World Video | Defence | Foreign Affairs | Natural Events | Trade | NZ in World News | NZ National News Video | NZ Regional News | Search

 


Israel: Loss of Protection for Civilian Objects

23 July 2014

Loss of Protection for Civilian Objects (Mosques, Schools, and Hospitals etc.)

A core principle of the law of armed conflict is the 'principle of distinction' - the obligation imposed on each party to a conflict to ensure at all times that a distinction is made between combatants and civilians. This principle is reflected in Article 48 to the Additional Protocol I of the Geneva Conventions:

In order to ensure respect for and protection of the civilian population and civilian objects, the Parties to the conflict shall at all times distinguish between the civilian population and combatants and between civilian objects and military objectives and accordingly shall direct their operations only against military objectives.

One of the first and foremost inferences from the principle of distinction is that, "…civilian objects shall not be the object of attack or of reprisals “ i.e., deliberate attacks against civilian objects are generally forbidden.

However, when a civilian object such as a mosque, a school, a hospital and the like is used for military purposes including as a command center; as a site for firing weaponry and launching rockets; as a place to conceal and store weapons, they are no longer considered to be civilian objects and thus lose their protections and become legitimate military objects which may be the target of an attack.

Whether an object is considered civilian, and thus granted protection against attack, or a legitimate military object, is determined not by its intrinsic function but rather if its "nature, location purpose or use make an effective contribution to military action."[ii] As stipulated by the International Committee of the Red Cross Commentary, military action may be comprised of:

… all objects directly used by the armed forces: weapons, equipment, transports, fortifications, depots, buildings occupied by armed forces, staff headquarters, communications centers etc.

In the recent Protective Edge operation we have witnessed Hamas commandeer otherwise civilian sites – schools, UN infrastructure, hospitals, private homes, mosques – and use them for military purposes, including for weapons storage; the establishment of command and control centers and for the firing of weapons and launching of rockets. Those civilian objects which are used by Hamas for military purposes lose their protection and turn into legitimate military objects.

As international law expert Prof. Yoram Dinstein noted:

Certain objects are by nature dedicated to civilian purposes: the templates are places of worship, civilian dwellings, schools and hospitals. As long as they fulfill their normal functions such objects must not be considered military objects. Still in the fluctuations that occur during combat, civilian objects may be used (or more precisely abused) by the enemy- contrary to the normal function- in a manner making an effective contribution to military action. If and when that is the case, even churches and hospitals become military objectives.

ENDS

© Scoop Media

 
 
 
 
 
World Headlines

 

MSF: Ebola Crisis Update - 16th October 2014

16 October 2014 Cases Deaths Guinea 1,472 843 Liberia 4,249 2,458 Nigeria 20 8 Sierra Leone 3,252 1,183 Senegal 1 0 Total 8,994 4,492 WHO Figures - Data are based on official information reported by Ministries of Health. These numbers are subject to change ... More>>

ALSO:

Detroit: City-Backed Water Shut-Offs Contrary To Human Rights

20 October 2014 – The city of Detroit must restore access to water for its citizens who remain unable to pay their bills, two United Nations experts urged today, adding that a failure to do so would be a violation of the most basic human rights of those ... More>>

ALSO:

DR Congo: Head Of UN Mission Condemns Deadly Rebel Attacks

A MONUSCO APC is greeted by FARDC soldiers on their way back from the front line in the Beni region of the DRC where the UN is backing the FARDC in an operation against ADF militia. Photo: MONUSCO/Sylvain Liechti More>>

UNESCO Chief Denounces Killing Of Cambodian Journalist

17 October 2014 – The head of the United Nations agency tasked with defending press freedom today denounced the killing of a Cambodian reporter shot while investigating illegal logging in the eastern part of the country. More>>


UN Lauds Role Of Family Farmers In Ending Global Hunger

A farmer at work in a dragon fruit field in Viet Nam (July 2013). Photo: FAO/Hoang Dinh Nam | See more photos More>>


Funding Gap Looms Amid Efforts To Tackle Ebola & ISIS

Funding Gap Looms Amid Efforts to Tackle ‘Twin Plagues’ Ebola, ISIL, Warns UN Rights Chief More>>

ALSO:

  • The White House - Ebola: What You Need to Know

  • Egypt Sentences Another Al Jazeera Journalist

    In another disturbing move against freedom of speech and independent journalism in Egypt, one of Al Jazeera Arabic channel’s presenters, Ahmed Mansour, has been sentenced in absentia to fifteen years imprisonment by Cairo’s criminal court on the absurd ... More>>

    ISIL Advance On Iraqi Town Unleash New Flood Of Displacement

    Syrian Kurds from the town of Kobane seeking shelter in Iraq's Kurdistan region. Photo: UNHCR/D. Nahr More>>

    ALSO:

  • U.S. Department of State - U.S. Condemns ISIL Attacks in Iraq

  • Get More From Scoop

     
     
     
     
     
    World
    Search Scoop  
     
     
    Powered by Vodafone
    NZ independent news