 2002 in Y village near Hasankeyf, should each be paid an average of 50,000 YTL (30,000 euros). This sum is hardly adequate to fully compensate a family for the destruction of its home and the deprivation of its livelihood for a decade or more, much less the profound trauma caused by the original displacements following the armed conflict. On the other hand, such a sum will substantially assist displaced families in returning to their homes in the southeast, or in integrating into cities to which they have fled. From this strictly practical point of view, the rulings of the Batman damage assessment commission may be deemed as the absolute minimum amount that could be considered adequate compensation.

By contrast, a decision of the Diyarbakır commission gave 101 families from village D near Kulp an average of 29,000 YTL (18,000 euros) each. In a group of villages near Kocaköy, the Diyarbakır commission gave 144 families an average of 18,000 YTL, with some families receiving as little as 5,000 YTL (3,000 euros). In Adıyaman, a family from village S received 17,000 YTL (10,700 euros) and in Elazığ a family from village A. received 16,000 YTL (10,000 euros). Such sums in no way meet the needs of a displaced family, typically impoverished by a decade in rented accommodations in the city, hoping to reconstruct their home, buy livestock or seed, and support themselves through two winters until they are able to establish an income stream. Such sums are also well below the average sums that the European Court of Human Rights has ordered the Turkish government to pay to families whose goods and houses it was responsible for destroying.

What is more, assessment commissions in Hakkari have rejected 243 internally displaced families’ applications on the grounds that villagers had been unable to document their forced displacement. For instance, the Hakkari assessment commission rejected dozens of applications from Akbulut village in that province on the grounds that the applicants had signed a paper ten years ago saying that they had quitted their village voluntarily. Given that many who were ultimately displaced from the southeast faced intimidation and threats of extreme violence before they fled, it is likely that any such statements were given under great duress.

Commissions must guard against fraudulent claims, but making unrealistic demands for documentation will only exclude genuine applicants. The true patterns of displacement can easily be established from official and non-governmental reports, from accounts given by village elders and muhtarlar, and the testimony of the displaced themselves. The assessment commissions should not attempt to deny displaced families the desperately needed compensation for which they clearly qualify by setting conditions that are impossible to meet, or do not take into account the circumstances surrounding most displacements.

The settlements in Batman province go one step toward meeting your government’s stated commitment to ensure the displaced can return in safety and dignity. The government must also ensure that returning villagers are safe from intimidation and attack by village guards; take reasonable measures to ensure that village sites are free of landmines; and provide essential infrastructure to returning communities (specifically, access to electricity, telephones, clean water, and schools).

We urge that you order an immediate and thorough review of the commissions’ work to ensure that all provinces consistently apply fair criteria in judging whether or not a particular family is entitled to receive a payment under the law, and consistently make payments that, although not full restitution, are at least adequate.


Holly Cartner
Executive Director
Europe and Central Asia division
Human Rights Watch

Kerim Yıldız
Executive Director
Kurdish Human Rights Project

Yusuf Alataş
Human Rights Association

© Scoop Media

World Headlines


At The UN: Paris Climate Agreement Moves Closer To Entry Into Force

The Paris Agreement on climate change moved closer toward entering into force in 2016 as 31 more countries joined the agreement today at a special event hosted by United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On The End Game In Spain (And Other World News)

The coverage of international news seems almost entirely dependent on a random selection of whatever some overseas news agency happens to be carrying overnight... Here are a few interesting international stories that have largely flown beneath the radar this past week. More>>

Amnesty/Human Rights Watch: Appalling Abuse, Neglect Of Refugees On Nauru

Refugees and asylum seekers on Nauru, most of whom have been held there for three years, routinely face neglect by health workers and other service providers who have been hired by the Australian government, as well as frequent unpunished assaults by local Nauruans. More>>


Other Australian Detention

Gordon Campbell: On The Censorship Havoc In South Africa’s State Broadcaster

Demands have included an order to staff that there should be no further negative news about the country’s President Jacob Zuma, and SABC camera operators responsible for choosing camera angles that have allegedly made the President ‘look shorter’ were to be retrained... More>>


Gordon Campbell: On A Bad Week For Malcolm Turnbull, And The Queen

Malcolm Turnbull’s immediate goal – mere survival – is still within his grasp... In every other respect though, this election has been a total disaster for the Liberals. More>>


Gordon Campbell: On Bidding Bye Bye To Boris

Boris Johnson’s exit from the contest for Conservative Party leadership supports the conspiracy theory that he never really expected the “Leave” option to win the referendum – and he has no intention now of picking up the poisoned chalice that managing the outcome will entail... More>>


Get More From Scoop

Search Scoop  
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news