World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search

 


Judicial Dignity No Excuse for Muzzling Freedom of Speech

NEPAL: Upholding Judicial Dignity No Excuse for Muzzling Freedom of Expression

July 2, 2014

The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) objects to the Contempt of Court Bill, which the government has tabled in Parliament on 9 June 2014. The Bill, if passed, will restrict freedom of expression and the freedom of the press. The Bill, while purporting to uphold judicial dignity, curtails individual freedom enshrined in Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and Article 12 (A) and 15 (1) of Nepal's Interim Constitution, 2007.

Article 3 and Article 4 of the proposed bill have questionable provisions. The Article 4, which defines contempt of court, is unclear. Terms like 'defamatory', 'malicious', 'false', and 'confusing' are not defined. This ambiguity can allow the court to arbitrarily interpret and misuse such terms and level charges against journalists and citizens who may have legitimate criticisms against judges and their decisions.

Contempt of court should be used when hurdles are created in the working of the court. But court orders themselves must be in accord with law. If court orders are themselves unlawful, it is not contempt of court to seek legal remedies. On the other hand, analyzing a decision of the court in a healthy manner and honorably disagreeing with the court should not be considered contempt of court.

As per the Bill, the bench, which has suffered the alleged contempt, has the right to pass judgment in the contempt case. Both the offended party and the adjudicator being the same person or body is something that infringes the separation of powers principle. If the same judges will be both the offended party and the adjudicators, contempt of court risks becoming a ruse for judges to settle personal vendettas.

Furthermore, the process of introducing the Bill in Parliament has been secretive. This is unfortunate, as Nepal needs a law to safeguard the independence of the judiciary, and lack of stakeholder consultation and public discussion can only make citizens suspect the motivations of the Executive and the Judiciary.

As this Bill impacts the freedom of the press, the freedom of expression and opinion, and the right to information law, it should have been prepared through a consultative process in a balanced manner. Contempt of court is aimed at safeguarding the independence of the judiciary. But care needs to be taken that it does not arrive with a heavy price for media and individual freedom.

The Nepal Judiciary, and especially the Supreme Court (SC), has had a fragile relationship with the Nepali media. This was evident in the criticism of judges recently appointed to the SC. Certain media reports had questioned the appointments in light of the controversial records of the appointees. If the government's motive behind introducing this law is, in fact, to curb legitimate criticism, the effect on society will be severe; democracy will be stalled without media being able to serve as watchdog.

The trend has been of the Nepal government enacting restrictive laws to curtail individual freedoms and using security agencies to intimidate those courageous enough to criticize the powerful. The cases of Raju Sah from Bara district and Abdul Rehman from Saptari district are two examples. Sah was arrested last month for posting an angry comment on Facebook over a widely shared photo of Home Minister Bamdev Gautam stepping over a divider in the middle of the street while holding up traffic. "He should be shot in the back", commented Sah on Facebook. Rehman, on the other hand, was arrested and detained for 20 days simply for making a comment on a news report indicating improved security in Saptari district. "How is security improving when I have to pay NRs. 50,000 simply to get back my own motorbike that had been stolen?" questioned Rehman. He was booked under the Electronic Transactions Act (ETA) for cyber crime and brought to the Kathmandu District Court to be prosecuted. Rehman is currently on bail.

When powerful politicians make a mockery of court judgments that is contempt. Balkrishna Dhungel, for instance, is someone who has been convicted of murder and sentenced to life imprisonment, in addition to the Court ruling that his property be confiscated. However, he roams free. The executive and judiciary have been unable and unwilling to incarcerate him. This indignity goes unmentioned. However, legitimate questions in the media about publicly relevant facts related to newly appointed judges have met judicial ire.

The judiciary is a vital organ of the state; it must be treated with dignity and respect. But fundamental rights cannot be taken away in the name of protecting the dignity of courts. Respect for the freedom of expression and media freedom as enshrined in the UDHR, ICCPR, and the Interim Constitution of Nepal itself needs consideration. The government may wish to consider withholding passage of the bill, until wide consultations with stakeholders are held.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
World Headlines

 

West Papua: “Lest We Forget”

AS Anzac approaches and Australians and New Zealanders remember those who fought and lost their lives on Anzac Day, it is hoped we will also remember the unfree people of the Pacific region and in particular those who are still suffering from human ... More>>

Iran: 81 Executions In One Week

Coincident with mass executions in the prisons of Ghezel-Hessar, Karaj and other cities, the anti-human regime of mullahs sent 16 other prisoners to the gallows in Mashhad and Birjand (northeastern Iran). Twelve of them were hanged collectively ... More>>

Al-Shabaab: Four Unicef Staff Killed In Somalia

Four UNICEF staff members have been killed in an attack on their vehicle in Garowe, Somalia. Four other UNICEF colleagues are in a serious condition. The IED (improvised explosive device) attack occurred when the staff were travelling from their guest ... More>>

UN: Suicide Attack In Jalalabad Condemned

NEW YORK/KABUL/GENEVA (18April 2015) – “I strongly condemn the brutal suicide attack that coincided with my visit to Jalalabad today,” said United Nations Assistant Secretary-General for Human Rights Ivan Šimonović during his visit to Afghanistan. ... More>>

Save The Children: STC Urges EU Leaders To Act To Prevent More Mass Drownings

Save the Children Urges EU Leaders to Act to Prevent More Mass Drownings at Sea. More>>

ALSO:

Japan: Independent Experts Slam Japan’s New Whaling Plan

Independent experts slam Japan’s new whaling plan and declare no more whales need to be killed for Antarctic research More>>

Gaza Strip: Attacks In The Border Areas

Following disengagement from the Gaza Strip in September 2005, Israel unilaterally and illegally established a so-called “buffer zone”, an area prohibited to Palestinians along the land and sea borders of the Gaza Strip. The precise area designated by ... More>>

Australian Government: Iraq Deployment: Joint Press Conference, Canberra

Back in March, the Government announced that we were preparing a force for a Building Partner Capacity training mission in Iraq. I can inform you that today the Cabinet has decided to deploy that force. The deployment will start tomorrow and we expect ... More>>

UNHRC: UN Committee Against Torture To Review New Zealand

UN Committee against torture to review New Zealand, Congo, Romania, Luxembourg, Spain, Serbia, Colombia, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia More>>

UNHRC: Nigeria: One Year On, Call To Bring Back Abducted Children

Nigeria: One year on, UN and African experts call for decisive steps to bring back abducted children More>>

EU & US Let Iran Win Top Seat On UN Women’s Rights Board

EU & US Allowed Iran to Win Top Seat on UN Women’s Rights Board, Rights Group Says More>>

Peaceful Tree Planting Attacked By Zionist Settlers/soldiers

Peaceful tree planting attacked by zionist settlers and soldiers, two Palestinians hospitalised and a German activist arrested. More>>

Get More From Scoop

 
 
 
 
 
World
Search Scoop  
 
 
Powered by Vodafone
NZ independent news