World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search

 


New Forces Need New Rules - UN Working Group on Mercenaries

OPINION PIECE

New Forces Need New Rules

By Ms. Faiza Patel, UN Working Group on the use of mercenaries

As the U.S. winds down its nine-year military presence in Iraq, the world risks forgetting a critical lesson. The widespread use of private military and security contractors without proper controls was one of the war’s costliest mistakes. Contractors are likely to remain a feature of both war and peace, diversifying into markets ranging from guarding ships in the Indian Ocean to spying in East Africa. Private companies guard diplomats from around the world, a trend that will likely only accelerate with incidents like the tragic killing of the U.S. Ambassador to Libya. We must strengthen our legal systems to account for these new forces.

Experience with security contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan has shown that their personnel often lack discipline and can commit violent crimes. But the international community lacks the tools and political will to control them or bring them to book when they abuse human rights.

Five years ago, security guards from Blackwater shot and killed 17 civilians in Baghdad’s Nisoor Square, setting off a wave of international condemnation. A criminal prosecution is pending in American courts, stymied by the government’s failure to collect evidence properly. Serious crimes by other contractors, including killings and sex trafficking, have simply not been pursued. The US Justice Department, for example, has declined to prosecute nearly 80 percent of contractor abuse cases referred to it.

Private actions have fared badly too. The U.S. Army concluded that contractors were involved in torturing prisoners at Iraq’s Abu Ghraib prison, but not one has been held responsible. Courts dismiss these civil suits because they wrongly liken contractors to soldiers in battle or the government asserts that litigation would compromise national security. An important avenue for victims to find justice may close if the U.S. Supreme Court finds (in an upcoming case involving Royal Dutch Petroleum and Shell) that corporations cannot be held liable for gross human rights violations abroad.

The impact of these cases extends far beyond the individuals concerned.

Last year, when I went to Iraq as an independent expert member of the United Nations Working Group on Mercenaries, government officials and ordinary citizens told me how contractors had mistreated civilians in ways both big and small and never held accountable. Their sense of injustice was palpable. A few months later, negotiations aimed at keeping U.S. troops in Iraq fell apart because the Iraqis – embittered by Nisoor Square and similar incidents – were unwilling to grant immunity to American troops. In Afghanistan, President Karzai has repeatedly tried to banish foreign security companies.
And of course, absent any civil or criminal sanctions, nothing prevents governments from awarding new contracts to companies accused of violating human rights. Even the promise of cost savings through privatization rings hollow. Estimates are that the American government lost between $31 and $60 billion through contractor waste and fraud in Iraq and Afghanistan.

There has been some notable reform. The past two National Defense Authorization Acts passed by the U.S. Congress contained tighter fiscal controls. Contractors supporting the U.S. Defense Department now fall under criminal jurisdiction. Switzerland is considering a new law on private military and security companies. South Africa has long had such a law.

Yet much more is required, and not just for security contractors working for the U.S., but those hired by other nations as well. These firms – many based in the U.S. or Western Europe – operate like any business. If the market dries up in Iraq or Afghanistan, they move to the U.A.E. or Sudan. Col. Gaddafi reportedly tried to engage a private company to smuggle him out of Libya. Tottering regimes may resort to contractors when the military is either unable or unwilling to suppress civilian unrest. Nations where these companies are based will suffer incalculable damage should contractors add to their record of human rights abuses in the volatile context of the Arab Spring.

Throughout history, the use of private military and security contractors has ebbed and flowed. For much of the modern era, their use was deemed unacceptable. But the U.S. revived contractors’ legitimacy during the Iraq war and the industry has grown exponentially. Today, the contractor issue is transnational, and requires a transnational solution. Companies easily change headquarters, names, and corporate forms. They recruit from around the world and operate around the world. No one country can regulate this business.

The United Nations Working Group on Mercenaries has developed a new treaty that would ban contractors from core military functions. All nations would be required to license and register contractors. Every country would have to establish jurisdiction over them and pledge to prosecute when they commit serious crimes. A modest international body would oversee these efforts. While by no means a panacea, this pact would increase oversight of military and security companies and put an end to their de facto impunity.

Multi-lateral treaties are not popular these days. Indeed, some countries that are home to military and security contractors oppose this reform. However, the stakes are too high to cling to ritual recalcitrance. It is time to seriously engage in the global effort to bring the rule of law to these new actors in the world’s conflicts.

Ms. Faiza Patel chairs the UN Working Group on the use of mercenaries as a means of violating human rights and impeding the exercise of the right of peoples to self-determination.

********

The Working Group on the use of mercenaries as a means of violating human rights and impeding the exercise of the right of peoples to self-determination was established in 2005 by the then Commission on Human Rights. It is composed of five independent experts serving in their personal capacities: Ms. Faiza Patel (Chair-Rapporteur, Pakistan), Ms. Patricia Arias (Chile), Ms. Elzbieta Karska (Poland) and Mr. Anton Katz (South Africa) and Mr. Gabor Rona (United States/Hungary). Learn more, log on to: http://www2.ohchr.org/english/issues/mercenaries/index.htm

UN Human Rights, follow us on social media:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/unitednationshumanrights
Twitter:
http://twitter.com/UNrightswire
Google+ gplus.to/unitednationshumanrights
YouTube:
http://www.youtube.com/UNOHCHR

Check the Universal Human Rights Index: http://uhri.ohchr.org/en

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
World Headlines

 

Breaking: Israel Shelling Beit Hanoun Hospital

The Israeli military have started to shell and shoot at Beit Hanoun hospital. There are still 61 medical staff and civilians, three patients and two International Solidarity Movement volunteers trapped inside. More>>

UN: Urgent Action To End Female Genital Mutilation UN: Urgent Action To End Female Genital Mutilation

New UN data shows need for urgent action to end female genital mutilation, child marriage More>>

World News: SRI LANKA: Justice Denied To Two Child Victims Of Rape
There have been reports of an alleged abduction and rape of an eleven-year-old girl by a group of Navy officers, and of another nine-year-old girl treated in a similar manner. More>>

‘Global Epidemic’ Of Anti-Semitism NGO Urges UN To Condemn ‘global Epidemic’ Of Anti-Semitism

French riot police officers face rioters in Sarcelles, a suburb north of Paris, on July 20, 2014. More>>


IDF Falsifies Photograph To Justify Bombing El-Wafa Hospital IDF Falsifies Photograph To Justify Bombing El-Wafa Hospital

On the 21st July at 2:17 PM, the IDF spokesperson released an image on twitter showing an aerial picture of a building marked as ‘Al-Wafa’ hospital. In the image there is a red circle, which they designated as the location from which a M75 rocket was ... More>>

MH17: Black Boxes Recovered by Malaysian Government

'Following the agreement Prime Minister Najib Razak brokered with rebel leaders, Malaysia has taken custody of flight MH17's black boxes. As the Prime Minister said, they will be passed to the international investigation team for analysis. More>>

ALSO:


Gaza Update On 15th Day Of The Israeli Offensive

Dozens of Palestinian Civilians Killed or Wounded as Israeli Forces Attack Apartment Buildings, Mosques, Hospitals and Schools; White Phosphorous Bombs and Flechette Shells Fired by Israeli Forces in Border Areas... More>>

Al Jazeera: Egypt Verdict Defies Logic And Any Semblance Of Justice

Following today’s verdict in Cairo, Al Jazeera English managing director Al Anstey said: “Today three colleagues and friends were sentenced, and will continue behind bars for doing a brilliant job of being great journalists. More>>


Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
World
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news