World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search

 


India: Human trafficking, not diplomatic impunity

AHRC-STM-013-2014
January 13, 2014

A Statement from the Asian Human Rights Commission

The debates so far, concerning the arrest of an Indian diplomat in the US, on charges of visa fraud, have omitted the nature of the crime the officer has committed. The crime alleged against the officer, is that of furnishing false documents to obtain visa for a migrant labour to the US. Read with the complaint made by the officer's domestic maid - the migrant labour brought to the US - the offense would amount to human trafficking.

The response by the Government of India, in support of its officer aboard, could at best be viewed as a resonation of the privileged Indian philosophy, one that always seeks to claim privilege against equality before law. When the law draws no exceptions for an accused, irrespective of the class and status the accused enjoys in private and official life, the Indian elite often claims unfairness.

An Indian elite arrested, held during pre-trail detention with others having similar legal status (accused and arrested of crimes), and having to undergo procedures set forth for those held in pre-trial detention is an exception in India. In countries where law-enforcement, generally, doesn't discriminate according to social status, things differ.

It is the lack of appreciation for equality before law, a concept seldom practiced in India, which has reflected in the Government of India's response to the arrest of its officer in the US. The Indian media's response is equal to that of the Government. No talking head or news outlet highlighted the serious nature of the crime the officer is accused of, one involving human trafficking. This despite many Indian editors having pledged their support to prevent the crime of human trafficking in the region. Is the Indian media simply unaware that importing migrant labour with an intent to pay wages lower than the statutory minimum wage, thereby exploiting the vulnerability of an 'imported domestic maid', is, in fact, human trafficking? What disconnects the dots?

India has ratified the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised Crime on 5 May 2011. However, the Government of India's position concerning the diplomat's case is that "the maid" in question had "signed voluntarily" an employment contract, for a lower rate of wages and therefore the case would not be one of human trafficking.

The problem with this position is that law prohibits contracting out. In addition, it has placed the accused officer in a precarious position of having to prove her onus in getting her maid to sign an employment contract that the officer knew would violate US law.

Further, the government's position confirms the charge against the officer – that the officer did, in fact, file visa papers in the US knowing that the content is false. To say the least, the Government of India's position, intended to save its officer accused of visa fraud and human trafficking, would corroborate the charge against the officer. One may only feel sorry for the quality of legal advice the government has received in this case.

Worse still is the Minster for External Affairs' promise to the Indian parliament, that he would not return to the House, without settling the case with authorities in the US. This underlines the minister's disrespect for the country's obligation under international law to prevent human trafficking and the belief that his office can threaten and bully the process of law in other jurisdictions. What the minister negated through his assurance in Parliament is his constitutional promise that his office will uphold the rule of law at all costs. Unfortunately, the parliamentarians applauded the Minister's promise to violate the law in India and his avowed attempt try and force an alien jurisdiction to do the same.

The Government of India's subsequent act, to assign the officer charged with the crime in the US to India's permanent mission at the United Nations in New York, is the most dismal of actions linked to this controversy. It not only reduces India's stature among the member states at the UN, but also strengthens allegations against India that its participation at the UN is often limited to window dressing. At the very least, India should not have joined the infamous league of states that use the UN as a repository of diplomats charged with serious crimes.

The officer in question has left the US after being ordered to leave the country by the US government, following the Government of India's refusal to revoke the officer's diplomatic immunity to allow the US government to prosecute the officer. The US government, for its part, understands such a 'diplomatic spat' quite well. It has also resorted to such crude behaviour when its own officers, or US citizens contracted by the US government, have been charged with crimes outside the US.

In the Raymond Allen Davis incident, the US government not only claimed that one of its defence contractors, charged for murder in Pakistan, enjoys full immunity – a tactic that failed to appease the Government of Pakistan. The US government also paid USD $ 2.4 million to the victims' families and helped relocate some of the family members of those murdered, thereby subverting all processes of civilized law in a case of murder.

Forcing the Indian diplomat out of the US implies that the prosecution against the officer in the US will be in abeyance. Perhaps this was the best way out for the US – to drop the persecution against the officer and still pretend it has not subverted its own rule of law framework, budging to pressure from an alien government.

Equality before law is, however, a universal concept. It is not something for selective application, to protect privileged US or Indian citizens. And, it is not a punishment.

It is guaranteed in the Indian Constitution too. The country and its people would have had a great cause to hold their head high in esteem, had the government chosen to allow the criminal case to proceed, as the rule of law warrants.

Unfortunately, the Indian government has chose to use its infamous influence to protract the law from taking its course. It has chosen not to protect the equally important rights of yet another Indian, who, albeit poor, has approached US authorities with a complaint of having been duped and trafficked into the US.

The Government of India's actions, so far, reiterate that the country and its system serves the privileged and that there are two categories of citizens in the country: one that the government serves, the other that doesn't exist.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
World Headlines

 

Myanmar Election: UNICEF Urges Prioritisation Of Children

With 99 days to go before Myanmar elections, UNICEF urges candidates make children the clear winner More>>

Liberia Thousands Of Unregistered Children Born During Ebola Crisis

Thousands of unregistered children born in Liberia during Ebola crisis at risk of exploitation – UNICEF More>>

UN Refugee Agency Envoy Angelina Jolie Visits Myanmar

UNHCR Special Envoy Angelina Jolie Pitt (left) in Myitkyina township, Kachin State, Myanmar, meeting with some of the 100,000 displaced people who currently live there. Photo: UNHCR/T.Stoddart More>>

As Health Needs Rise In Somalia, Funding Hits New Low

As health needs rise in Somalia, funding hits new low, cutting off 1.5 million from care – UN More>>

Need To End Violence Against Children In Conflict

‘We should be outraged’ more not being done to end violence against children in conflict – UNICEF chief More>>

On Mandela Day, UN Joins Call To Promote Community Service

Nelson Mandela, then Deputy President of the African National Congress of South Africa, raises his fist in the air while addressing the Special Committee Against Apartheid in the General Assembly Hall. UN Photo/P. Sudhakaran More>>

Some $3.2 Billion Needed For Ebola Recovery Efforts

Some $3.2 billion needed for Ebola recovery efforts in Guinea, Liberia and Sierra Leone – UN More>>

World Day: UN Spotlights Plight Of Vulnerable Populalations

Syrian refugees fleeing the fighting near the Syrian city of Kobani wait in a holding area before boarding buses in Turkey (September 2014). Photo: UNHCR /I. Prickett More>>

Afghanisatan: Direct Talks Between Government And Taliban

The United Nations Security Council has welcomed the recently held direct talks between Afghan Government and Taliban representatives as a step towards “peace and reconciliation” in the region. More>>

Eradicating World Hunger By 2030

Agriculture workers collect carrots on a farm in Chimaltenango, Guatemala. Photo: World Bank/Maria Fleischmann More>>

Bangladesh: Flood Leads To UN Agency Providing Food Relief

Anwar Hossain unloads cartons of High Energy Biscuits from a pickup truck and transfers them to a distribution center in Kawar Khop union, Ramu upazila, Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. Photo: WFP/Kamrul Mithon More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
World
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news