World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search

 


Donziger, Ecuadorians File Motion to Stay Judge's Decision

Donziger, Ecuadorians File Emergency Motion to Stay Judge Kaplan’s RICO Decision

NEW YORK, Mar. 18 /CSRwire/ - Saying the decision in Chevron’s RICO case is without legal precedent, New York Attorney Steven Donziger and two Ecuadorian villagers today filed papers with Judge Lewis A. Kaplan seeking to stay his decision granting an injunction and other remedies to Chevron after it was hit with a $9.5 billion judgment in Ecuador for deliberately dumping toxic waste into the rainforest.

The papers, filed by Donziger’s lead appellate attorney Deepak Gupta, argue that Judge Kaplan’s decision is highly likely to be thrown out on appeal and will cause “irreparable harm” if not stayed pending the appeals process, which can sometimes take two years or more.

The papers, which can be read here, argue that Judge Kaplan’s RICO decision “seeks to preemptively undermine the judicial decree of a foreign sovereign nation and, in so doing, to let Chevron Corporation off the hook for decades of deliberate pollution in the Amazon rainforest.” The brief adds: “Along the way, it sidesteps jurisdictional hurdles, runs afoul of fundamental norms of international comity, and contravenes multiple decisions of the Second Circuit arising out of this same long-running controversy.”

“It is unlikely to survive appeal. And there is no question,” the papers argue, “that it will cause irreparable harm to the defendants and others if it is allowed to go into effect before the Second Circuit has had an opportunity to review it.”

The filing for a stay is the first step to kicking off what Gupta hopes will be a searching appellate review process. “It is now time for the appellate court to weigh in on these critical legal issues, which affect the well-being of thousands of rainforest villagers suffering from the effects of Chevron’s pollution in the Amazon,” said Gupta.

“The more our legal team analyzes this 500-page decision, it becomes increasingly clear that it will not stand up on appeal,” said Karen Hinton, a spokesperson for Donziger.

For more detail on the problems with Judge Kaplan’s decision, see this background memo released on the day of his decision and this updated analysis released today.

Donziger has argued that Judge Kaplan lacked jurisdiction over him once Chevron dropped all money damages claims on the eve of trial, given that an injunction (as opposed to money) would not remedy an actual injury caused to Chevron; that Judge Kaplan’s decision violates previous orders from a federal appellate court barring him from ruling on the validity of the Ecuadorian judgment; that the decision violates international comity, in that it deems Ecuador’s entire judicial system unworthy of international respect; and that Donziger himself faces “irreparable harm” by being forced to turn over to Chevron shares in a company that was set up to administer recovery funds, thereby depriving him of his ability to earn a living.

Gupta suggested to Judge Kaplan that if he plans to deny the request for a stay, that he do so “promptly” so that a three-judge panel from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals (which oversees Kaplan’s court) can take up the issue. The papers also ask Judge Kaplan to issue a “temporary administrative stay of the judgment” pending resolution by the Court of Appeals.

Judge Kaplan already has been reversed once in the case when he tried to issue an unprecedented injunction blocking the Ecuadorians from enforcing their judgment anywhere in the world. The latest motion argues that Judge Kaplan’s more recent injunction in practice does the same thing, even though it uses different language.

Donziger repeatedly has said he did not receive a fair trial in Judge Kaplan’s courtroom; his former counsel, the renowned trial lawyer John Keker, accused Judge Kaplan of letting the case “degenerate into a Dickensian farce”. For background on Judge Kaplan’s bias as explained in various legal petitions, see here, here, and here.

Today’s stay motion represents the first appearance in the case from John Campbell and Justin Marceau, two law professors at the University of Denver who are teaching a special course built around Donziger’s appeal. Nine students in the class are carrying out research assignments for the legal team.

Donziger said the filing of the papers is “an important first step” in having Judge Kaplan’s decision reviewed by new judges.

“It is our belief that Judge Kaplan’s decision is wrong on the law, wrong on the facts, and resulted from a skewed legal proceeding that violated the due process rights of the defendants,” said Donziger.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
World Headlines

 

South Sudan: UN Agencies Reach More Than Half A Million

South Sudan: UN Agencies Reach More than Half a Million People with Life-Saving Aid More>>

Israeli Plans To Expand Its Illegal Settlement Enterprises

PLO Executive Committee member, Dr. Hanan Ashrawi, strongly denounced Israeli plans to expand its illegal settlement enterprise by approving the construction of 2,561 units in the settlement of Givat Hamatos. More>>

ALSO:

Ecuador: Villagers Plan To Seize Chevron's $106M Arbitral Award

QUITO, ECUADOR, Sep. 30 /CSRwire/ - In what could be a huge boost to their campaign to force Chevron to comply with a $9.5 billion environmental judgment in Ecuador, rainforest villagers plan to enforce a court order directing them to take possession ... More>>

World Grossly Ill-Prepared To Deal Ebola Outbreak

Leaders from Sierra Leone and Liberia, the two countries, along with Guinea at the frontlines of the battle against the unprecedented Ebola outbreak in West Africa, urged the General Assembly today ensure the United Nations mounted a stronger, better coordinated response “to end this grave threat to our collective survival.”More>>

ALSO:

  • Save The Children - Save the Children Builds Its First Ebola Treatment Centre


  • Israel’s Netanyahu Warns Against ‘Militant Islam’

    29 September 2014 – From the podium of the General Assembly today Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned the world of the grave threat he said it faced from militant Islam’s desire to dominate the planet, be they Sunni extremists or ... More>>

    Deputy PM of Syria Victims Of ISIL Brutality 'Waiting On Us To Act'

    As the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) militant began carrying their slaughter in the Middle East, “they might have surprised many of the countries present here, but not…us,” the Deputy Prime Minister of Syria told the United Nations General Assembly, underscoring today that the time has come for the world to stand united and tackle the threat head-on.More>>

    Not A Single Child Untouched By Recent Gaza Conflict

    There is not a single child who has not been adversely affected by the recent conflict in Gaza, where children suffer from bedwetting, difficulties in sleeping, nightmares, a loss of appetite, and display more aggressive behaviour at school, an independent United Nations human rights expert said todayMore>>


    Ebola: UN Readies To Start Work As Death Toll Surpasses 3,000

    Ebola response: medical supplies, including protective equipment and essential medicine, are loaded onto trucks at the Lungi International Airport in Freetown, capital of Sierra Leone. Photo: UNICEF/Sulaiman Stephens More>>

    Get More From Scoop

     
     
     
     
     
    World
    Search Scoop  
     
     
    Powered by Vodafone
    NZ independent news